Sam Field
#11
I can't hold anythung against Brown for leaving. It was potentially a great opportunity. If you were a youth player with a similar-sized club as we were then and Chelsea came-in offering to set you up for life, would you not take it?
Reply
#12
(07-23-2021, 09:58 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: I can't hold anythung against Brown for leaving. It was potentially a great opportunity. If you were a youth player with a similar-sized club as we were then and Chelsea came-in offering to set you up for life, would you not take it?

You wouldn’t, which I why I’ve never understood the animosity towards him on here.
Reply
#13
(07-23-2021, 04:04 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Disappointed for the lad.

Izzy Brown did his cruciate last week as well and is out until deep in to next year.

Thorne, Field, Izzy…some of our kids have sole rotten luck.

Yeah, some have been forced to sign for Villa.
Reply
#14
(07-23-2021, 09:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(07-23-2021, 09:34 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Not had the best of fortune,  but their choice to leave. 

A reasonable £3m in hindsight for 3 players who have proven to not be quite good enough.

I think they all had a chance if circumstances were different. Real football isn't a computer game with numbered attributes. However for all 3.

Izzy Brown. Chased the money and the dream if playing with superstars, didn't stand out in a very, very talented youth team, then injuries hit.

George Thorne. Certainly had potential, remember his debut at Old Trafford, looked so comfortable. Got frustrated being behind Yacob and Mulumbu, which was totally correct, and then... Injuries hit once he moved.

Sam Field. In many ways was the most promising of these three. Never let Pulis down, but his caution at playing youth when experience was available meant he struggled for a run of games. Due to his play style needs a lot of experience before we see him near his best. An inability to force himself ahead of experienced players in training, and injuries whenever it looked like he could ruined him. Pardew annihilated his confidence which seemed to affect him badly too, not a great sign tbf.

In different circumstances they could have made it here. O'Shea and Ferguson never looked fantastic in youth football, not looking like they'd make it at our level, both got a chance, stayed fit, got long runs in the team. Attitude and luck play as much a part as talent.

And if my Aunty had...

Simply not good enough.

Sam had reasonable opportunities,  the others jumped ship.  The only one I have any sympathy for....

Brown is just not worth a second's attention, took the money at 16 (or his Family did) .  

Thorne - not prepared to knuckle down and await his opportunity.  Was not good enough at the time...
Reply
#15
(07-24-2021, 12:17 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-23-2021, 09:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(07-23-2021, 09:34 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Not had the best of fortune,  but their choice to leave. 

A reasonable £3m in hindsight for 3 players who have proven to not be quite good enough.

I think they all had a chance if circumstances were different. Real football isn't a computer game with numbered attributes. However for all 3.

Izzy Brown. Chased the money and the dream if playing with superstars, didn't stand out in a very, very talented youth team, then injuries hit.

George Thorne. Certainly had potential, remember his debut at Old Trafford, looked so comfortable. Got frustrated being behind Yacob and Mulumbu, which was totally correct, and then... Injuries hit once he moved.

Sam Field. In many ways was the most promising of these three. Never let Pulis down, but his caution at playing youth when experience was available meant he struggled for a run of games. Due to his play style needs a lot of experience before we see him near his best. An inability to force himself ahead of experienced players in training, and injuries whenever it looked like he could ruined him. Pardew annihilated his confidence which seemed to affect him badly too, not a great sign tbf.

In different circumstances they could have made it here. O'Shea and Ferguson never looked fantastic in youth football, not looking like they'd make it at our level, both got a chance, stayed fit, got long runs in the team. Attitude and luck play as much a part as talent.

And if my Aunty had...

Simply not good enough.

Sam had reasonable opportunities,  the others jumped ship.  The only one I have any sympathy for....

Brown is just not worth a second's attention, took the money at 16 (or his Family did) .  

Thorne - not prepared to knuckle down and await his opportunity.  Was not good enough at the time...

Way to completely miss my point.
Reply
#16
(07-23-2021, 09:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ferguson never looked fantastic in youth football

Disagree 100%. As someone who regularly watches the U23's and the youth team when possible it was always clear that Ferguson was a cut above, right from the first time I saw him. The only doubt about him was his height for a centre back. Problem sorted with his move to full back.
Reply
#17
(07-24-2021, 08:18 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(07-23-2021, 09:47 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ferguson never looked fantastic in youth football

Disagree 100%. As someone who regularly watches the U23's and the youth team when possible it was always clear that Ferguson was a cut above, right from the first time I saw him. The only doubt about him was his height for a centre back. Problem sorted with his move to full back.

Cheers.

I was often told the opposite, I didn't watch much of it, so I'll bow to what you said, but even that doesn't totally behave my point, in his case, a position change helped. How often would that help a player but the manager doesn't see it?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: