The starting 11 has been confirmed
#21
(08-05-2021, 10:24 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
CA Baggie Wrote:
baggiebloke Wrote:Just need the sub humans...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-58094408

I think we all rightly condemn them.  Also 207 comments is 207 too many.

Here’s the “but”.  “Racist Uk” and “rotten to the core” transpires to be 34 people out of how many millions of us?

I think the fact it was 34 people and the way people in general reacted to those, without the hyperbole of those type of comments above, shows we’ve come a long, long way.

We’re not there yet, I doubt we’ll ever have true equity (sadly that’s just the inability of man to not crave power of some sort), but we’re inching closer and closer.

Comments like “rotten to the core” do more harm than good in these situations.

This in bucket loads.

Right from the off I said as a percentage the figure would be utterly minuscule, but a news agenda is then set up to blow this story of racism on every front page. There will always be idiots, but sadly the focus on the story after the Euros will have many thinking we’ve a racism problem when the figures show we haven’t.

Social media allows every moron a comment. These numbskulls will always be in society.

I know i sparked it with my initials comments but to say we don't have a racism problem is not true, I was merely highlighting the mass hysteria and news coverage which blows things like this out of context and doesn't help the equality cause on the bigger issues.  I think the vast majority of the general public get along fine and there's little day to day casual racism in an Alf Garnet style.  It still seeps through the corridors of power though, as it does from the elite when dealing with the working class.  There's still a reason why a black person is more likely to face prosecution, more likely to get a heavier sentece, more likely to be paid less, more likely to be overlooked for promotion and loads more that Fuzzbox could probably tell you.  As my nephew tells me he gets followed in shops by security whilst watching they're not following the white chap that walked in.  How do you think that makes him feel?

Fuzzbox - 600 posts were reviewed and 207 were found to be racist, no doubt there were more unreported as you say but when it's 34 people from the UK it shows how far we've come.

We have come a long way and I would be happy to agree that the media sensationalises stories. One of the problems with their approach is that it causes people to go the other way and 'minimise' stories.  In that vein, I think you might be relying on this as some sort of defining statistic when in reality, it isn't.

1) 600 posts were reviewed. Out of how many? How did they get that sample?
2) How did they decide what was racist? Was it what was prosecutable or what was on balance of probability? For instance, if I called you an 'Irish bastard' that may not be prosecutable because I didn't attribute any negative association DIRECTLY with the word 'Irish'. I could argue I was just distinguishing you in the same way as saying 'dark-haired'. I was probably being 'racist' but it's doubtful it's a prosecutable offence that the cps would take on.
3) To send a high profile athlete a racist message is very stupid. You are likely to be identified. Therefore, this statistic is not indicative of the number of racists, it's the amount of incredibly stupid (and probably drunk) racists
4) They are more likely to be foreign because of No 3. If you're foreign, you're probably not aware of the risk you're taking. Equally, that risk was also smaller. How much less likely are you to be arrested or publically shamed if you're based outside of the UK? Had the UK police force even chosen to pursue them before?
5) Is racism even the same in other countries? Eg anti-irish discrimination. Does it have the same meaning in say Lithuania, where there is no knowledge of the Potato Famine or the hundreds of years of intimidation and abuse? Should we expect someone from Singapore to have the same knowledge of race relations and all the historical 'issues'?  Is their 'racism' even the same? Should we judge them the same?
6) Even a racist knows that it's not a good idea to be racist in public. That doesn't mean they are not racist.
7) I don't 'like' certain people. That doesn't mean I feel the need to tweet to them to voice my disapproval. I still don't 'like' them, though.

I'm sorry for your nephew's experience - I don't get that anymore. Maybe it's because I'm old and mostly wear a suit or 'smart clothes'. I had hoped that sort of thing had stopped. Maybe though, because it doesn't affect me, I probably just haven't noticed it.

To me, your nephew's experience is a more serious thing and more indicative of racism than drunken racist tweets sent by idiots to a 'celebrity'.

I don't mean this snidely, but surely that should be the focus of your attention rather than whether racism in this country is overblown?

Presumably 600 that were reported?

I think you’re confusing your point between myself and Spandau.  I think the reaction to the racist tweets was OTT when you see that it’s come down to 34 people.  If it was 340 people that’s still a tiny amount and shows how far we’ve come, the outpouring of support was great to see.

I think the fact that I’ve highlighted where the true racism comes in shows my attention is not on the “overblown” element.  My point was that the reaction to those tweets was overblown not the level of racism.  

The reaction and sensationalised stories around the tweets followed by 34 people does the battle against racism no help whatsoever.  Comments like “rotten to the core” followed by those numbers gives ammunition to racists “see they’re all too over sensitive”, “can’t say nothing these days” and  “woke/political correctness gone mad” will be all over the Tommy Robinson lovers Facebook pages.

As for my nephew, he marched for BLM and before he left the Uk (he now works in Europe for a US company) decked a Romanian chap at work for calling him a “black bastard”.  Sadly he knows now that’s the world we live in but is still fighting for it to be a better place.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#22
[quote="CA Baggie" pid='375621' dateline='1628170352']

I think you’re confusing your point between myself and Spandau. [/qoute]

You're right I did. I thought it made no sense! Apologies to you both!

Oh and I agree with your point about hyperbolic reporting actually causing more problems than they solve. 

When I read this type of 'news' I always sigh - I know exactly what's coming next....

As I've said before the news and indeed the whole story of anti-racism should include the substantial 'white input' to equality because

1) It's true
2) It stops it being an us against them
3) It shows it's a people problem which we ALL need to solve.

On a personal level, I expect Black people to be anti-racist (probably a little unfair, I know). But when a man stands up against sexism, or an able-bodied against disability discrimination or a white man against racism, to me they are the real heroes.

They could have walked away, but they didn't.

I know people rile against 'White Saviours' and 'white fragility' but to me, that's the least of our (societies) problems.

Say it quietly, but things are getting better, despite all the moaning. I'm talking about everyone's rights - women, disabilities, gender.

But, I don't think it's 'fixed' in place. It might only take a recession to slip backwards....
Reply
#23
(08-05-2021, 01:32 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:24 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
CA Baggie Wrote:I think we all rightly condemn them.  Also 207 comments is 207 too many.

Here’s the “but”.  “Racist Uk” and “rotten to the core” transpires to be 34 people out of how many millions of us?

I think the fact it was 34 people and the way people in general reacted to those, without the hyperbole of those type of comments above, shows we’ve come a long, long way.

We’re not there yet, I doubt we’ll ever have true equity (sadly that’s just the inability of man to not crave power of some sort), but we’re inching closer and closer.

Comments like “rotten to the core” do more harm than good in these situations.

This in bucket loads.

Right from the off I said as a percentage the figure would be utterly minuscule, but a news agenda is then set up to blow this story of racism on every front page. There will always be idiots, but sadly the focus on the story after the Euros will have many thinking we’ve a racism problem when the figures show we haven’t.

Social media allows every moron a comment. These numbskulls will always be in society.

I know i sparked it with my initials comments but to say we don't have a racism problem is not true, I was merely highlighting the mass hysteria and news coverage which blows things like this out of context and doesn't help the equality cause on the bigger issues.  I think the vast majority of the general public get along fine and there's little day to day casual racism in an Alf Garnet style.  It still seeps through the corridors of power though, as it does from the elite when dealing with the working class.  There's still a reason why a black person is more likely to face prosecution, more likely to get a heavier sentece, more likely to be paid less, more likely to be overlooked for promotion and loads more that Fuzzbox could probably tell you.  As my nephew tells me he gets followed in shops by security whilst watching they're not following the white chap that walked in.  How do you think that makes him feel?

Fuzzbox - 600 posts were reviewed and 207 were found to be racist, no doubt there were more unreported as you say but when it's 34 people from the UK it shows how far we've come.

We have come a long way and I would be happy to agree that the media sensationalises stories. One of the problems with their approach is that it causes people to go the other way and 'minimise' stories.  In that vein, I think you might be relying on this as some sort of defining statistic when in reality, it isn't.

1) 600 posts were reviewed. Out of how many? How did they get that sample?
2) How did they decide what was racist? Was it what was prosecutable or what was on balance of probability? For instance, if I called you an 'Irish bastard' that may not be prosecutable because I didn't attribute any negative association DIRECTLY with the word 'Irish'. I could argue I was just distinguishing you in the same way as saying 'dark-haired'. I was probably being 'racist' but it's doubtful it's a prosecutable offence that the cps would take on.
3) To send a high profile athlete a racist message is very stupid. You are likely to be identified. Therefore, this statistic is not indicative of the number of racists, it's the amount of incredibly stupid (and probably drunk) racists
4) They are more likely to be foreign because of No 3. If you're foreign, you're probably not aware of the risk you're taking. Equally, that risk was also smaller. How much less likely are you to be arrested or publically shamed if you're based outside of the UK? Had the UK police force even chosen to pursue them before?
5) Is racism even the same in other countries? Eg anti-irish discrimination. Does it have the same meaning in say Lithuania, where there is no knowledge of the Potato Famine or the hundreds of years of intimidation and abuse? Should we expect someone from Singapore to have the same knowledge of race relations and all the historical 'issues'?  Is their 'racism' even the same? Should we judge them the same?
6) Even a racist knows that it's not a good idea to be racist in public. That doesn't mean they are not racist.
7) I don't 'like' certain people. That doesn't mean I feel the need to tweet to them to voice my disapproval. I still don't 'like' them, though.

I'm sorry for your nephew's experience - I don't get that anymore. Maybe it's because I'm old and mostly wear a suit or 'smart clothes'. I had hoped that sort of thing had stopped. Maybe though, because it doesn't affect me, I probably just haven't noticed it.

To me, your nephew's experience is a more serious thing and more indicative of racism than drunken racist tweets sent by idiots to a 'celebrity'.

I don't mean this snidely, but surely that should be the focus of your attention rather than whether racism in this country is overblown?

Presumably 600 that were reported?

I think you’re confusing your point between myself and Spandau.  I think the reaction to the racist tweets was OTT when you see that it’s come down to 34 people.  If it was 340 people that’s still a tiny amount and shows how far we’ve come, the outpouring of support was great to see.

I think the fact that I’ve highlighted where the true racism comes in shows my attention is not on the “overblown” element.  My point was that the reaction to those tweets was overblown not the level of racism.  

The reaction and sensationalised stories around the tweets followed by 34 people does the battle against racism no help whatsoever.  Comments like “rotten to the core” followed by those numbers gives ammunition to racists “see they’re all too over sensitive”, “can’t say nothing these days” and  “woke/political correctness gone mad” will be all over the Tommy Robinson lovers Facebook pages.

As for my nephew, he marched for BLM and before he left the Uk (he now works in Europe for a US company) decked a Romanian chap at work for calling him a “black bastard”.  Sadly he knows now that’s the world we live in but is still fighting for it to be a better place.

Just to elaborate on my message, which was quickly off my phone first this morning, I think it does need clarity. We do have a racial problem, of course virtually all countries do, ours is far less than most are, and my point is that in an age where critical thinking is virtually defunct, the absence of putting into perspective with the number of social media posts, the racist ones, creates a narrative that heaps of people are racially abusing players, when probably less than 1 in 10,000 people on social media were stupid/vile enough to abuse the 3 players.

The media reporting creates a vision where a black inner city kid might think millions of white people are aggressively racist, where a neighbourhood like mine, middle class, rural fringes is the sort of place where we are closet KKK people (worth pointing out the neighbour 3 doors up is West Indian, by the way, in a mixed race family.

So much good has been done over decades, and what is a racist crime now, a vile comment said or typed anonymously into a computer, is a world different from black kids and asian kids being booted to bits and spat on as they were in the 70s. Without using perspective correctly it creates a totally knee-jerk, immature and disjointed dialogue on the issue. Of course, such things shouldn't happen, but get real- the world will always have pond life and we've come on leaps and bounds since bananas being thrown at matches a generation ago.

The media reporting, in my opinion, after the Euros was very unhelpful for race relations. It's worth adding, now the numbers are out there is very little in the media about this and many scared ethnic kids who need to know this won't know it.
Reply
#24
(08-05-2021, 02:51 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 01:32 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:24 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:04 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:This in bucket loads.

Right from the off I said as a percentage the figure would be utterly minuscule, but a news agenda is then set up to blow this story of racism on every front page. There will always be idiots, but sadly the focus on the story after the Euros will have many thinking we’ve a racism problem when the figures show we haven’t.

Social media allows every moron a comment. These numbskulls will always be in society.

I know i sparked it with my initials comments but to say we don't have a racism problem is not true, I was merely highlighting the mass hysteria and news coverage which blows things like this out of context and doesn't help the equality cause on the bigger issues.  I think the vast majority of the general public get along fine and there's little day to day casual racism in an Alf Garnet style.  It still seeps through the corridors of power though, as it does from the elite when dealing with the working class.  There's still a reason why a black person is more likely to face prosecution, more likely to get a heavier sentece, more likely to be paid less, more likely to be overlooked for promotion and loads more that Fuzzbox could probably tell you.  As my nephew tells me he gets followed in shops by security whilst watching they're not following the white chap that walked in.  How do you think that makes him feel?

Fuzzbox - 600 posts were reviewed and 207 were found to be racist, no doubt there were more unreported as you say but when it's 34 people from the UK it shows how far we've come.

We have come a long way and I would be happy to agree that the media sensationalises stories. One of the problems with their approach is that it causes people to go the other way and 'minimise' stories.  In that vein, I think you might be relying on this as some sort of defining statistic when in reality, it isn't.

1) 600 posts were reviewed. Out of how many? How did they get that sample?
2) How did they decide what was racist? Was it what was prosecutable or what was on balance of probability? For instance, if I called you an 'Irish bastard' that may not be prosecutable because I didn't attribute any negative association DIRECTLY with the word 'Irish'. I could argue I was just distinguishing you in the same way as saying 'dark-haired'. I was probably being 'racist' but it's doubtful it's a prosecutable offence that the cps would take on.
3) To send a high profile athlete a racist message is very stupid. You are likely to be identified. Therefore, this statistic is not indicative of the number of racists, it's the amount of incredibly stupid (and probably drunk) racists
4) They are more likely to be foreign because of No 3. If you're foreign, you're probably not aware of the risk you're taking. Equally, that risk was also smaller. How much less likely are you to be arrested or publically shamed if you're based outside of the UK? Had the UK police force even chosen to pursue them before?
5) Is racism even the same in other countries? Eg anti-irish discrimination. Does it have the same meaning in say Lithuania, where there is no knowledge of the Potato Famine or the hundreds of years of intimidation and abuse? Should we expect someone from Singapore to have the same knowledge of race relations and all the historical 'issues'?  Is their 'racism' even the same? Should we judge them the same?
6) Even a racist knows that it's not a good idea to be racist in public. That doesn't mean they are not racist.
7) I don't 'like' certain people. That doesn't mean I feel the need to tweet to them to voice my disapproval. I still don't 'like' them, though.

I'm sorry for your nephew's experience - I don't get that anymore. Maybe it's because I'm old and mostly wear a suit or 'smart clothes'. I had hoped that sort of thing had stopped. Maybe though, because it doesn't affect me, I probably just haven't noticed it.

To me, your nephew's experience is a more serious thing and more indicative of racism than drunken racist tweets sent by idiots to a 'celebrity'.

I don't mean this snidely, but surely that should be the focus of your attention rather than whether racism in this country is overblown?

Presumably 600 that were reported?

I think you’re confusing your point between myself and Spandau.  I think the reaction to the racist tweets was OTT when you see that it’s come down to 34 people.  If it was 340 people that’s still a tiny amount and shows how far we’ve come, the outpouring of support was great to see.

I think the fact that I’ve highlighted where the true racism comes in shows my attention is not on the “overblown” element.  My point was that the reaction to those tweets was overblown not the level of racism.  

The reaction and sensationalised stories around the tweets followed by 34 people does the battle against racism no help whatsoever.  Comments like “rotten to the core” followed by those numbers gives ammunition to racists “see they’re all too over sensitive”, “can’t say nothing these days” and  “woke/political correctness gone mad” will be all over the Tommy Robinson lovers Facebook pages.

As for my nephew, he marched for BLM and before he left the Uk (he now works in Europe for a US company) decked a Romanian chap at work for calling him a “black bastard”.  Sadly he knows now that’s the world we live in but is still fighting for it to be a better place.

Just to elaborate on my message, which was quickly off my phone first this morning, I think it does need clarity. We do have a racial problem, of course virtually all countries do, ours is far less than most are, and my point is that in an age where critical thinking is virtually defunct, the absence of putting into perspective with the number of social media posts, the racist ones, creates a narrative that heaps of people are racially abusing players, when probably less than 1 in 10,000 people on social media were stupid/vile enough to abuse the 3 players.

The media reporting creates a vision where a black inner city kid might think millions of white people are aggressively racist, where a neighbourhood like mine, middle class, rural fringes is the sort of place where we are closet KKK people (worth pointing out the neighbour 3 doors up is West Indian, by the way, in a mixed race family.

So much good has been done over decades, and what is a racist crime now, a vile comment said or typed anonymously into a computer, is a world different from black kids and asian kids being booted to bits and spat on as they were in the 70s. Without using perspective correctly it creates a totally knee-jerk, immature and disjointed dialogue on the issue. Of course, such things shouldn't happen, but get real- the world will always have pond life and we've come on leaps and bounds since bananas being thrown at matches a generation ago.

The media reporting, in my opinion, after the Euros was very unhelpful for race relations. It's worth adding, now the numbers are out there is very little in the media about this and many scared ethnic kids who need to know this won't know it.

Yes, Alf.

;-)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: