Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-16-2022, 01:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: One thing has become apparent of the past few months and our ownership they've decided they've started a revolution of where we were as a club.
Whether it's an ill-thought through concept or some masterplan only time will tell. However, by appointing Ishmael they've bought into his philosophy regardless of what we think of it. They'll give him time barring proper plummeting.
They've bought into it as he did so well at Barnsley- a club with pennies to spend who he turned from relegation candidates to promotion nearly men. Now he's left look at them?
Now, I have gone on record stating I've been more fed up of him than any manager of late. However, I've also said he does need time.
Time, it's worth adding, is in scarce supply anywhere nowadays in this ridiculous age of impatience where an Amazon parcel arrives the next day.
What I'm currently seeing from the negative, having been there today, and having seen most of our games either on TV or been there, is simply we don't commit enough bodies in the penalty area. It leads to lame 25 yard efforts on target being regarded as attempts as well as other 25 yard efforts with packed penalty areas and blocks also efforts. it's given a totally false feel of the games.
Today I'm hard pressed to recall so many up and under as Eddie Waring used to call them. It was real hoofball.
Now, trying to be balanced we are defensively solid, yet I'll admit that matters not a jot when you know you let a goal in and there's no way back. We have to be more adventurous and we are not.
However, we have been crying out for Dike. We have been crying out for a proper barrel chested heavyweight giant and I think he looked the business. Once those around him start getting on the right wavelength it can change.
Also some big players are missing.
Simply though, looking at the big picture as a club, we've not bought well for 4 years or so. This style requires players of a certain kind. It's a bigger revolution than most.
I'm willing to even miss out on the play-offs if we see the philosophy taking shape by the end of the season. I think it's worth a gamble as we have gone stale.
I can''t recall a rebuild like this since 2006.
Incidentally, some of the stuff on here beggars belief whilst we are still in the top six. I can see why Birdman lost it last week as the hissing and spitting bile and pure entitlement is childish by people who, by and large, have seen us in similar positions many times over the past 20 years.
Those 8 years in the Prem has made some of you every bit as arrogant as our neighbours.
I'd like to add, finishing positively, generally great support today and I can see Dike being a big star who will at least get us out of a hole financially if you soothsayers with your portents of doom prove yourselves right. What if it doesn't?
What if we continue to slide?
How low can we go before you become entitled?
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
01-17-2022, 11:52 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-17-2022, 12:44 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(01-17-2022, 11:35 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-16-2022, 01:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: One thing has become apparent of the past few months and our ownership they've decided they've started a revolution of where we were as a club.
Whether it's an ill-thought through concept or some masterplan only time will tell. However, by appointing Ishmael they've bought into his philosophy regardless of what we think of it. They'll give him time barring proper plummeting.
They've bought into it as he did so well at Barnsley- a club with pennies to spend who he turned from relegation candidates to promotion nearly men. Now he's left look at them?
Now, I have gone on record stating I've been more fed up of him than any manager of late. However, I've also said he does need time.
Time, it's worth adding, is in scarce supply anywhere nowadays in this ridiculous age of impatience where an Amazon parcel arrives the next day.
What I'm currently seeing from the negative, having been there today, and having seen most of our games either on TV or been there, is simply we don't commit enough bodies in the penalty area. It leads to lame 25 yard efforts on target being regarded as attempts as well as other 25 yard efforts with packed penalty areas and blocks also efforts. it's given a totally false feel of the games.
Today I'm hard pressed to recall so many up and under as Eddie Waring used to call them. It was real hoofball.
Now, trying to be balanced we are defensively solid, yet I'll admit that matters not a jot when you know you let a goal in and there's no way back. We have to be more adventurous and we are not.
However, we have been crying out for Dike. We have been crying out for a proper barrel chested heavyweight giant and I think he looked the business. Once those around him start getting on the right wavelength it can change.
Also some big players are missing.
Simply though, looking at the big picture as a club, we've not bought well for 4 years or so. This style requires players of a certain kind. It's a bigger revolution than most.
I'm willing to even miss out on the play-offs if we see the philosophy taking shape by the end of the season. I think it's worth a gamble as we have gone stale.
I can''t recall a rebuild like this since 2006.
Incidentally, some of the stuff on here beggars belief whilst we are still in the top six. I can see why Birdman lost it last week as the hissing and spitting bile and pure entitlement is childish by people who, by and large, have seen us in similar positions many times over the past 20 years.
Those 8 years in the Prem has made some of you every bit as arrogant as our neighbours.
I'd like to add, finishing positively, generally great support today and I can see Dike being a big star who will at least get us out of a hole financially if you soothsayers with your portents of doom prove yourselves right. What if it doesn't?
What if we continue to slide?
How low can we go before you become entitled?
I think the board have to set some parameters rather than the knee-jerk stuff on here. Say they agree that out of the play-offs at the end of the season is unacceptable then so be it. Say they say at any point dropping below two points below 6th. They have to also work out extraneous stuff, say for instance if we got a crippling injury list.
Maybe they say a return of below an average of 12 points in a 10 game run.
There's many parameters, which are based on analysis and patience.
My own is simply we should expect play-offs, but if we miss them and end the season well then still give him his chance. One more window, pre season, and 10 games next season is where I'd draw the line if we're not improving consistently.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(01-16-2022, 12:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-16-2022, 11:47 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: The club have budgeted for being in this league for 3 years, hence the pathetic summer.
Over cautious perhaps? With this squad and such a risk on the manager, possibly very prudent.
So promotion or bust this season just isn't true by all accounts, and not how the club are seeing it, no matter how many times fans say it.
Val is doing a poor job at the moment, however it's a perfect storm of suspensions, injuries, inconsistent players losing form and none of it helped by his absolute refusal to budge from his principles. However to defend these principles, they are throughout the club now, the academy sides are benefitting from a club uniformed style of play, this allows a better path to the first team.
We've just in a very exciting young striker, who has all the qualities to make a difference and in time make a healthy profit for the club too. He wouldn't be here if it wasn't for Val, so a small plus in his column.
I'm not seeing Val as the messiah, I can see why fans are against him at this point. However you'll find it's very rare for me to call for the manager, even Bilic I actively disliked towards the end, I felt deserved the season since no one was keeping that squad up without a lot of luck.
We haven’t heard anything from the club to suggest we are putting money aside for three / four seasons. If we are, I don’t see how that cuts down on the risk particularly, slows the risk down perhaps but we are still entrusting a very raw manager with our medium and long term future. If we were / are going down that route then surely it would have been better to have a Hodgson type manager in place?
I’m not calling for Val to be sacked, he clearly has the season, it wouldn’t make any sense not to, unless this current run of form continues. This isn’t about his style of football for me it’s purely based on results against resources, I’ve always tried to judge by this as it seems the fairest way, with this in mind imo he’s not getting the best out the squad and this worries me for the future given our self sufficient way of operating as a club.
Over the next few weeks hopefully the injuries abs self inflicted suspensions will have eased and Val will have the double edged sword of a very decent squad for this current Covid decimated Championship and a complete lack of excuses for not doing a hell of a lot better, and by better I mean aiming for promotion and not just making the play-offs. Nothing good comes out of staying in the Championship for long.
All good points.
My biggest concern with Val, and I have a few, is the players are regressing under him. Take injuries and suspensions out of it just look at it.
Furlong - Decent start getting worse.
Townsend - Average start and getting worse
Grady - Not getting any tune out of him
Robbo - meh. They definitely don't seem to see eye to eye.
Ajayi - Bombed
Mowatt - Decent start and tailing off.
Livermore - As you'd expect. No progress
Phillips - indifferent form before injury.
You could argue Grant is an improvement on last season but we were in the prem then. TGH is a plus point but how long until his confidence starts to wane under this system. He's much more suited to midfield imo.
I'm just not seeing anything in Vals coaching that is getting these players to up their game 10/15%.
Like you say he will have this season but if he fails to reach the play offs he will have proven to be an abject failure and must be potted.
Massive game Saturday. Anything less than 3 points at home to Posh and he is under all sorts of pressure imo
Posts: 4,322
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Good to see a lot of sense in this Fred, we dont normally get that 48 hours after a loss
Since DiMatteo was sacked (almost) 10 years ago, only Hodgson and Pulis have been given time, 9 others have been and gone in less than a season. While this isn't uncommon in modern football, its not a way to run a club and you wouldn't see this in any other industry.
After enduring the holy trinity of Pulis, Pads and BFS, I dont find it too difficult to get behind anyone.
I dont think this is happy clapping, Im looking at what has gone wrong and hoping that the club have learned from it.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-17-2022, 12:01 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Good to see a lot of sense in this Fred, we dont normally get that 48 hours after a loss
Since DiMatteo was sacked (almost) 10 years ago, only Hodgson and Pulis have been given time, 9 others have been and gone in less than a season. While this isn't uncommon in modern football, its not a way to run a club and you wouldn't see this in any other industry.
After enduring the holy trinity of Pulis, Pads and BFS, I dont find it too difficult to get behind anyone.
I dont think this is happy clapping, Im looking at what has gone wrong and hoping that the club have learned from it.
Time is much easier to give when surviving in the Prem than when battling and surrendering all of your advantages in the Champ.
|