Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
01-05-2022, 03:24 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-05-2022, 03:26 PM by Sliced.)
Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(01-05-2022, 04:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Because he's the only senior player we have who can operate as a target man
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(01-05-2022, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Because he's the only senior player we have who can operate as a target man I'd rather have someone who can hit the target, man.
Hugill has offered nothing whatsoever, just because he can do a job on paper should not get him in when he's not doing it on the pitch. If you are saying that's the sole reason that Val played him then you must agree that he is a very unimaginative coach?
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Well Val ball is utterly reliant on a target man style forward. No one else can do it. Any other form of centre forward would require quite a drastic change all over the pitch. Same as Klopp never got his Gegenpress working at Liverpool properly until he had Firmino since he relies on a False 9 dragging defenders around while the inside forwards cut into space.
I always say this. Klopp NEVER changes formation or makes any drastic change to his teams plan, if it's not working, he get's other players to do the same thing, slightly different being slightly different players. Yet he's one of the best in the world. It's not as uncommon to be totally set on one style and formation as fans like to think it is, not many coaches are very flexible nowadays. Modern training styles don't encourage it, with almost all ball work being totally reliant on muscle memory since the game is so quick now. Knowing exactly where other players will be is key, when you fiddle with the formation ,you lose that. Ok if you have players like City have under Pep, who does tinker, they barely need to look to see where everyone is, ours can't. Maybe Sawyers.
We hired a manager known for being very wedded to his philosophy and style, we can't then complain because he's acting like someone wedded to a style and philosophy....
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
01-05-2022, 04:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-05-2022, 04:51 PM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(01-05-2022, 04:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Because he's the only senior player we have who can operate as a target man I'd rather have someone who can hit the target, man.
Hugill has offered nothing whatsoever, just because he can do a job on paper should not get him in when he's not doing it on the pitch. If you are saying that's the sole reason that Val played him then you must agree that he is a very unimaginative coach?
He hasn't had as many minutes as you might think (It just feels like more  ) and at times Val has tried Phillips in the role as well as Robbo. If you accept that Faal (who has been injured) or Cleary are not physically/mentally ready then he didn't really have any other options.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(01-05-2022, 04:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Because he's the only senior player we have who can operate as a target man I'd rather have someone who can hit the target, man.
Hugill has offered nothing whatsoever, just because he can do a job on paper should not get him in when he's not doing it on the pitch. If you are saying that's the sole reason that Val played him then you must agree that he is a very unimaginative coach?
Let's be honest here, Hugill has been crap but Val has tried all sorts up top and nothing has worked to produce goals. Phillips, Robinson, Grant and Zohore have been used there and not been effective. Hell, there's a few times where we've been chasing a late goal and shoved Bartley up there and it's not worked. Who do you want him to put up there? Hugill's not playing because he's highly rated, he's playing because he's the only one who can do a somewhat competent job
Like trying to unscrew a torx screw without a torx screwdriver.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(01-05-2022, 04:49 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (01-05-2022, 04:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (01-05-2022, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Genuine question. When people say "picking of favourites" do they just mean Livermore?
I would say Furlong probably could have been dropped a couple of times but we seemingly weren't aware of any reasonable alternatives until a few weeks ago. I wouldn't say that was picking a favourite. When he picked Furlong despite TGH's 3 x MoTM performances and bringing Livermore back after his suspension, despite us playing better without him, is pretty much the crux of it.
To a lesser extent, his insistence on playing Hugill every game.
Robinson, Diangana, Phillips and even Grant could all fit at times based on performances.
We have, at some point, tried pretty much every combo though, so for me, it's more about the system and approach than the personnel. He simply has to find a way of getting more out of the players he has.
Hopefully Dike is the magic missing piece but I have concerns that he will just be thrown in to the same old system and, if it doesn't work, we will just be back to square one with less games to go.
Because he's the only senior player we have who can operate as a target man I'd rather have someone who can hit the target, man.
Hugill has offered nothing whatsoever, just because he can do a job on paper should not get him in when he's not doing it on the pitch. If you are saying that's the sole reason that Val played him then you must agree that he is a very unimaginative coach?
He hasn't had as many minutes as you might think (It just feels like more ) and at times Val has tried Phillips in the role as well as Robbo. If you accept that Faal (who has been injured) or Cleary are not physically/mentally ready then he didn't really have any other options. This.
People keep saying there’s no plan B. In modern football Plan B is different players within the same system, who may have marginally different attributes that can affect change or have improved performance than those they’re replacing.
Further, we do change elements of our play but within the system of 343. We do not for instance play the same with Hugill central as we do Robinson - and we will play slightly different (and i wager much improved) with Dike.
|