How much difference do managers make?
#21
I think this is simply down to the amount of power the manager has. It's not like 1970 any more where managers like Clough and Revie looked after everything. There's now probably 20 people doing various facets of what that role was, so comparing modern figureheads coaches/managers to then is barmy.

Some clubs have a very rigid structure for the manager, where he's basically just responsible for the team that takes the pitch. Some even seem to have little say in recruitment.

Watford cannot be an incredible basket case as their recent history for a club that really are a notch below the likes of us historically, is quite impressive whilst bigger clubs than them like Forest, Derby, Boro, Sunderland etc have languished.

In the modern era losing Ashworth has been the biggest issue Albion have had.

So the answer to the original question is it depends on the club.
Reply
#22
(10-05-2021, 10:49 AM)Squid Wrote: As much as it pains me to say anything against Darren Moore, most managers could have got that 18/19 team promoted. So sometimes it's the negative impact of the manager as much as the positive.

On this, I dont our midfield was ever good enough that season for a team looking to get promotion.

Perhaps if Barry and Livermore had been available for the whole season it might have been, but they weren't
Reply
#23
What difference, at the end of the day, does a manager make is a question I've asked myself many a time.

If we take the Man City team last season as our baseline the question is, could any other manager have won the League with that set of players?

I think its obvious that any manager is only as good as the quality of his players. If his players are rubbish the results will be rubbish in the long term. However, there are other factors which the manager brings which will get his players galvanised and playing in a style best suited to them, or the exact opposite. So a manager can have a detrimental effect on a good team. Likewise, they will not have a positive effect, other than an initial short term, on a bad team.

I think what makes a manager, ultimately, is how they man manage the team as I think most managers are intelligent enough to play to the players' strengths. Most managers, that is. Those that don't, fail. And most, if not all, managers can read a game, so can react to opposition changes. However, how successful those reactions are tend to be down to the quality of player at his disposal.

So I think most managers could have won the League with Man City last season, albeit not "as well" as Pep did it, provided the players were onside. 

Likewise, I think Pep would fail at the clubs who get relegated each season, provided that relegation was down to quality of player rather than other issues.

Previously I judged how good a manager was by the quality of their signings. Some managers "knew a good player when they saw one" although, in reality, it might have been club finances which dictated who was signed. I don't know how much that applies in this day and age.

So, in summary, the main difference between managers is how they handle the players, as I would expect tactics to be generally the same based on the same set of players, and suited to those players strengths.  The quality of player is then the deciding factor in how that team does. In my onions.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: