Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
fuzzbox Wrote:It doesn't help that he raised expectations by initially saying we should be looking at promotion.
It makes me wonder whether he had actually watched us before he took charge. If he didn't, why not? If I was lucky enough to get such a high profile, high paying job, I would have watched back to back football matches for at least a week before I took the job. And then carried on for another week afterwards!
(It's a shame he didn't read any of the forums before he took the job. He may have either turned it down or at least took the job a bit more seriously!)
This also makes me wonder what the interview process was like. I can't help thinking there wasn't one - maybe because they were friends? Otherwise, surely, there would be a game plan or a strategy BEFORE the first game. In essence, we lost the first few games whilst the manager was finding out the players and what didn't work and (hopefully) what might. Instead, after the first few defeats, he just said he was finding out about the players. We could have all told him that some of his setups were never going to work and frankly, he should have known that himself if he had done any research.
People talk about a 'new manager bounce' as if it's a natural phenomenon. It isn't. A new manager comes in after analysing the team and developing an approach that will make the biggest impact in the shortest possible time.
I can't help thinking that with Steve Bruce, it was more like "Hi mate, do you want the job for loads of cash". Steve then does his research with a quick check on Wikipedia, sees lots of names he has vaguely heard of and reads a few articles saying the style of football doesn't work and the players hate it. He thinks 'Why not? Problem: Pissed of quality players playing shit system. Solution: Make friends with players so they actually play, play 'normal' football and get promoted. Easy"
So, Bruce wasted 'the bounce' thinking the players would increase their levels of performance now their 'nasty manager' has gone. Now he seems shell shocked and devoid of ideas. Too late, he's realised this is actually a big job. A bit like a schoolkid who didn't do any prep for an exam, thinking he can 'wing it' and then finding out the questions weren't as easy as he thought.
Except this is a highly paid professional. Whether or not this is conjecture (as someone stated), it has such a ring of truth that I wouldn't doubt this is actually quite likely what has happened
As for the OP, Baying for Blood. Absolutely I am. I stayed off here deliberately post match and all day today, angry beyond reason. Actually no, angry with very good reason. Last night was without doubt the biggest catalogue of managerial errors I can remember at Albion. Not one or two, but virtually every decision made was ridiculous and bound to fail. But ultimately my biggest rage is that Bruce simply went for damage limitation (to his reputation) in a must win game, and still failed.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-19-2022, 06:49 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (04-19-2022, 12:43 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Except that other than for the opening sentence this is all conjecture, not fact. I fully agree though that what we’ve seen makes it plausible, but that’s still not proof that proper due diligence wasn’t followed. You could just as easily argue that despite Bruce conducting some form of analysis beforehand the squad itself is so corrupt that it is past salvaging.
You're right, it's complete conjecture.
But...If there was due diligence, well that doesn't reflect well on Bruce either. He should have tempered his expectations, expressed less shock at some of the displays and not talked about how he was just getting to know the players quite as much. None of us have met the players, but we all knew how they would behave - because we've watched them! Let's face it, none of us were surprised by any changes in form or attitude...
But even aside from that, maybe even a cogent strategy to address our very obvious weaknesses observed in the games before he arrived would have been useful. Instead, we got squads, formations and player positions that have already been tried and failed - usually for footballing reasons that we could all see. This was an unnecessary waste of games when we couldn't afford it.
FWIW, I don't think the squad is corrupt - they're just not very good and maybe, never were. Yes, almost all of them had good games, but not one of them was ever consistently above even average, much less able to sustain a run of great performances. For x sake, by the end, we were pinning all our hopes on the 'mercurial' talents of M Philips coming back and a striker who has only played the best part of an hour for us!
If that's all we have to cling to, we're obviously not very good. In fact, the only good players we have had in the last few seasons either belonged to someone else or didn't want to play for us! Thinking about it, maybe that should have been a clue of what was to come...
As I said a couple of weeks ago about when we scored 5 at Chelsea, half of the team from then have gone. We have also made no effort to replace the most creative midfielder we’d had in decades.
It’s a colossal balls up.
We’ve basically got the players not good enough for Allardyce and padded the squad out with standard championship players in Molumby, Reach and Mowatt.
Meanwhile expensive acquisitions like Grant, Diangana and Zohore are now about as valuable as a Rolf Harris painting.
It’s a mess. However, I’m going to accept it with good grace and hope we’ve learnt.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
04-19-2022, 09:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-19-2022, 09:34 PM by clem4england.)
(04-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My issue with Bruce is I've simply seen nothing from him to suggest it'll improve in any way if he stays.
Last night's team selection can only be described as either lazy or moronic I don't see that he can make massive changes to the starting XI with no window and I'm not wholly sure what I'd do differently given the lack of options in midfield and out wide.
HOWEVER, at no time has he looked like he has made any sort of improvement or progress on the pitch. I don't see any experimentation; just the same old selections that haven't previously worked. More worryingly, I see no evidence of any coaching ability and development of players and, realistically no coach gets 3-4 windows nowadays without showing some form of progress and getting a few decent results, so our way out of this is a top coach like Corboran or Jones who gets the most out of his minimal resources.
(04-19-2022, 10:58 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-19-2022, 09:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I do wonder though considering we almost all agree that the owners of the club have mishandled it appallingly since they bought it from Peace that there's an element of screaming fans who somehow expect Bruce to be a miracle worker, considering he's had no new players.
Both Gourlay and Bruce made it very clear that the expectation was promotion. You're seeking to defend someone who had made a club that was on a bad run worse, which was completely the opposite of what his remit is.
Unless they're lucky enough to be appointed just before a transfer window, new managers have to have the ability to make a difference with the players who are already at the club, rather than attempt to tread water until the next window arrives. With more than 1000 games under his belt, Bruce really ought to be able to make a difference to an existing squad.
That he hasn't made any difference at all results-wise and has made us worse in other respects has led me to believe that he shouldn't be entrusted with the summer transfer window or for us to have to put up with his bewildering team selections and lack of tactical nous in the early stages of next season. We need someone at the helm who's younger and has some oomph, charisma and guile if next season isn't to be a repeat of this one. Roy and Pulis made instant impacts. You could see exactly what they had changed and what they wanted to do. We have seen nothing like this; just some fumbling around with new selections hoping / praying we might stumble on a formula or some form.
Posts: 239
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
0
But i thought it was just a formation change?
"I will give it 6 months" - Duffers about GB News (16th June 2021) Channel is going strong
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-19-2022, 09:28 PM)clem4england Wrote: (04-19-2022, 10:26 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My issue with Bruce is I've simply seen nothing from him to suggest it'll improve in any way if he stays.
Last night's team selection can only be described as either lazy or moronic I don't see that he can make massive changes to the starting XI with no window and I'm not wholly sure what I'd do differently given the lack of options in midfield and out wide.
HOWEVER, at no time has he looked like he has made any sort of improvement or progress on the pitch. I don't see any experimentation; just the same old selections that haven't previously worked. More worryingly, I see no evidence of any coaching ability and development of players and, realistically no coach gets 3-4 windows nowadays without showing some form of progress and getting a few decent results, so our way out of this is a top coach like Corboran or Jones who gets the most out of his minimal resources.
(04-19-2022, 10:58 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-19-2022, 09:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I do wonder though considering we almost all agree that the owners of the club have mishandled it appallingly since they bought it from Peace that there's an element of screaming fans who somehow expect Bruce to be a miracle worker, considering he's had no new players.
Both Gourlay and Bruce made it very clear that the expectation was promotion. You're seeking to defend someone who had made a club that was on a bad run worse, which was completely the opposite of what his remit is.
Unless they're lucky enough to be appointed just before a transfer window, new managers have to have the ability to make a difference with the players who are already at the club, rather than attempt to tread water until the next window arrives. With more than 1000 games under his belt, Bruce really ought to be able to make a difference to an existing squad.
That he hasn't made any difference at all results-wise and has made us worse in other respects has led me to believe that he shouldn't be entrusted with the summer transfer window or for us to have to put up with his bewildering team selections and lack of tactical nous in the early stages of next season. We need someone at the helm who's younger and has some oomph, charisma and guile if next season isn't to be a repeat of this one. Roy and Pulis made instant impacts. You could see exactly what they had changed and what they wanted to do. We have seen nothing like this; just some fumbling around with new selections hoping / praying we might stumble on a formula or some form.
As did Moore.
All of the above improved things in a division where, due to the obvious points of lesser budget/ squad quality, the circumstances were far tougher.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
We have had all types of different managers over the years and although fans might not of liked them for various reasons,most of them had a plan.Take Pulis ,for all you can criticise at least he had a plan and you watched and new exactly what they worked on in training.A lot of the time it was sit deep with two big players at full back and set pieces were a priority.A bit more to it but you get the idea.
Big Dave patient play out from the back and yes this was also criticised but it was a plan.Step forward now to Bruce and can anybody tell me what the plan is?You have to remember when he was at Newcastle he ended up having to bring Jones into his coaching team because of the volume of criticism he was getting.Agnew and Clemence have been with him for years and I’d love to know what is going on at the training ground.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Huggybear Wrote:We have had all types of different managers over the years and although fans might not of liked them for various reasons,most of them had a plan.Take Pulis ,for all you can criticise at least he had a plan and you watched and new exactly what they worked on in training.A lot of the time it was sit deep with two big players at full back and set pieces were a priority.A bit more to it but you get the idea.
Big Dave patient play out from the back and yes this was also criticised but it was a plan.Step forward now to Bruce and can anybody tell me what the plan is?You have to remember when he was at Newcastle he ended up having to bring Jones into his coaching team because of the volume of criticism he was getting.Agnew and Clemence have been with him for years and I’d love to know what is going on at the training ground.
Looking forward to this....
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-20-2022, 02:44 PM)Huggybear Wrote: We have had all types of different managers over the years and although fans might not of liked them for various reasons,most of them had a plan.Take Pulis ,for all you can criticise at least he had a plan and you watched and new exactly what they worked on in training.A lot of the time it was sit deep with two big players at full back and set pieces were a priority. A bit more to it but you get the idea.
Big Dave patient play out from the back and yes this was also criticised but it was a plan.Step forward now to Bruce and can anybody tell me what the plan is?You have to remember when he was at Newcastle he ended up having to bring Jones into his coaching team because of the volume of criticism he was getting.Agnew and Clemence have been with him for years and I’d love to know what is going on at the training ground.
Actually, I'd say how you described it was ALL there was to it
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
I think we're all missing the deep complexity of Bruce's tactics:
Plan A: defenders hoof, sorry, play it upfield towards Carroll and then we see what happens. If that fails we move to:
Plan B: we get the ball out wide on the right around the half way line, cross it in the general dierction of Carroll and see what happens. Then on to:
Plan C: get the ball out wide on the left around the half way line, cross it in the general direction of Carroll and see what happens.
If those multiple plans fail, we can always hope for a set piece where we can launch it in the general direction.......
He's a coaching genius.
|