Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... part 2
#21
Only real criticism i have is the lack of flexibility in the formation, like many others. Maybe this will come later, who knows? The style has certainly changed to a more patient, less harem-scarem way.
Reply
#22
Who do you realistically want instead? Bear in mind the calibre of applicants interviewed when we were fairly stable in the Premiership. We couldn't persuade Pep and co to come when Roy left for the England job
Reply
#23
(11-12-2021, 03:53 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Only real criticism i have is the lack of flexibility in the formation, like many others. Maybe this will come later, who knows? The style has certainly changed to a more patient, less harem-scarem way.

Sorry Ferenc but I am quite happy with him being in charge at the moment. 

Some have an issue with the "style" of football but ive seen much worse and we HAVE shown a change in the way we have played over the last few matches even if not formation. However, I am accepting of the rigidity in formation as he wants consistency not only in the first team squad but also through all the age ranges so players can step in and know their role.

In regards to results and position in the table we are on track given the unbalanced nature of our squad and lack of summer investment.  Yes, that squad is still better than most in the division but not up to the quality of the top two who are on target to break records.   Yes we have spent money over the last few years but in Grant, Grady and Zahore we have not spent wisely or got value.

Im happy that he has talked about utilising youth and shown that by playing GH rather than shoe horning Phillips or Reach into RWB has may also walk the walk.  Yes he bought Furlong back next match but that was a reasonable decision.   I like the fact he has also talked about the losing to many good youth players and the need to address this.

Finally, the club is currently devoid of football knowledge or leadership at all levels from owner down.  Val looks a natural leader and has the big personality the role currently needs.   I do think he has something of the SGM about him personally and in the way he sets up his teams.  Not in a tactical sense just no nonsense.  I'll take that.
Reply
#24
Cuzer Wrote:No, I think he's evolving game by game, just look at our possession stats, less long balls, more patience, the problem is our squad lacks creativiity and my critcism of Val is 3-4-3 is a religion and he needs to be more flexible

Fulham for example, great game to drop an extra midfielder in and go with two strikers, lack of flexibility is my only criticism of him so far personally

Cuzer

Word for word, this is my opinion too. Thing is, Ferenc, we simply haven't spent. The manager was appointed to get us up on a shoestring. There are two teams with better squads than us and we are right behind them. I'm not sure we have any right to be higher. Re the style of play; As Cuzer says, the tactics have definitely changed in the last few games, I'm hopeful we are finding our way.
Reply
#25
(11-12-2021, 03:39 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-12-2021, 02:56 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-12-2021, 02:36 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-12-2021, 12:53 PM)B36baggie Wrote:
(11-12-2021, 12:27 PM)Sliced Wrote: Our best team is

Johnstone

Furlong
Clarke
Ajayi
Bartley
Townsend

Mowatt
Livermore

Grant
Robinson
Grady

Only debateable are Phillips or Molumby instead of one of the above. We know our best team there are just no reasonable alternatives when it gets stale!

Also I wouldn't say we were formationless, we've used the same one every week!

I would certainly have O'Shea in any best side.

Dearie me, Forgot about O’Shea. Obviously goes in ahead of Ajayi

I think our best team is probably:

Robinson Hugill(!!!) Phillips
Mowatt Livermore Molumby
Townsend Clarke Bartley Furlong
Johnstone 

Fuck me. I stopped reading at Hugill. No Grant? Top scorer. Our only real source of goals the last couple of months.

I thought I’d put Grant in - I meant him, not Phillips. Been a long day Big Grin

(11-12-2021, 03:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Meh, we are 3rd with the third best squad. We have to win the play-off's or punch above our weight in terms of talent and finish top two. If we don't, then we are fecked as a club. So either support the manager and team or question if you really want the best for the club. If you want hope for the club, being sold whilst in the Prem is the only real way this can be achieved.

Sadly I’m not sure we’ll get sold in the PL… or if we do, I’m wary of the owners we will attract there.
How many teams of our size in the last 10-15 years have had a progressive change of ownership whilst in the PL?
Reply
#26
Loathe VIs football. It’s joyless shite. He doesn’t allow players to express themselves and as a result he doesn’t get the best out of them. He can fuck off as far as I’m concerned and I’m not a purist by any stretch. If the wage bill is 3rd highest chances are we finish 3rd we might as well enjoy it. If we lose against Coventry in the playoffs I’m gonna go apeshit.
Reply
#27
Another thought on this. When the high press does work it is as exciting as anything else. To be honest, after the novelty wore off, I got bored to death watching Barcelona take 200 passes to get out of their own half. Wenger's Arsenal also used to wear the lacquer off the ball passing it to death.  We don't  have that quality plus we have not been able to press much lately, sometimes the opposition don't want the ball, but we are at least attempting to play through the other team. I believe we are simply 2 players from being a very decent Championship side, I'm sure Val would know exactly who he'd have, given half a chance..
Reply
#28
(11-12-2021, 07:23 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Loathe VIs football. It’s joyless shite. He doesn’t allow players to express themselves and as a result he doesn’t get the best out of them. He can fuck off as far as I’m concerned and I’m not a purist by any stretch. If the wage bill is 3rd highest chances are we finish 3rd we might as well enjoy it. If we lose against Coventry in the playoffs I’m gonna go apeshit.

What a prattish and joyless post.
Reply
#29
(11-12-2021, 09:16 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(11-12-2021, 07:23 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Loathe VIs football. It’s joyless shite. He doesn’t allow players to express themselves and as a result he doesn’t get the best out of them. He can fuck off as far as I’m concerned and I’m not a purist by any stretch. If the wage bill is 3rd highest chances are we finish 3rd we might as well enjoy it. If we lose against Coventry in the playoffs I’m gonna go apeshit.

What a prattish and joyless post.

Whereas your post is full of joy…
Reply
#30
It's pretty obvious Val came in with a set of instructions from the board. Get us up without spending any money. And we will be selling your best player and we will be terminating 15 current squad members.
The attractiveness of the football has to go hand in hand with who is available to play together with confidence levels.
We could play a more open game, but would we be 3rd in the table. With the current recruitment policy that's debatable.
The shouting for a CF who can score 20 goals - everyone wants one and they don't come for free.
IMO our issues run deeper then just a CF or a game plan / tactics. It's a mental fragility that kills us. We struggle to maintain any dominance from the start of a game. 
It's no coincidence Alex Ferguson used to employ psychiatrists to ensure players were mentally strong and up to speed the moment they stepped on the pitch. 
Physical fitness is not the be all and end all. 
Back to the OP we all would like Val to playing more attractive football but let the guy buy a couple of quality players to have a chance.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: