Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
11-08-2021, 12:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-08-2021, 12:11 AM by Tom Joad.)
(11-07-2021, 09:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Just out of interest, has anyone got any spending stats for the whole division? It would be intriguing to see how many teams can be using the didn't spend anything arguments. Especially as it could well be argued that we already had / have better players than 75% of the other teams, and if nobody (ignoring Fulham!) has really spent anything then that argument is totally moot.
Not really. No one else in the division has let go of their best players (loaned or otherwise), but expects to still steamroller their way to promotion.
I know you're waging a war against Val but maybe give us a viable alternative? As for you saying taking Fulham out of your argument, that just leaves one other team above us?
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-07-2021, 10:51 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (11-07-2021, 12:32 PM)Squid Wrote: (11-07-2021, 09:37 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-07-2021, 12:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (11-06-2021, 11:59 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's a "No" from me. They are above average Championship players looking average at best some of the time. The coach has to take some responsibility for days of under-achievement like today.
How can he be blamed for players not being able to do the basics though?
People keep talking about a Plan B.
Today we had little problem getting through their midfield. We also got the ball into their box plenty. But our front three were by and large, useless. A formation change wouldn't have helped that.
Apparently it's Val's fault Robinson cannot complete the most simple of passes because he scored against some part-timers for Ireland.
If anything, I could pick at our set-pieces, as if we're struggling to score, we need those to be better. However, I suspect that players are doing it all during training, but can't replicate it on matchday.
When most of these same players failed to perform for Sam Allardyce, many posters on here were quick to blame Allardyce for "losijng them". Why is Ismael absolved of all blame for sending out a team that can't "do the basics"? Is he working on these weaknesses in training? Could he freshen up his attack with a youngster or two? Doing the same every week doesn't seem to be working consistently.
Not me. It was clear they'd been having far too nice a time under Bilic and that Allardyce was a big shock to many of them. In the end though, Livermore aside and after some horrendous results, most of them played their best football of the season under him. Phillips and Townsend in particular. Results don't bear that out.
There were some mid term improvements, but the beginning and end of his tenure were rubbish.
And he cost us money we couldn't afford with no end product.
If we'd kept Bilic we'd still have gone down, but in a much healthier position.
The players could barely run for 75 minutes under Bilic, they were that unfit.
Besides which, the fact he got another job a mere two weeks later would tell you that he was eager to be sacked. That whole huffing and puffing over Hegazi being sold was just his agent testing the waters.
I know we had some good times under Bilic, but the fact is, as soon as the job got challenging, he lost interest. The utter mess he and Dowling made of the team preparation that summer should be a criminal offence. Yes, it would have always been a huge challenge to avoid relegation, but the bottom third of the PL is very poor and with the right team and high fitness and organisation levels, we may have stood chance.
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(11-08-2021, 01:25 AM)Squid Wrote: (11-07-2021, 10:51 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (11-07-2021, 12:32 PM)Squid Wrote: (11-07-2021, 09:37 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-07-2021, 12:13 AM)Squid Wrote: How can he be blamed for players not being able to do the basics though?
People keep talking about a Plan B.
Today we had little problem getting through their midfield. We also got the ball into their box plenty. But our front three were by and large, useless. A formation change wouldn't have helped that.
Apparently it's Val's fault Robinson cannot complete the most simple of passes because he scored against some part-timers for Ireland.
If anything, I could pick at our set-pieces, as if we're struggling to score, we need those to be better. However, I suspect that players are doing it all during training, but can't replicate it on matchday.
When most of these same players failed to perform for Sam Allardyce, many posters on here were quick to blame Allardyce for "losijng them". Why is Ismael absolved of all blame for sending out a team that can't "do the basics"? Is he working on these weaknesses in training? Could he freshen up his attack with a youngster or two? Doing the same every week doesn't seem to be working consistently.
Not me. It was clear they'd been having far too nice a time under Bilic and that Allardyce was a big shock to many of them. In the end though, Livermore aside and after some horrendous results, most of them played their best football of the season under him. Phillips and Townsend in particular. Results don't bear that out.
There were some mid term improvements, but the beginning and end of his tenure were rubbish.
And he cost us money we couldn't afford with no end product.
If we'd kept Bilic we'd still have gone down, but in a much healthier position.
The players could barely run for 75 minutes under Bilic, they were that unfit.
Besides which, the fact he got another job a mere two weeks later would tell you that he was eager to be sacked. That whole huffing and puffing over Hegazi being sold was just his agent testing the waters.
I know we had some good times under Bilic, but the fact is, as soon as the job got challenging, he lost interest. The utter mess he and Dowling made of the team preparation that summer should be a criminal offence. Yes, it would have always been a huge challenge to avoid relegation, but the bottom third of the PL is very poor and with the right team and high fitness and organisation levels, we may have stood chance. Maybe. We'll never know of course.
I could argue that had Bilic been given the resources BFS got, and which he evidently wanted, he'd have performed better.
Or that Sam brought these higher fitness levels (I disagree about the degree. Not as much as is the accepted wisdom on here)... with no improvement in results.
There's more to football than running around a lot, obviously. Bilic recruited very well.
Imagine Pereira, even Krov, in our team now.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-08-2021, 12:08 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (11-07-2021, 09:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Just out of interest, has anyone got any spending stats for the whole division? It would be intriguing to see how many teams can be using the didn't spend anything arguments. Especially as it could well be argued that we already had / have better players than 75% of the other teams, and if nobody (ignoring Fulham!) has really spent anything then that argument is totally moot.
Not really. No one else in the division has let go of their best players (loaned or otherwise), but expects to still steamroller their way to promotion.
I know you're waging a war against Val but maybe give us a viable alternative? As for you saying taking Fulham out of your argument, that just leaves one other team above us?
Not waging war against anyone. I actually want Six to succeed, but that doesn't mind blindly accepting the dross he is serving up currently.
As for the spending, according to an Athletic headline there has been a total of £40m spent on 37 players in the entire Championship. Around HALF of that was Fulham. As for letting their best players go, Barnsely did, to us. Six didn't want MP so even that argument is flawed. We coul have kept him and not played him.
People continually saying we spent nothing are conveniently overlooking the fact that we already have, on paper at least, a better set of players than the majority of the division, and the majority of the division spent nothing as well. Coventry for example are flying, they may not last the course, but right now they spent a whopping £1m and are punching way above what many would have expected.
Managers do not need to spend / spend loads to achieve things in this league, but you know, invent some vendetta or some shyte to try and prove your flaky as fuck point.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
MassDebater Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:MassDebater Wrote:Just out of interest, has anyone got any spending stats for the whole division? It would be intriguing to see how many teams can be using the didn't spend anything arguments. Especially as it could well be argued that we already had / have better players than 75% of the other teams, and if nobody (ignoring Fulham!) has really spent anything then that argument is totally moot.
Not really. No one else in the division has let go of their best players (loaned or otherwise), but expects to still steamroller their way to promotion.
I know you're waging a war against Val but maybe give us a viable alternative? As for you saying taking Fulham out of your argument, that just leaves one other team above us?
Not waging war against anyone. I actually want Six to succeed, but that doesn't mind blindly accepting the dross he is serving up currently.
As for the spending, according to an Athletic headline there has been a total of £40m spent on 37 players in the entire Championship. Around HALF of that was Fulham. As for letting their best players go, Barnsely did, to us. Six didn't want MP so even that argument is flawed. We coul have kept him and not played him.
People continually saying we spent nothing are conveniently overlooking the fact that we already have, on paper at least, a better set of players than the majority of the division, and the majority of the division spent nothing as well. Coventry for example are flying, they may not last the course, but right now they spent a whopping £1m and are punching way above what many would have expected.
Managers do not need to spend / spend loads to achieve things in this league, but you know, invent some vendetta or some shyte to try and prove your flaky as fuck point. I am not buying into this "best set of players" thing. We let go of almost everyone of quality and it remains to be seen whether we wheel and deal (and I suspect sell Sam J) in January. We are still the closest opposition to the two teams with obviously stronger squads. Yes, Barnsley (also) sold their best players, but look where they are in the table. We are, in the table, where we probably should be.
As for dross. I've seen so, so many much worse performances over the years, now that was dross. Saturday was a game where we tried to play through the opponents. You can't press a side that doesn't ever keep the ball. The fact it didn't work was mainly down to our players shortcomings. bad first touches, muscled off the ball, poor passing. I wont even slate them, as I said, I don't think this squad is all that good and I couldn't criticize their effort. Two decent signings would change that but I don't see it happening.
BTW. I'm not inventing a vendetta. I love a good chat about all things Albion but you are starting a dozen different threads post games all slating the manager. I'm afraid we are stuck with him, like it or not, as he suits the owners requirement of not spending. All I'll say is, be careful what you wish for. Currently, he is probably the best man for the job and we have to get behind him.
Anyway, I'd love to go on and on about the Albion but it's Monday and I can't put off going to work any longer. Enjoy your day, I'm happy to resume battle later!
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-08-2021, 09:28 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: MassDebater Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:MassDebater Wrote:Just out of interest, has anyone got any spending stats for the whole division? It would be intriguing to see how many teams can be using the didn't spend anything arguments. Especially as it could well be argued that we already had / have better players than 75% of the other teams, and if nobody (ignoring Fulham!) has really spent anything then that argument is totally moot.
Not really. No one else in the division has let go of their best players (loaned or otherwise), but expects to still steamroller their way to promotion.
I know you're waging a war against Val but maybe give us a viable alternative? As for you saying taking Fulham out of your argument, that just leaves one other team above us?
Not waging war against anyone. I actually want Six to succeed, but that doesn't mind blindly accepting the dross he is serving up currently.
As for the spending, according to an Athletic headline there has been a total of £40m spent on 37 players in the entire Championship. Around HALF of that was Fulham. As for letting their best players go, Barnsely did, to us. Six didn't want MP so even that argument is flawed. We coul have kept him and not played him.
People continually saying we spent nothing are conveniently overlooking the fact that we already have, on paper at least, a better set of players than the majority of the division, and the majority of the division spent nothing as well. Coventry for example are flying, they may not last the course, but right now they spent a whopping £1m and are punching way above what many would have expected.
Managers do not need to spend / spend loads to achieve things in this league, but you know, invent some vendetta or some shyte to try and prove your flaky as fuck point. I am not buying into this "best set of players" thing. We let go of almost everyone of quality and it remains to be seen whether we wheel and deal (and I suspect sell Sam J) in January. We are still the closest opposition to the two teams with obviously stronger squads. Yes, Barnsley (also) sold their best players, but look where they are in the table. We are, in the table, where we probably should be.
As for dross. I've seen so, so many much worse performances over the years, now that was dross. Saturday was a game where we tried to play through the opponents. You can't press a side that doesn't ever keep the ball. The fact it didn't work was mainly down to our players shortcomings. bad first touches, muscled off the ball, poor passing. I wont even slate them, as I said, I don't think this squad is all that good and I couldn't criticize their effort. Two decent signings would change that but I don't see it happening.
BTW. I'm not inventing a vendetta. I love a good chat about all things Albion but you are starting a dozen different threads post games all slating the manager. I'm afraid we are stuck with him, like it or not, as he suits the owners requirement of not spending. All I'll say is, be careful what you wish for. Currently, he is probably the best man for the job and we have to get behind him.
Anyway, I'd love to go on and on about the Albion but it's Monday and I can't put off going to work any longer. Enjoy your day, I'm happy to resume battle later!
Other than Pereira who did we let go?
A dozen threads? please show me them, I started a couple after the game on Saturday. One was a joke and titled as such, nobody really thinks a thread calling for oli burke is serious do they? One was about movies... so erm enlighten me please
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
11-08-2021, 10:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-08-2021, 10:21 AM by Sliced.)
There's been 5 threads in the past 5 days around the team or manager being shit, 4 were in the space of 2 days.
As for "who we lost", look at our starting 11s from last season. In terms of personnel we lost our entire first choice midfield in Okay, AMN, Gallagher and Pereira, we lost our first choice striker in Diagne and our second choice striker was sent away on a free then replaced with worse.
"Oh but they weren't permanent players"!? Doesn't matter, thats a massive turn over in personnel. There's a reason why everything good last season either came thorugh loanees or Pereira. All that's gone and been replaced in the laziest way possible by *insert ANYONE available for cheap*.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-08-2021, 10:15 AM)Sliced Wrote: There's been 5 threads in the past 5 days around the team or manager being shit, 4 were in the space of 2 days.
As for "who we lost", look at our starting 11s from last season. In terms of personnel we lost our entire first choice midfield in Okay, AMN, Gallagher and Pereira, we lost our first choice striker in Diagne and our second choice striker was sent away on a free then replaced with worse.
"Oh but they weren't permanent players"!? Doesn't matter, thats a massive turn over in personnel. There's a reason why everything good last season either came thorugh loanees or Pereira. All that's gone and been replaced in the laziest way possible by *insert ANYONE availble for cheap*.
Sums our position up perfectly that.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
The tenor of many comments on this thread and others, give the impression that we are in massive crisis, we are a long way from that.
The reality is we are third, we are collecting points at a rate just short of 2 points a game. And we shouldn't ignore that at the moment we are having to put out teams without key personnel due to injury and suspensions.
People complain about performance, but that is such a subjective concept to measure. My opinion is that we are seeing performances no worse than in the Megson first promotion season, don't recall people moaning about performance then.
Only a fool would deny there are issues at the club, both on and off the pitch. But I am not convinced that they are in the main the fault of the current manager.
It seems to me that we fans have become a wee bit entitled at this level. It us our right to get promotion, without having to break sweat playing champagne football. Well the reality is that we are not in that position, anything gained now will be a struggle.
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
If I was a Sheff Utd fan I would be concerned. An expensively assembled side. An expensively appointed manager. 18th in the table.
But Albion?
|