The case for Appleton
#31
Lampard had an incredibly strong side at Derby but they were streaky as hell, always felt like the team was playing well in spite of him.

At Chelsea he did OK, but his absolute kid in a sweet shop mentality in the transfer market this summer, and inability to sort a defence out in 2 years which Tuchel fixed within days of arriving doesn’t inspire confidence.
Reply
#32
Lampard erm no!!
Reply
#33
(05-20-2021, 09:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Lampard had an incredibly strong side at Derby but they were streaky as hell, always felt like the team was playing well in spite of him.

At Chelsea he did OK, but his absolute kid in a sweet shop mentality in the transfer market this summer, and inability to sort a defence out in 2 years which Tuchel fixed within days of arriving doesn’t inspire confidence.

Yes- a big name based on his career, but no real CV worth considering. Both he and Di Matteo got the Chelsea job too early.

As we know with Robbie D, he was in the right place at the right time so got a Champions League feather in his cap, much in the same way as Tony Barton did with our fishy friends all those years ago.

The more I think about it, I can just see this being a two horse race between Wilder and Appleton. I would add that I think we'd cough up £700k if we thought Appy was worth it, when we look at that in the equation of a transfer fee where we wouldn't quibble over a couple of million in an era where decent players cost several million at least.
Reply
#34
(05-21-2021, 04:52 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-20-2021, 09:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Lampard had an incredibly strong side at Derby but they were streaky as hell, always felt like the team was playing well in spite of him.

At Chelsea he did OK, but his absolute kid in a sweet shop mentality in the transfer market this summer, and inability to sort a defence out in 2 years which Tuchel fixed within days of arriving doesn’t inspire confidence.

Yes- a big name based on his career, but no real CV worth considering. Both he and Di Matteo got the Chelsea job too early.

As we know with Robbie D, he was in the right place at the right time so got a Champions League feather in his cap, much in the same way as Tony Barton did with our fishy friends all those years ago.

The more I think about it, I can just see this being a two horse race between Wilder and Appleton. I would add that I think we'd cough up £700k if we thought Appy was worth it, when we look at that in the equation of a transfer fee where we wouldn't quibble over a couple of million in an era where decent players cost several million at least.

So Lampard doesn’t have a CV worth considering, yet Appy does?

Other than playing for us, please tell me how Appys career makes him worth considering.
Reply
#35
Appleton's last two jobs at Oxford and now Lincoln shows he knows how to improve clubs considerably. Lampard took a Derby side that finished in the play offs and did the exact same thing except with loanees such as Mount, Wilson and Tomori. While at Chelsea there were reports that he stopped speaking to some of the players and that doesn't bode well in terms of his man management style. The improvement in Chelsea and some of the players he froze out speaks volumes. I'd say Appleton is a far better coach than Lampard too.
Reply
#36
(05-21-2021, 09:03 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Appleton's last two jobs at Oxford and now Lincoln shows he knows how to improve clubs considerably. Lampard took a Derby side that finished in the play offs and did the exact same thing except with loanees such as Mount, Wilson and Tomori. While at Chelsea there were reports that he stopped speaking to some of the players and that doesn't bode well in terms of his man management style. The improvement in Chelsea and some of the players he froze out speaks volumes. I'd say Appleton is a far better coach than Lampard too.

Lampard took Derby to the final in his year though. That’s further than they got the year before. So it was an improvement. As was their style of football. They wiped the foot with us twice that season and were the best team to visit us at our place that year. Mount, Wilson and co. weren’t the stars they are now. Decent young prospects that were unproven in that league. Lampard got the playing and had a big part in the players they are today.

He also got Chelsea back in the CL in his first season and started this with a 17 game unbeaten run. 

As stated elsewhere, the Chelsea job was too big/soon for him but with his eagerness, enthusiasm, contacts...we should at least be talking to him.
Reply
#37
(05-21-2021, 09:20 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(05-21-2021, 09:03 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Appleton's last two jobs at Oxford and now Lincoln shows he knows how to improve clubs considerably. Lampard took a Derby side that finished in the play offs and did the exact same thing except with loanees such as Mount, Wilson and Tomori. While at Chelsea there were reports that he stopped speaking to some of the players and that doesn't bode well in terms of his man management style. The improvement in Chelsea and some of the players he froze out speaks volumes. I'd say Appleton is a far better coach than Lampard too.

Lampard took Derby to the final in his year though. That’s further than they got the year before. So it was an improvement. As was their style of football. They wiped the foot with us twice that season and were the best team to visit us at our place that year. Mount, Wilson and co. weren’t the stars they are now. Decent young prospects that were unproven in that league. Lampard got the playing and had a big part in the players they are today.

He also got Chelsea back in the CL in his first season and started this with a 17 game unbeaten run. 

As stated elsewhere, the Chelsea job was too big/soon for him but with his eagerness, enthusiasm, contacts...we should at least be talking to him.

Have to agree to disagree on this one Dumbo. 

In Tomori and Mount they had arguably the best CB and best player in the division, you only have to see how much having Barnes and a fit Grealish carried us and Villa... even with Moore in charge, if we'd kept Barnes we'd have won promotion. Lampard had that and more and still only made the playoffs.

Also, looking at his transfer record there... he spent £6m on Martin Waghorn and a further £6m on Marriott and Jozefzoon... None of those players have been particularly successful.

I then look at his time at Chelsea and whilst they started strongly, the same weaknesses were there throughout his whole time. They were reliant on attacking players doing something special to win the game, not due to anything in particular the team did well. You only have to look at their improvement under Tuchel (who again I have some doubts about as an elite manager) to see why I'd have concerns about Lampard's ability to get the best out of our team and resources.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: