Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(06-07-2022, 02:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-07-2022, 12:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 11:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-07-2022, 08:28 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And I'm not exactly a fan of any PM or government since Lloyd George, and even he was extremely flawed.
Jesus, you have a very high bar for #leastworst don't you? 
Least worst is a fallacy.
Least worst is the outcome of every democratic election ever, anywhere.
No it isn't, especially in a country like the UK which has a voting system that is fundamentally undemocratic and is the last vestige of opposition to the 1832 reform act.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
06-07-2022, 04:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-07-2022, 04:13 PM by Pontificator.)
(06-07-2022, 02:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 02:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-07-2022, 12:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 11:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-07-2022, 08:28 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And I'm not exactly a fan of any PM or government since Lloyd George, and even he was extremely flawed.
Jesus, you have a very high bar for #leastworst don't you? 
Least worst is a fallacy.
Least worst is the outcome of every democratic election ever, anywhere.
No it isn't, especially in a country like the UK which has a voting system that is fundamentally undemocratic and is the last vestige of opposition to the 1832 reform act.
What is democracy? Your view of it, mine, anyone else? Weve got a system and it is our form of democracy. If you want rid of the Tories vote Labour in England, Wales and Scotland. PR would be a disaster for the Labour Party and a Labour majority would be impossible. The great reforms Labour governments made over the decades may never have happened under PR. It would spell the end of the Labour Party as it is now.
(06-07-2022, 04:07 PM)Pontificator Wrote: (06-07-2022, 02:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 02:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-07-2022, 12:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 11:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Jesus, you have a very high bar for #leastworst don't you? 
Least worst is a fallacy.
Least worst is the outcome of every democratic election ever, anywhere.
No it isn't, especially in a country like the UK which has a voting system that is fundamentally undemocratic and is the last vestige of opposition to the 1832 reform act.
What is democracy? Your view of it, mine, anyone else? Weve got a system and it is our form of democracy. If you want rid of the Tories vote Labour in England, Wales and Scotland. PR would be a disaster for the Labour Party and a Labour majority would be impossible. The great reforms Labour governments made over the decades may never have happened under PR. It would spell the end of the Labour Party as it is now.
The members of the Labour Party who proselytise for PR can't see further than their noses, why would you want to weaken the party? - Turkeys Christmas
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
06-07-2022, 04:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-07-2022, 04:46 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(06-07-2022, 04:07 PM)Pontificator Wrote: What is democracy? Your view of it, mine, anyone else? Weve got a system and it is our form of democracy. If you want rid of the Tories vote Labour in England, Wales and Scotland. PR would be a disaster for the Labour Party and a Labour majority would be impossible. The great reforms Labour governments made over the decades may never have happened under PR. It would spell the end of the Labour Party as it is now.
The members of the Labour Party who proselytise for PR can't see further than their noses, why would you want to weaken the party? - Turkeys Christmas
I am not a member nor a supporter of the Labour Party, I do not care about the Labour Party as it exists now or has it has done in the past, I have never voted Labour at any level. I do not want a Labour majority government as I do not trust the Labour Party. Labour are never going to represent my constituency and voting for them ensures that my Tory MP stays in, so I see no reason to tactically vote for them where I am.
What I want is a political system that makes big-tent parties redundant and ensures governments are formed based on a majority, not a plurality, as any government that does not represent a majority of the vote is undemocratic, on top of wanting an electoral system that allows for genuine electoral accountability which FPTP fails at. If we lived in a world where the Tories and Labour were the only two options I probably wouldn't vote.
I also find defences of our current system as being "our democracy" and a "British democracy" as spurious. University constituencies were part of our democracy, until they weren't. Rotten boroughs were part of our democracy, until they weren't. Public voting was a part of our democracy, until it wasn't. Plural voting was a part of our democracy, until it wasn't. Etc, etc, etc. The issues and limitations of FPTP were known in the 1910s and accepted by the government over 100 years ago and was supposed to be replaced until the Tories lied and broke a promise on voting reform, STV was specifically designed to work with UK parliamentary systems. Our voting system isn't static and using a voting system that is undemocratic and was conceived in the 14th century when our parliamentary system is completely alien to those circumstances isn't sensible.
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(06-07-2022, 04:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-07-2022, 04:07 PM)Pontificator Wrote: What is democracy? Your view of it, mine, anyone else? Weve got a system and it is our form of democracy. If you want rid of the Tories vote Labour in England, Wales and Scotland. PR would be a disaster for the Labour Party and a Labour majority would be impossible. The great reforms Labour governments made over the decades may never have happened under PR. It would spell the end of the Labour Party as it is now.
The members of the Labour Party who proselytise for PR can't see further than their noses, why would you want to weaken the party? - Turkeys Christmas
I am not a member nor a supporter of the Labour Party, I do not care about the Labour Party as it exists now or has it has done in the past, I have never voted Labour at any level. I do not want a Labour majority government as I do not trust the Labour Party. Labour are never going to represent my constituency and voting for them ensures that my Tory MP stays in, so I see no reason to tactically vote for them where I am.
What I want is a political system that makes big-tent parties redundant and ensures governments are formed based on a majority, not a plurality, as any government that does not represent a majority of the vote is undemocratic, on top of wanting an electoral system that allows for genuine electoral accountability which FPTP fails at. If we lived in a world where the Tories and Labour were the only two options I probably wouldn't vote.
I also find defences of our current system as being "our democracy" and a "British democracy" as spurious. University constituencies were part of our democracy, until they weren't. Rotten boroughs were part of our democracy, until they weren't. Public voting was a part of our democracy, until it wasn't. Plural voting was a part of our democracy, until it wasn't. Etc, etc, etc. The issues and limitations of FPTP were known in the 1910s and accepted by the government over 100 years ago and was supposed to be replaced until the Tories lied and broke a promise on voting reform, STV was specifically designed to work with UK parliamentary systems. Our voting system isn't static and using a voting system that is undemocratic and was conceived in the 14th century when our parliamentary system is completely alien to those circumstances isn't sensible.
Is what it is and it's neither in the Tories or Labour's interest to consider PR so it won't happen. I don't consider it undemocratic and am not convinced looking at the Shropshire by election and the upcoming Tiverton & Honiton that voters are incapable of doing what needs to be done.
I assume you would prefer a left wing if not a Labour government rather than a Tory government, but left wing parties only ever get 50% of the vote. I can't imagine a coalition of left wing parties being anything else than a horse trading disaster ushering in a Tory government for years. The osbornnomics of austerity, was delivered by a coalition and laid the foundations for Brexit and with FPTP at least we don't get National Rally in our largely conservative country
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
PR isn't in the interest of the Labour establishment but I'd say it's very much in the interest of the Labour base as it makes it easier for the decouple the party from the hard left and makes things harder for the Tories to get into power by capitalising on the greater factionalism on the left.
I don't know whether I'd prefer a left wing government, right now I'd prefer Labour - preferably in a coalition but Johnson is that bad I'm not sure I'd mind a majority Labour government right now - but 12 years ago I wanted a Lib-Tory coalition and in 2015 I wanted a Lib-Tory coalition.
Brexit wasn't caused by just austerity, it was caused by a longstanding disconnect between government and the people (which I think has been partly caused by a lack of electoral accountability of which FPTP is part of), the lack of a pro-European spirit filtering through from dynamic parts of the country to less dynamic parts, and an unwillingness of those in charge for so many years to correct the lies and misrepresentations they fed lest they out themselves as the chancers they are. Also, and I don't think it should be forgotten, fundamentally dishonest campaigning offering everything to everyone against a fixed and known quantity.
Our current system encourages coalitions, the coalitions are just internal within the party. The Liberal Democrats formed as a party after two separate parties joined together as an effective coalition, their predecessors the Liberals had the same thing with the Peelites, Whigs and Radicals. Labour formed through a coalition of Liberal Radicals, the social democrats in the labour movement and the socialists joined together. The Tories whole schtick to keeping relevant is to continually absorb other parties.
As for extremists, the likes of the Monday Club just bury themselves in a larger party. Where do you think the UKIP lot split from in the first place and then ended back up?
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(06-07-2022, 06:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: PR isn't in the interest of the Labour establishment but I'd say it's very much in the interest of the Labour base as it makes it easier for the decouple the party from the hard left and makes things harder for the Tories to get into power by capitalising on the greater factionalism on the left.
I don't know whether I'd prefer a left wing government, right now I'd prefer Labour - preferably in a coalition but Johnson is that bad I'm not sure I'd mind a majority Labour government right now - but 12 years ago I wanted a Lib-Tory coalition and in 2015 I wanted a Lib-Tory coalition.
Brexit wasn't caused by just austerity, it was caused by a longstanding disconnect between government and the people (which I think has been partly caused by a lack of electoral accountability of which FPTP is part of), the lack of a pro-European spirit filtering through from dynamic parts of the country to less dynamic parts, and an unwillingness of those in charge for so many years to correct the lies and misrepresentations they fed lest they out themselves as the chancers they are. Also, and I don't think it should be forgotten, fundamentally dishonest campaigning offering everything to everyone against a fixed and known quantity.
Our current system encourages coalitions, the coalitions are just internal within the party. The Liberal Democrats formed as a party after two separate parties joined together as an effective coalition, their predecessors the Liberals had the same thing with the Peelites, Whigs and Radicals. Labour formed through a coalition of Liberal Radicals, the social democrats in the labour movement and the socialists joined together. The Tories whole schtick to keeping relevant is to continually absorb other parties.
As for extremists, the likes of the Monday Club just bury themselves in a larger party. Where do you think the UKIP lot split from in the first place and then ended back up?
Decoupling the party from the hard left, what does that mean? The party will always contain members who sympathise with the hard left world view. just as the conservative party will always contain members of a hard right world view. We have taken back control of the NEC and the hard left are being marginalised. This is because we stayed in the party with the intention of saving it. Keir Starmer has done more in two years than Kinnock did in many. The difference between practical politics and academic as it were! The Tory Party is the worse for the loss of those one nation Torys; Soubry, Gaulke, Grieve, Stewart etc who would have been formidable in the current situation.
The severe austerity, the ridiculous idea that the government should run a surplus, the sound money bollocks laid waste to services, growth and social cohesion and was much more the foundation of the Brexit vote as the outright lies and the poor remain campaign sabotaged by Corbyn. Never forget that Cable and Clegg and the MSM were right behind the Tories, blaming the financial crisis on labour spending for too much - lying bastards!
The ancient analysis, the narrow minded book read socialists view is interesting but largely irrelavent to the real needs of people. Johnson and Brexit changed everything. the massive task for Starmer and Labour is to offer a new economic vision. I look forward to reading what you suggest
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
06-08-2022, 12:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-08-2022, 12:13 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
Fantastic, you've marginalised the hard left. What will you do when they come back? Because they will come back. Cameron thought he'd marginalised the nationalists and populists in the Tory party, now they're running the bloody country. You're never going to decouple Labour from the hard left under FPTP because the voting system encourages big tent coalitions within parties. With PR you have an avenue to shut them out of government as per Ireland and Germany, and then after the fact you can work with them externally instead of internally on a more case-by-case basis on key issues where interests align much as you can work with social liberals.
As for austerity, did you read the 2010 Labour Party manifesto? The public sector cuts that were made between 2010 and 2015 under the coalition were in line with the proposed cuts made by Labour, don't pretend that things would have been sunshine and rainbows under Labour. Labour didn't even commit to reversing the public sector cuts in the 2015 and 2017 manifestos for crying out loud. And if you want to get into the distribution of economic growth and social cohesion, that's been a longstanding issue in this country going back to Attlee. Austerity had very little to do with that. As for a budget surplus, good government should always aim to minimise the deficit when it can - that is literally the foundation of the Nordic economies which is what I expect a good social democratic party to have as a primary economic goal.
I think it's pretty obvious what needs to happen on the economy, address wealth inequality and attempt to equalise conditions for small business so they can compete with big business.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-08-2022, 12:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I think it's pretty obvious what needs to happen on the economy, address wealth inequality and attempt to equalise conditions for small business so they can compete with big business.
It's also pretty obvious why that doesn't happen, whatever the political weather. If you want PR you should also want state-funded political parties, which will go down with the public like a bucket of tepid vomit. I'm not saying that's wrong idea. Far from it.
|