Never mind VAT on Jaffa Cakes - this excise duty case takes the biscuit!
HMRC's case essentially says that soup, custard and anything less than solid is not a foodstuff! I hope that caught the attention. The appellant won.
The appellant, Gourmet Classic, is a long-standing client - I helped set up an excise warehouse to receive alcohol (mainly wine) under duty suspension for reduction of alcohol and seasoning for wholesale distribution as cooking wine for use in commercial kitchens. Under Alcohol Ingredients Relief (AIR) such a product was accepted by HMCE to be an eligible product for excise duty relief (by remission) when the low strength wine was produced, so no duty passed on to customers. HMRC reneged on this in 2017 and asserted that duty would be due. I got involved in the fight which finally ended up with HMRC issuing a £multi-million assessment (with penalties in the wings). This went to appeal last month - the decision very quickly released. Link: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKFTT/TC...09440.html
The basic law, which I worked to implement and run in HMCE in 1991 provides that duty is relieved on foodstuff where there is no more than 5 litres pure alcohol to 100kg of final product. HMRC's case at the final iteration is that only solid foodstuff is eligible for the relief. This came as news to me because when I ran policy on this regime, there was never any thought that the relief was intended only for solids. Indeed, I set up the trade facility excise warehouse policy designation specifically to enable several soup manufacturers to get the relief on wine used in making their soups (Better cash-flow than paying the duty and reclaiming it).
In the case of the culinary wine, of course it is a foodstuff - it is not a beverage and, moreover, there is no risk of abuse or duty evasion given the nature of the product. The logic of HMRC's argument leads to (a) how "gloopy" does the product have to be for AIR and (b) that each such case has to be tested individually to test that gloopiness. What loopiness! Probably another one that will be reported in the media.
HMRC's case essentially says that soup, custard and anything less than solid is not a foodstuff! I hope that caught the attention. The appellant won.
The appellant, Gourmet Classic, is a long-standing client - I helped set up an excise warehouse to receive alcohol (mainly wine) under duty suspension for reduction of alcohol and seasoning for wholesale distribution as cooking wine for use in commercial kitchens. Under Alcohol Ingredients Relief (AIR) such a product was accepted by HMCE to be an eligible product for excise duty relief (by remission) when the low strength wine was produced, so no duty passed on to customers. HMRC reneged on this in 2017 and asserted that duty would be due. I got involved in the fight which finally ended up with HMRC issuing a £multi-million assessment (with penalties in the wings). This went to appeal last month - the decision very quickly released. Link: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKFTT/TC...09440.html
The basic law, which I worked to implement and run in HMCE in 1991 provides that duty is relieved on foodstuff where there is no more than 5 litres pure alcohol to 100kg of final product. HMRC's case at the final iteration is that only solid foodstuff is eligible for the relief. This came as news to me because when I ran policy on this regime, there was never any thought that the relief was intended only for solids. Indeed, I set up the trade facility excise warehouse policy designation specifically to enable several soup manufacturers to get the relief on wine used in making their soups (Better cash-flow than paying the duty and reclaiming it).
In the case of the culinary wine, of course it is a foodstuff - it is not a beverage and, moreover, there is no risk of abuse or duty evasion given the nature of the product. The logic of HMRC's argument leads to (a) how "gloopy" does the product have to be for AIR and (b) that each such case has to be tested individually to test that gloopiness. What loopiness! Probably another one that will be reported in the media.

