Posts: 9,616
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(12-13-2021, 10:14 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: We start the season and pure Vaball worked a treat. Hi press, hi line, quick and direct. Then the rest of the division soiled itself and put 10 men behind the ball against us and lumped it at every opportunity. It even took the manager by surprise just how many teans were willing to sacrifice their own style to nullify us. So we end up playing a weird hybrid for a while whilst trying to find the right blend.
During this time we started to play through the lines much more but struggled with how to work the press, and this was when it looked a bit directionless. However, we were still not conceding many and creating multiple half chances in a game; with a proven goalscorer we might have still come out of that period in touch with the top two.
As it is we've just had two very good results and seem to have found a better balance between the football we are playing and the hi line and press. We now have the best defensive record in the division and with that goalscorer we might have added four or five more to our GD. This has coincided with the top two dropping points as this is a relentless league. Teams will most likely double down on us defensively again after these results so it is likely that we will also be dropping points again, but that is the Championship.
I was watching the evolution of the playing style with some surprise at the negative comments being made. I got that it was frustrating and at times maddening, but could see the reason why we were struggling. However just three or four goals over that period might still have had us top. Also the criticism around tactical inflexibility was kind of missing the point; all the age groups play the same way so players get to understand their roles completely within the system. The style of football can change, and has, but not the structure. This is central to Vals philosophy. I know the minute 60 change also annoys many but he does this so he can ask his forwards to press hard from the front and run themselves into the ground knowing changes will be made.
So there is method behind the madness, which is more than some recent managers have offered. And he has had success without really using the transfer market. His confidence that we will see some (maybe just a number 9) additions in January is reassuring and with any success in the window this does look like a team that is yet to reach its best. With a few Val tyoe additions it may turn out to be more substance over style again, but if we are winning and scoring goals.....will anyone really care how?? Winning is everthing, how you do it is just a detail.
Fantastic post, bud!
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Lurker#3 Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:We start the season and pure Vaball worked a treat. Hi press, hi line, quick and direct. Then the rest of the division soiled itself and put 10 men behind the ball against us and lumped it at every opportunity. It even took the manager by surprise just how many teans were willing to sacrifice their own style to nullify us. So we end up playing a weird hybrid for a while whilst trying to find the right blend.
During this time we started to play through the lines much more but struggled with how to work the press, and this was when it looked a bit directionless. However, we were still not conceding many and creating multiple half chances in a game; with a proven goalscorer we might have still come out of that period in touch with the top two.
As it is we've just had two very good results and seem to have found a better balance between the football we are playing and the hi line and press. We now have the best defensive record in the division and with that goalscorer we might have added four or five more to our GD. This has coincided with the top two dropping points as this is a relentless league. Teams will most likely double down on us defensively again after these results so it is likely that we will also be dropping points again, but that is the Championship.
I was watching the evolution of the playing style with some surprise at the negative comments being made. I got that it was frustrating and at times maddening, but could see the reason why we were struggling. However just three or four goals over that period might still have had us top. Also the criticism around tactical inflexibility was kind of missing the point; all the age groups play the same way so players get to understand their roles completely within the system. The style of football can change, and has, but not the structure. This is central to Vals philosophy. I know the minute 60 change also annoys many but he does this so he can ask his forwards to press hard from the front and run themselves into the ground knowing changes will be made.
So there is method behind the madness, which is more than some recent managers have offered. And he has had success without really using the transfer market. His confidence that we will see some (maybe just a number 9) additions in January is reassuring and with any success in the window this does look like a team that is yet to reach its best. With a few Val tyoe additions it may turn out to be more substance over style again, but if we are winning and scoring goals.....will anyone really care how?? Winning is everthing, how you do it is just a detail.
Fantastic post, bud!
Good post. If we did have that goalscorer turning some of these shots into goals we would be top of the league now and I don't reckon our style of play would have merited a mention. Reading tippy tapped the ball around their own penalty area for 70 minutes on Saturday, 2 shots, no goals, would we be happy watching that?
Posts: 2,798
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
17
(12-13-2021, 10:55 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Lurker#3 Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:We start the season and pure Vaball worked a treat. Hi press, hi line, quick and direct. Then the rest of the division soiled itself and put 10 men behind the ball against us and lumped it at every opportunity. It even took the manager by surprise just how many teans were willing to sacrifice their own style to nullify us. So we end up playing a weird hybrid for a while whilst trying to find the right blend.
During this time we started to play through the lines much more but struggled with how to work the press, and this was when it looked a bit directionless. However, we were still not conceding many and creating multiple half chances in a game; with a proven goalscorer we might have still come out of that period in touch with the top two.
As it is we've just had two very good results and seem to have found a better balance between the football we are playing and the hi line and press. We now have the best defensive record in the division and with that goalscorer we might have added four or five more to our GD. This has coincided with the top two dropping points as this is a relentless league. Teams will most likely double down on us defensively again after these results so it is likely that we will also be dropping points again, but that is the Championship.
I was watching the evolution of the playing style with some surprise at the negative comments being made. I got that it was frustrating and at times maddening, but could see the reason why we were struggling. However just three or four goals over that period might still have had us top. Also the criticism around tactical inflexibility was kind of missing the point; all the age groups play the same way so players get to understand their roles completely within the system. The style of football can change, and has, but not the structure. This is central to Vals philosophy. I know the minute 60 change also annoys many but he does this so he can ask his forwards to press hard from the front and run themselves into the ground knowing changes will be made.
So there is method behind the madness, which is more than some recent managers have offered. And he has had success without really using the transfer market. His confidence that we will see some (maybe just a number 9) additions in January is reassuring and with any success in the window this does look like a team that is yet to reach its best. With a few Val tyoe additions it may turn out to be more substance over style again, but if we are winning and scoring goals.....will anyone really care how?? Winning is everthing, how you do it is just a detail.
Fantastic post, bud!
Good post. If we did have that goalscorer turning some of these shots into goals we would be top of the league now and I don't reckon our style of play would have merited a mention. Reading tippy tapped the ball around their own penalty area for 70 minutes on Saturday, 2 shots, no goals, would we be happy watching that?
I believe we were all very happy watching that.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-13-2021, 08:39 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: In most games this season, we've had more shots than the opposition and spent more time in their half. I really do think if we had converted more of the chances (and therefore won a few more), the style of play really wouldn't be an issue. Like everyone else, I'm hoping we can get in a more clinical striker in January.
In most games in the bad period, we had loads more shots, but none of the fuggers went anywhere near the opposition goal. Can we put that stupid stat to bed please? I suspect that against Reading we had more on target shots than most games in October added together (not checked before someone points out that I'm wrong).
It's not a stupid stat. You've illustrated what I said. We missed so many shots because we haven't git a clinical striker. 25 shots at Blackpool 3 on target. Whether you like the style of play or not, in most games it's effective, we just need the right personnel to make it successful.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-13-2021, 01:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (12-13-2021, 08:39 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: In most games this season, we've had more shots than the opposition and spent more time in their half. I really do think if we had converted more of the chances (and therefore won a few more), the style of play really wouldn't be an issue. Like everyone else, I'm hoping we can get in a more clinical striker in January.
In most games in the bad period, we had loads more shots, but none of the fuggers went anywhere near the opposition goal. Can we put that stupid stat to bed please? I suspect that against Reading we had more on target shots than most games in October added together (not checked before someone points out that I'm wrong).
It's not a stupid stat. You've illustrated what I said. We missed so many shots because we haven't git a clinical striker. 25 shots at Blackpool 3 on target. Whether you like the style of play or not, in most games it's effective, we just need the right personnel to make it successful.
You are assuming that all shots are equal, and they quite simply are not. A shot from the halfway line that the keeper picks up with no bother is still a shot. It's about the quality of the shots, for me I only really count a shot if it makes the keeper work (as in not make a routine save), hits the woodwork, is cleared off the line or misses by say a foot.
On Saturday, Robinson could have had 4, I think there were a couple of others that could have had a goal each too, they all were either very close or made the keeper do some real work. Against Blackpool the keeper barely did anything, and the same goes for most of the games in Oct/Nov. That's not down to not having a real striker, as we've seen these players CAN hit the target, it was down to us lumping in pointless crosses to nobody and then maybe causing a scramble with a tame effort... Or it bouncing in and someone lashing at it.
Our shooting was abysmal, and against Coventry it was pretty bad too. We didn't really create the clear cut chances to get a real shot off, so we just hit it and hoped, time and time again... All of them make the stats look better than the reality actually was. Not just to do with no real striker (although Hugill is technically one of them).
Against reading we actually created decent goal scoring chances, and some of the shots were poor, but at least a lot more were dangerous. I couldn't give a flying one about having 30 shots that trickle to the keeper or fly miles wide or super high.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-13-2021, 02:13 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 01:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (12-13-2021, 08:39 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: In most games this season, we've had more shots than the opposition and spent more time in their half. I really do think if we had converted more of the chances (and therefore won a few more), the style of play really wouldn't be an issue. Like everyone else, I'm hoping we can get in a more clinical striker in January.
In most games in the bad period, we had loads more shots, but none of the fuggers went anywhere near the opposition goal. Can we put that stupid stat to bed please? I suspect that against Reading we had more on target shots than most games in October added together (not checked before someone points out that I'm wrong).
It's not a stupid stat. You've illustrated what I said. We missed so many shots because we haven't git a clinical striker. 25 shots at Blackpool 3 on target. Whether you like the style of play or not, in most games it's effective, we just need the right personnel to make it successful.
You are assuming that all shots are equal, and they quite simply are not. A shot from the halfway line that the keeper picks up with no bother is still a shot. It's about the quality of the shots, for me I only really count a shot if it makes the keeper work (as in not make a routine save), hits the woodwork, is cleared off the line or misses by say a foot.
On Saturday, Robinson could have had 4, I think there were a couple of others that could have had a goal each too, they all were either very close or made the keeper do some real work. Against Blackpool the keeper barely did anything, and the same goes for most of the games in Oct/Nov. That's not down to not having a real striker, as we've seen these players CAN hit the target, it was down to us lumping in pointless crosses to nobody and then maybe causing a scramble with a tame effort... Or it bouncing in and someone lashing at it.
Our shooting was abysmal, and against Coventry it was pretty bad too. We didn't really create the clear cut chances to get a real shot off, so we just hit it and hoped, time and time again... All of them make the stats look better than the reality actually was. Not just to do with no real striker (although Hugill is technically one of them).
Against reading we actually created decent goal scoring chances, and some of the shots were poor, but at least a lot more were dangerous. I couldn't give a flying one about having 30 shots that trickle to the keeper or fly miles wide or super high.
You're not really convincing me that I'm wrong to think we need a better striker.
I just watched the Blackpool highlights and I'm convinced some of those chances would have been in the back of the net had they fell to SKP, Gayle or JRod.
Anyway, let's see if one gets recruited in January...
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-13-2021, 06:15 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (12-13-2021, 02:13 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 01:21 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (12-13-2021, 08:39 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (12-13-2021, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: In most games this season, we've had more shots than the opposition and spent more time in their half. I really do think if we had converted more of the chances (and therefore won a few more), the style of play really wouldn't be an issue. Like everyone else, I'm hoping we can get in a more clinical striker in January.
In most games in the bad period, we had loads more shots, but none of the fuggers went anywhere near the opposition goal. Can we put that stupid stat to bed please? I suspect that against Reading we had more on target shots than most games in October added together (not checked before someone points out that I'm wrong).
It's not a stupid stat. You've illustrated what I said. We missed so many shots because we haven't git a clinical striker. 25 shots at Blackpool 3 on target. Whether you like the style of play or not, in most games it's effective, we just need the right personnel to make it successful.
You are assuming that all shots are equal, and they quite simply are not. A shot from the halfway line that the keeper picks up with no bother is still a shot. It's about the quality of the shots, for me I only really count a shot if it makes the keeper work (as in not make a routine save), hits the woodwork, is cleared off the line or misses by say a foot.
On Saturday, Robinson could have had 4, I think there were a couple of others that could have had a goal each too, they all were either very close or made the keeper do some real work. Against Blackpool the keeper barely did anything, and the same goes for most of the games in Oct/Nov. That's not down to not having a real striker, as we've seen these players CAN hit the target, it was down to us lumping in pointless crosses to nobody and then maybe causing a scramble with a tame effort... Or it bouncing in and someone lashing at it.
Our shooting was abysmal, and against Coventry it was pretty bad too. We didn't really create the clear cut chances to get a real shot off, so we just hit it and hoped, time and time again... All of them make the stats look better than the reality actually was. Not just to do with no real striker (although Hugill is technically one of them).
Against reading we actually created decent goal scoring chances, and some of the shots were poor, but at least a lot more were dangerous. I couldn't give a flying one about having 30 shots that trickle to the keeper or fly miles wide or super high.
You're not really convincing me that I'm wrong to think we need a better striker.
I just watched the Blackpool highlights and I'm convinced some of those chances would have been in the back of the net had they fell to SKP, Gayle or JRod.
Anyway, let's see if one gets recruited in January...
Everyone wants a better striker, I'm not trying to say otherwise!
Posts: 655
Threads: 185
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
with regard to the last game, all I saw was the 10 or so mins on quest and Robbo's goal which was well taken, right place to be at the right tlme ! However there are lads on here whose views I respect, and from their comments, it seems things are looking up! Great!
|