Squad Depth 2019 vs 2021
#11
Field, Harper and Sawyers out with Mowatt, Molomby and Castro in. Field's time had come and needed to move on and there is little doubt that neither of Sawyers or Harper would be suited to Valball. Even with Molomby coming in a lot will depend on Snodgrass being able to complement in the middle. Castro is the wildcard, and as much as it would be great to see him come through you'd hope he will be playing a very minor role. Still feels one light to me in midfield but we know the manager likes a small, tight squad.
Reply
#12
(08-27-2021, 11:49 AM)Sliced Wrote: Keepers:
2019: Johnstone, Bond, Al-Habsi
2021: Johnstone, Button, Palmer

Same for both years.

Defenders:
2019: Gibbs, Townsend, Ajayi, Hegazi, Bartley, O'Shea, Ferguson, Furlong, Peltier
2021: Townsend, Reach, Ajayi, Clarke, Bartley, O'Shea, Kipre, Furlong

Same number of bodies initially but we're playing 5 at the back instead of 4, also Reach isn't really a defender first and foremost and we're lacking a defender with the versatiliy of Ferguson. Peltier came in for extra cover later in the season.

Potential Central Midfielders:
2019: Livermore, Sawyers, Harper, Barry, Brunt, Krovinovic
2021: Livermore, Mowatt.......maybe Snodgrass

No words needed

Attacking Midfielders/Wide Players:
2019: Pereira, Robinson, Phillips, Grosicki, Edwards, Diangana, Willock
2021: Robinson, Phillips, Diangana, Grant

Arguably our most covered position and we're still weaker than 2019, with less options.

Strikers:
2019: Austin, HRK, Zohore, Tulloch
2021: Hugill, Zohore, Tulloch

Basically one realistic striking option unless we decide to play one of our limited attacking midfield/wide options up front.


Without splitting hairs about which of the above are actually wide players/midfielders or should be in other categories it doesn't make for good reading. For anyone doubting the importance of a squad in the championship, the likes of Krovinovic and Edwards weren't even considered regular first teamers but they made 43 and 30 appearances respectively in 2019.

I think you do have to look at where those players are up to in terms of their progression too. Lots of players in that 2019 squad are now much more established.

Defence: 
Furlong, Townsend and O'Shea were all doubted and not considered first teamers, they are now, and are arguably 3 of our better players. And with Kipre and Reach we are just short of a right sided player unless Val trusts Ingram, which I have no problems with.

Midfield:
Harper, Barry and Brunt hardly featured. We have Castro who is the Harper replacement. So our options are Livermore, Mowatt, Snoddy and Castro. With Reach who has also played in there for Sheff Wed. All that being said I would still like another box to box player if we can. 

Forwards: 
Hugill, Phillips, Robinson, Diangana, Grant and Tulloch. I think we have enough up there for this league.

I don't see the wrist-slitting necessity, yes we seem short in CM, but we have 5 first team CBs with only 3 to play. 2 LWBs, 1 RWB with Phillips and Ingram to cover. Mowatt and Livermore as first choice with Snoddy and Castro to cover and 6 forwards with only 3 who can play, and thats not including Zahore as he should'nt even be considered. As I say I would love a CM and I think we will get one now Sawyers has moved on. But Christ me poeple don't make out we are fodder outside the XI, when it just isn't the case.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
(08-27-2021, 01:24 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Field, Harper and Sawyers out with Mowatt, Molomby and Castro in.  Field's time had come and needed to move on and there is little doubt that neither of Sawyers or Harper would be suited to Valball.  Even with Molomby coming in a lot will depend on Snodgrass being able to complement in the middle.  Castro is the wildcard, and as much as it would be great to see him come through you'd hope he will be playing a very minor role.  Still feels one light  to me in midfield but we know the manager likes a small, tight squad.

Disagree about Field. Think it was a bit myopic to sell him, in the circumstances.
Reply
#14
(08-27-2021, 02:05 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(08-27-2021, 01:24 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Field, Harper and Sawyers out with Mowatt, Molomby and Castro in.  Field's time had come and needed to move on and there is little doubt that neither of Sawyers or Harper would be suited to Valball.  Even with Molomby coming in a lot will depend on Snodgrass being able to complement in the middle.  Castro is the wildcard, and as much as it would be great to see him come through you'd hope he will be playing a very minor role.  Still feels one light  to me in midfield but we know the manager likes a small, tight squad.

Disagree about Field. Think it was a bit myopic to sell him, in the circumstances.

He's injured, again. We did very well to get some money for him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: