A couple of random points
#31
(08-16-2021, 01:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:03 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 11:27 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 11:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 11:09 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Correct. So while the fee is undisclosed it’s still going to hit the books. That will tally against all the paperwork required at a footballing level. 

The posts above regarding billionaires and directors living in palatial homes are an absolute aside. The fee agreed will be the income that hits the books it will not be able to taken out the club. 

If the issue people are raising is ‘has Lai’s palm been greased’ then yeah probably. But not in a direct way affecting WBA (to be clear I know many feel the low fee is a result of this I personally think it’s basic market economics - he’s worth what people will pay and beholden to demand pricing) therefore no WBA monies can leave the club to Lai. 

On directors doing dodgy stuff, yeah it happens and can be done in a variety of ways depending how you set yourself up, what’s classed as business expenditure and who owns what assets where. Then there’s the illegality people attempt. 

That said this is a very public business (football) regulated in a very public way. Direct fraudulent monetary practices is difficult.

All correct.

I think the fact we have accepted an offer far below what MP is actually worth so that Lai can most probably recoup some investment through outside business deals and potential backhanders most certainly affects WBA. We should have been much firmer with how we sold a player we owned with 3 years left to run on his contract. Clubs get twitchy later in the window and the money is starting to trickle through to transfers - we blinked far too fast, and changed our stance far too quickly for there not to have been some motive at the top level for Lai to approve the transfer. 

Can you clarify how Lai is able to use our profitable stance (at a time when no club is making a profit) to make his loan disappear? Surely this counts as "taking money out of the club" as presumably the money was originally taken by JP and has accrued interest, but by clearing it through a dividend he's not only taking cash out at a time when the club needs it more than ever, but is failing to repay monies JP too?

Pereira Fee:

There is no empirical evidence to back up claims he is worth more than €20m. His contract was worth £13.5m so we’ve actually accrued profit against that. As Birdie says the Db which is very commonly used purported £17m but that doesn’t reflect a depressed market or the change in status to championship level. In addition the player wanted to go to Saudi and reap the 400k SAR (£77.5k) a week at near tax free as he was offered. Three factors here; 1. Even contact through intermediaries for EPL clubs suggested feeds of 8-10m. Late in the window this would have probably risen, but above £17m. Doubtful. 2. Leaving it late in the window would have meant no time to bring players in which we still intend to do, but having £20m rather than £17m would mean nothing if we couldn’t spend it 3. Above all and more importantly no EPL or European team is going to pay him £120k a week. No one. That’s the wage he’d have had to take to match the Al Hilal offer after tax. More so no one is going to pay him £77k. So what is the point holding out for more that probably won’t come when he wants to take the money in Saudi anyway? And the club did nearly get them to double their offer which was then accepted. 

Loan:

I have to say this is most puzzling and I can’t see the basis for S4As complaint. It is standard practice for a holding company to borrow from a subsidiary especially where the holding company only holds or accounts for a single subsidiary. It’s paper money in effect. Akin to moving money from savings to current account then claiming for loss of interest on the savings. 

The issue here is there is an unsubstantiated claim this money was used to consolidate the personal holdings of the former owner. If that is true and proven then that’s a different matter. However there is no proof. If the holding company used the money on behalf of the groups benefit then I can’t see an issue. Again it’s paper money. 

To your point; declaring a dividend then using that to repay the line doesn’t take money out it just moves money in the accounts to write off the debt. Like withdrawing £50 from the cash point and then paying it into the savings account and then transferring it back to the current account. The question on lost interest and the entirety of the loan is moot if he holding company used the money appropriately. I know many will question appropriately, but the crux is whether it was used to buy Peace more shares. As aforementioned we’ve seen no evidence just suspicion on this.
The trading company is £4.5m worse off.  Assuming the trading company to be the football club, then the asset (the loan owed) has been repaid out of the profits. 

They've taken the money out by way of dividend, then put it back to clear the loan.  A simple in and out transaction that has made the asset disappear.  It will all be on paper anyway without any physical cash movement.

The club is worse off by the value of the loan though.

As for Pereira, I don't believe for 1 second that the market dictates he's only worth £17m.  It's either very naive business or something else is going on.  I doubt the billionaire owners of PALM are quite that naive.  It would be interesting to know the owners of the business behind both clubs, their connections or third party connections and what business transactions are incurred through those over the course of the next couple of years...  It really wouldn't be difficult to shift some value into other means if both parties are open to it.  I can see the attraction for them, helps with FFP and the player comes with a bit of a discount and I can see the attraction to PALM, a chance to recoup a little of the sunk cost of their investment in the club.

CA - that’s not quite accurate on the loan. What was the loan used for? Where was it spent? How did it enrich the trading entity, or moreover the group. Why was it needed? Etc. There’s an assumption by Albion fans and S4A is was inappropriately spent and what evidence is there of this? 

On Pereira it’s like flogging a dead horse. Everyone keeps saying he’s worth more than this? Where’s the evidence? Bundesliga Rookie of the year 2018, unwanted by his parent club sells him to us for between 7-9m. Does something not sound right there? He was only worth that because there were other factors affecting his valuation. So the fact we’ve doubled the fee we paid isn’t terrible business.

Further to this of course the market dictates the fee. I can stick my house in the market for £1.5m it doesn’t mean someone will buy it if it’s worth half that much - especially if the searches flag up issues. Like they did when anyone asked for character references. Do I believe in a non Covid ear we’d have got €25m not €20m - yes of course I do. However we are in a pandemic, we needed to sell, the player demanded to go. If we’d have held out a year, and he had have further tarnished his reputation, plus a year less on the contract d have been far worse off.
Reply
#32
Not wanting to tag onto already long posts, but we have to let the Pereira thing go.

1)It wasn't a sellers market
2)The player didn't fit the style of the manager as stated in the Athletic
3)The player's main concern was getting the highest wages possible.

I think we did well getting it sorted quickly and avoiding a tedious aga.
Reply
#33
The club made it clear they did not NEED to sell after the relegation and we would have a strong budget (wages more tan transfer fees). SO whilst I understand the current climate, slow transfer market, no character references, etc, etc, etc.

But it boils down to a footballing decision, also. If he did go for a fee of 17 million, and that 17 million gets spent between now and September, on players that improve he squad on the whole, and have resale potential, fine. If it doesn't, and we have either folded at the first bit of pressure form player/agent/interested club (delete as appropriate), its a complete and utter shit show.

I keep reading about a player only being worth what somebody is willing to pay. What about what he is worth to the club he's at? Double figures goal return in the Prem in a shit crap team, a hatful of assists to boot. Got us promoted borderline single handedly before and there's no reason to believe he wouldn't have done so again. A sulking Pereira on a 4 year deal would know that he will ruin his career if he played hardball, if the club were tough enough (Daniel Levy style), and would eventually play, and contribute. He was worth a lot more than £17 million to us, just at the greasy one was worth more than 50 million to them lot!

The reality is there's 3 scenarios;

1) Val made an example of him for the greater good of his philosophy and told the club he wasn't going to be involved, and wanted him gone and didn't care either way.

2) The club are doing some back handed shit with the Saudis and circumnavigating the rules to line their pockets through alternative payments.

3) The club shit the bed and took an offer too early as they crumbled like Sick Vics hamstrings, as they are completely clueless from a football perspective, and just saw; Signed for 8.5mill + Sold for 17mill = Double our money. And, in this case we will have to wait to see what business is done before the end of the window before slamming them too much.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#34
Definately 1.

I do worry part of 2 may be true.

Not 3. Honestly, at first the club were really keen on much more and were prepared to hold. It was football people that made it clear it wasn't going to end how we wanted it too, and in the circumstances, it was the best we could do.
Reply
#35
Oh, trust me on this.

Pereira doesn't give a shit about his career. It is literally all about the money, he'd have sulked happily for 4 years if needed.

As said, there's a reason the only staff member who has anything remotely positive to say about him is Bilic.
Reply
#36
I think a lot of the frustration around the Pereira deal is that it’s being approached in that we let the buying club and the player dictate his value when we should only be selling a player when his value to us is met and at this moment in time, we haven’t seen any value in return for losing our best player.

If we spend the £17m mooted on 3-4 players who can improve our team, and we can hopefully improve and either use to get back into the PL or earn us a substantial profit in future windows then we were right to let him go, but the fact is that despite knowing he was likely to leave, and despite knowing the positions we need to strengthen in, nothing has yet happened.

If by the end of the window weve plugged the gaps and have a squad that puts us in a better short term position than having even a half motivated MP in the side, and a better long term position in having saleable assets then the sale was a success, but if we use the money to pay André Gray’s wages for 12 months whilst watching Livermore and Snodgrass blow out of their arses in central midfield the question marks around his sale will never stop being raised.

Oh, and whilst I totally get the reasoning for his value being £17m, the fact we went from “he won’t be sold for less than £30m and can rot in the reserves” to “£17m will do” literally overnight screams of outside influence.


EDIT: thanks for the attempt at explaining the loan BB… though I think I’m siding with CA, although I really don’t understand how it works Big Grin

If someone could tell me how to move money from my current account to my savings account and make my whole mortgage debt vanish on paper that would be great.
Reply
#37
(08-16-2021, 05:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think a lot of the frustration around the Pereira deal is that it’s being approached in that we let the buying club and the player dictate his value when we should only be selling a player when his value to us is met and at this moment in time, we haven’t seen any value in return for losing our best player.

If we spend the £17m mooted on 3-4 players who can improve our team, and we can hopefully improve and either use to get back into the PL or earn us a substantial profit in future windows then we were right to let him go, but the fact is that despite knowing he was likely to leave, and despite knowing the positions we need to strengthen in, nothing has yet happened.

If by the end of the window weve plugged the gaps and have a squad that puts us in a better short term position than having even a half motivated MP in the side, and a better long term position in having saleable assets then the sale was a success, but if we use the money to pay André Gray’s wages for 12 months whilst watching Livermore and Snodgrass blow out of their arses in central midfield the question marks around his sale will never stop being raised.

Oh, and whilst I totally get the reasoning for his value being £17m, the fact we went from “he won’t be sold for less than £30m and can rot in the reserves” to “£17m will do” literally overnight screams of outside influence.


EDIT: thanks for the attempt at explaining the loan BB… though I think I’m siding with CA, although I really don’t understand how it works Big Grin

If someone could tell me how to move money from my current account to my savings account and make my whole mortgage debt vanish on paper that would be great.

Simple. Get Christian Purslow to do your accounts. Problem sorted.
Reply
#38
Ultimately the fee of £17m is a good return on investment and especially as Valball® doesn't allow for silky number 10's playing in the hole.

Valball® requires pace and tenacity upfront and pace and aggression in the middle of the park.

The £17m now needs to be reinvested. Plain and simple. We have money and this style of football requires a good deep squad. We don't have that in certain areas. So sell a player we don't need and buy players we most definitely need.

The clocks ticking.
Reply
#39
(08-16-2021, 02:26 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 01:03 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 11:27 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2021, 11:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: All correct.

I think the fact we have accepted an offer far below what MP is actually worth so that Lai can most probably recoup some investment through outside business deals and potential backhanders most certainly affects WBA. We should have been much firmer with how we sold a player we owned with 3 years left to run on his contract. Clubs get twitchy later in the window and the money is starting to trickle through to transfers - we blinked far too fast, and changed our stance far too quickly for there not to have been some motive at the top level for Lai to approve the transfer. 

Can you clarify how Lai is able to use our profitable stance (at a time when no club is making a profit) to make his loan disappear? Surely this counts as "taking money out of the club" as presumably the money was originally taken by JP and has accrued interest, but by clearing it through a dividend he's not only taking cash out at a time when the club needs it more than ever, but is failing to repay monies JP too?

Pereira Fee:

There is no empirical evidence to back up claims he is worth more than €20m. His contract was worth £13.5m so we’ve actually accrued profit against that. As Birdie says the Db which is very commonly used purported £17m but that doesn’t reflect a depressed market or the change in status to championship level. In addition the player wanted to go to Saudi and reap the 400k SAR (£77.5k) a week at near tax free as he was offered. Three factors here; 1. Even contact through intermediaries for EPL clubs suggested feeds of 8-10m. Late in the window this would have probably risen, but above £17m. Doubtful. 2. Leaving it late in the window would have meant no time to bring players in which we still intend to do, but having £20m rather than £17m would mean nothing if we couldn’t spend it 3. Above all and more importantly no EPL or European team is going to pay him £120k a week. No one. That’s the wage he’d have had to take to match the Al Hilal offer after tax. More so no one is going to pay him £77k. So what is the point holding out for more that probably won’t come when he wants to take the money in Saudi anyway? And the club did nearly get them to double their offer which was then accepted. 

Loan:

I have to say this is most puzzling and I can’t see the basis for S4As complaint. It is standard practice for a holding company to borrow from a subsidiary especially where the holding company only holds or accounts for a single subsidiary. It’s paper money in effect. Akin to moving money from savings to current account then claiming for loss of interest on the savings. 

The issue here is there is an unsubstantiated claim this money was used to consolidate the personal holdings of the former owner. If that is true and proven then that’s a different matter. However there is no proof. If the holding company used the money on behalf of the groups benefit then I can’t see an issue. Again it’s paper money. 

To your point; declaring a dividend then using that to repay the line doesn’t take money out it just moves money in the accounts to write off the debt. Like withdrawing £50 from the cash point and then paying it into the savings account and then transferring it back to the current account. The question on lost interest and the entirety of the loan is moot if he holding company used the money appropriately. I know many will question appropriately, but the crux is whether it was used to buy Peace more shares. As aforementioned we’ve seen no evidence just suspicion on this.
The trading company is £4.5m worse off.  Assuming the trading company to be the football club, then the asset (the loan owed) has been repaid out of the profits. 

They've taken the money out by way of dividend, then put it back to clear the loan.  A simple in and out transaction that has made the asset disappear.  It will all be on paper anyway without any physical cash movement.

The club is worse off by the value of the loan though.

As for Pereira, I don't believe for 1 second that the market dictates he's only worth £17m.  It's either very naive business or something else is going on.  I doubt the billionaire owners of PALM are quite that naive.  It would be interesting to know the owners of the business behind both clubs, their connections or third party connections and what business transactions are incurred through those over the course of the next couple of years...  It really wouldn't be difficult to shift some value into other means if both parties are open to it.  I can see the attraction for them, helps with FFP and the player comes with a bit of a discount and I can see the attraction to PALM, a chance to recoup a little of the sunk cost of their investment in the club.

CA - that’s not quite accurate on the loan. What was the loan used for? Where was it spent? How did it enrich the trading entity, or moreover the group. Why was it needed? Etc. There’s an assumption by Albion fans and S4A is was inappropriately spent and what evidence is there of this? 

It’s exactly accurate.  Do the double entry and tell me how the club isn’t £4.5m down on the balance sheet.

Was it an asset in the company accounts - yes.

Have they paid it off via a dividend - yes (so we’re told).

It was a hang over from JRPs days, no idea why £4.5 was loaned up to holdings, but if it’s been paid off as reported, i.e. via dividend, the balance sheet has dropped by £4.5m.

The group position won’t change, but I’m assuming we’re talking about the football club not the shenanigans of why we have a holding company.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#40
(08-12-2021, 12:29 PM)Rom2021 Wrote: Johnstone- find it bizarre that arsenal arn't in for him now they have pulled out of the Ramsdale deal for half the price .. Alex Crook reckons they wont revisit Johnstone. Although great news for us.


Dike - this is a no brainer of a deal, knows the system, knows VI, Mowett etc , young , clearly knows where the net is. sign on a loan with a view to a perm if we get promoted.

If we cant get this deal over the line , then its clear that the Periera money is on its way to China.

Orlando don't want to let him go as they can't get a replacement this late in their season.

(08-12-2021, 12:36 PM)MassDebater Wrote: here's a couple of random points.
[Image: how-to-point-out-mistakes-made-when-spea....jpg?w=640]

[Image: file-20180220-116368-j2k6gq.jpg?ixlib=rb...0&fit=crop]

Jailbird Ronnie Wallwork wants a word....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: