Appleton
#41
(02-27-2021, 10:08 AM)Wotty Wrote: ........I’m not sure BFS is a pull to anyone

Depends on how you look at it, his appointment with us definitely yanked a few chains Big Grin .
Reply
#42
(02-27-2021, 10:00 AM)Faggits Wrote: Whoever the coach is will be expected to deliver promotion on a shoestring with a few permanent but mainly loan signings , no disrespect to Appleton who may be a fantastic coach but if your a young player at a big club looking for a loan with a number of options on the table and someone like a Big Sam or a Lampard comes calling the lure of playing for them would be there , I’m not sure Appleton carries the same kind of gravitas .

Whoever is employed next season won’t be expected to win promotion on a shoe string. Every manager we have had in the Championship over the last 20 years has had one of, if not the, strongest budget in the division to work with and there is absolutely no reason to doubt that will be the case once again. 

Young players go where they’re told most of the time... they may give interviews saying they’ve always admired X, Y and Z,  but ultimately the parent clubs will assess the fees being offered, the facilities at the loan club and any relationship between the the managers/staff. Given the Championship will have had 12 months without any match day revenue, the very fact we could even contribute towards a loanees wages will give us the pick of the bunch... also, look at the squad at Lincoln, they have players are on loan from clubs like Spurs and Man City. If Jose and Pep think players can develop under Appleton that’s a much better endorsement than relying on the fact people admired Lampard.

I get the clamour for a steady hand like Allardyce, but he has done absolutely nothing deserving of the job next season here yet. We’re worse off under him in every conceivable metric than we were under Bilic, he needs to demonstrate a little more than half a point a game before he should even be considered to manage in the Champ for the first time in a decade. 

And Lampard. Fuck off.
Reply
#43
There seems to be a feeling among some that Allardyce or a similarly experienced coach will provide a better chance of an immediate return next season, but how many times do we see clubs fall into this trap? It's what keeps the same old names forever riding the managerial merry-go-round. 

Based on recent history, it's quite clear that having lots of experience or having managed in / gained promotion from The Championship previously shouldn't be a prerequisite to making an managerial appointment. Looking at this season and the previous couple the following managers have all placed in the top 6 or are on course to; Farke (twice), Frank (twice), Cooper (twice) Paunovic, Parker, Harris, Wilder, Smith & Lampard. None of these would be considered experienced managers at Championship level or higher. In the same time period the only managers to have finished in the top 6 that are experienced coaches are Bielsa and Bilic.

This isn't to say that Allardyce or someone similar wouldn't be successful, rather that someone of that ilk is no more likely to succeed than someone with less experience. In terms of safe hands at Championship level, both Warnock and McCarthy are still proving to be effective managers at 'Boro and Cardiff respectively, however they are very much the outliers. Most managers have a natural shelf-life, the way that game evolves renders some of them less relevant if they don't adapt. There is also the motivation and hunger to keep going which is something which worries me about Allardyce. 

Personally I'd like to see somebody who's career is on an upward trajectory and could grow with the club, this is actually more likely to provide a better chance of survival were we to be promoted again, think Howe, Smith, Wilder (yes, this season I know), and perhaps Parker. In addition to those you've got Farke who is odds-on to bring Norwich back and I have no doubt they'll be stronger next time. 

With this in mind I'd hope we were looking at the likes of Appleton (who would be my pick) and Cook who have been discussed here in the last couple of days, but also Valerien Ismael at Barnsley, Mark Robins at Coventry and Ryan Lowe at Plymouth. There are plenty of others in the EFL that are promising, as well as abroad if we're willing to think a bit differently.
Reply
#44
(02-27-2021, 02:20 PM)OmarLittle Wrote: There seems to be a feeling among some that Allardyce or a similarly experienced coach will provide a better chance of an immediate return next season, but how many times do we see clubs fall into this trap? It's what keeps the same old names forever riding the managerial merry-go-round. 

Based on recent history, it's quite clear that having lots of experience or having managed in / gained promotion from The Championship previously shouldn't be a prerequisite to making an managerial appointment. Looking at this season and the previous couple the following managers have all placed in the top 6 or are on course to; Farke (twice), Frank (twice), Cooper (twice) Paunovic, Parker, Harris, Wilder, Smith & Lampard. None of these would be considered experienced managers at Championship level or higher. In the same time period the only managers to have finished in the top 6 that are experienced coaches are Bielsa and Bilic.

This isn't to say that Allardyce or someone similar wouldn't be successful, rather that someone of that ilk is no more likely to succeed than someone with less experience. In terms of safe hands at Championship level, both Warnock and McCarthy are still proving to be effective managers at 'Boro and Cardiff respectively, however they are very much the outliers. Most managers have a natural shelf-life, the way that game evolves renders some of them less relevant if they don't adapt. There is also the motivation and hunger to keep going which is something which worries me about Allardyce. 

Personally I'd like to see somebody who's career is on an upward trajectory and could grow with the club, this is actually more likely to provide a better chance of survival were we to be promoted again, think Howe, Smith, Wilder (yes, this season I know), and perhaps Parker. In addition to those you've got Farke who is odds-on to bring Norwich back and I have no doubt they'll be stronger next time. 

With this in mind I'd hope we were looking at the likes of Appleton (who would be my pick) and Cook who have been discussed here in the last couple of days, but also Valerien Ismael at Barnsley, Mark Robins at Coventry and Ryan Lowe at Plymouth. There are plenty of others in the EFL that are promising, as well as abroad if we're willing to think a bit differently.

Talking sense is not what this bored is for.  Do one.
Reply
#45
OmarLittle Wrote:There seems to be a feeling among some that Allardyce or a similarly experienced coach will provide a better chance of an immediate return next season, but how many times do we see clubs fall into this trap? It's what keeps the same old names forever riding the managerial merry-go-round. 

Based on recent history, it's quite clear that having lots of experience or having managed in / gained promotion from The Championship previously shouldn't be a prerequisite to making an managerial appointment. Looking at this season and the previous couple the following managers have all placed in the top 6 or are on course to; Farke (twice), Frank (twice), Cooper (twice) Paunovic, Parker, Harris, Wilder, Smith & Lampard. None of these would be considered experienced managers at Championship level or higher. In the same time period the only managers to have finished in the top 6 that are experienced coaches are Bielsa and Bilic.

This isn't to say that Allardyce or someone similar wouldn't be successful, rather that someone of that ilk is no more likely to succeed than someone with less experience. In terms of safe hands at Championship level, both Warnock and McCarthy are still proving to be effective managers at 'Boro and Cardiff respectively, however they are very much the outliers. Most managers have a natural shelf-life, the way that game evolves renders some of them less relevant if they don't adapt. There is also the motivation and hunger to keep going which is something which worries me about Allardyce. 

Personally I'd like to see somebody who's career is on an upward trajectory and could grow with the club, this is actually more likely to provide a better chance of survival were we to be promoted again, think Howe, Smith, Wilder (yes, this season I know), and perhaps Parker. In addition to those you've got Farke who is odds-on to bring Norwich back and I have no doubt they'll be stronger next time. 

With this in mind I'd hope we were looking at the likes of Appleton (who would be my pick) and Cook who have been discussed here in the last couple of days, but also Valerien Ismael at Barnsley, Mark Robins at Coventry and Ryan Lowe at Plymouth. There are plenty of others in the EFL that are promising, as well as abroad if we're willing to think a bit differently.

Good post.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: