OMG M&S PC OTT
#51
(11-10-2021, 07:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pointing out that people aren't happy about having opportunities to do things they were once able to do closed off from them when, as far as they're concerned, they're fixing something wrong with them to live life as they think they should be allowed to.

On the point of competition I believe it's dependent on a multitude of factors with respect to inherent advantages and as such things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis by the appropriate authorities, an androgenised trans woman would have inherent advantages against a typical cis-woman owing to going through androginsation owing to bone and muscle structures but things get more complex when comparing a trans woman who hasn't gone through androgenisation (owing to them being intersex and assigned male then transitioning later in life or being a male and not undergoing the process for whatever reason) as those inherent biological advantages in competitive sports disappear. There's also the risk of intersex people being caught up in it, see Caster Semenya.

It's an incredibly complex issue and the only thing I am opposed to is how simply and one-dimensional it is being presented as, as well as presenting the issue with people like Lauren Hubble or however you spell it vs issues like trans women being blanket banned from being able to play amateur contact women's rugby even though the RFU guidance, which rightly covers the issue over health risks to others in contact sport for androgenised trans women, is based on evidence which doesn't apply to the aforementioned trans women who haven't gone through androgenisation.

It’s not complex if you say if you change your gender then you can’t participate in female sport.

Another problem solved.

<brushes white flakes from epaulettes>
Reply
#52
(11-10-2021, 09:30 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 07:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pointing out that people aren't happy about having opportunities to do things they were once able to do closed off from them when, as far as they're concerned, they're fixing something wrong with them to live life as they think they should be allowed to.

On the point of competition I believe it's dependent on a multitude of factors with respect to inherent advantages and as such things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis by the appropriate authorities, an androgenised trans woman would have inherent advantages against a typical cis-woman owing to going through androginsation owing to bone and muscle structures but things get more complex when comparing a trans woman who hasn't gone through androgenisation (owing to them being intersex and assigned male then transitioning later in life or being a male and not undergoing the process for whatever reason) as those inherent biological advantages in competitive sports disappear. There's also the risk of intersex people being caught up in it, see Caster Semenya.

It's an incredibly complex issue and the only thing I am opposed to is how simply and one-dimensional it is being presented as, as well as presenting the issue with people like Lauren Hubble or however you spell it vs issues like trans women being blanket banned from being able to play amateur contact women's rugby even though the RFU guidance, which rightly covers the issue over health risks to others in contact sport for androgenised trans women, is based on evidence which doesn't apply to the aforementioned trans women who haven't gone through androgenisation.

It’s not complex if you say if you change your gender then you can’t participate in female sport.

Another problem solved.

<brushes white flakes from epaulettes>

Think you might need some Head and Shoulders there
Reply
#53
(11-10-2021, 09:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 09:30 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 07:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pointing out that people aren't happy about having opportunities to do things they were once able to do closed off from them when, as far as they're concerned, they're fixing something wrong with them to live life as they think they should be allowed to.

On the point of competition I believe it's dependent on a multitude of factors with respect to inherent advantages and as such things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis by the appropriate authorities, an androgenised trans woman would have inherent advantages against a typical cis-woman owing to going through androginsation owing to bone and muscle structures but things get more complex when comparing a trans woman who hasn't gone through androgenisation (owing to them being intersex and assigned male then transitioning later in life or being a male and not undergoing the process for whatever reason) as those inherent biological advantages in competitive sports disappear. There's also the risk of intersex people being caught up in it, see Caster Semenya.

It's an incredibly complex issue and the only thing I am opposed to is how simply and one-dimensional it is being presented as, as well as presenting the issue with people like Lauren Hubble or however you spell it vs issues like trans women being blanket banned from being able to play amateur contact women's rugby even though the RFU guidance, which rightly covers the issue over health risks to others in contact sport for androgenised trans women, is based on evidence which doesn't apply to the aforementioned trans women who haven't gone through androgenisation.

It’s not complex if you say if you change your gender then you can’t participate in female sport.

Another problem solved.

<brushes white flakes from epaulettes>

Think you might need some Head and Shoulders there

Now that's a far more complex operation.
Reply
#54
Fuck sake.

What ever happened to “oi!!, student!! Where’s the paella rice for my bbq?”

This world is going down the paella pan.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: