Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
01-27-2021, 08:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-27-2021, 08:52 PM by Lillwall's left foot.)
I've been a fan of Gibbs but have to admit that although his touch and athletesism make him LOOK like a good full back he just isnt. I was low down in the East Stand for a season so had him yards away 45 mins each game. He stopped at best 50% of the crosses coming in from his side and is poor in the air defensively. Again looks good going forward but despite the odd goal contributes few crosses.
Townsend LOOKS ungainly at times and doesn't seem as quick as Gibbs, but might very well be. He's commited in the tackle and although not tall uses his body well to be competitive in the air. He has improved immensely and is not given credit for the quality of his delivery, occasionally he puts in an absolute peach. Is he PL quality? probably not, but time will tell with continued improvement. Should be get the shirt for the next game? After Gibbs showing against City, definitely yes.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
I reckon Townsend is one of those players who'll give you basically the same regardless of the level of opposition. He won't stand out but he'll rarely let you down either.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
I can’t quite fathom how a professional player can have such serious flaws in their game. As Backside says - you defend first and the rest is a bonus.
Furlong is the same - his positioning is horrendous. Constantly he drops inside so he is in the right-sided centre half area and there is an acre of space for the left side of the opposition. It has cost us numerous times.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(01-27-2021, 03:40 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (01-27-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Spot on. Excellent points. A bit more thoughtful than"he's crap", so a bit wasted on some other sites I read...
Another +1 on this one.
I think people think of Gibbs as being that third fiddle to Ashley Cole (I know there was Clichy in between) of marauding left backs that support the left-sided midfielder, overlap and get ball into dangerous areas. The way it works with us is that he pulls wide, there's no-one to pass to so he goes back again, always with his left foot and hardly ever inside (even if there is an option). Attack dies. If he doesn't get forward and offer that to the team he's nigh on useless. Powderpuff in the challenge and shit in the air.
Posts: 1,365
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
I thought, against City, in amongst an absolute smorgasbord of abysmal performances, Gibbs was stand-out shite. An absolute calamity defensively. One of the worst performances I’ve seen by an Albion player in the top flight.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(01-27-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-27-2021, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (01-27-2021, 10:58 AM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I think Gibbs does get slightly overrated by a few because he came from Arsenal and he's a decent footballer. Defensively he's so poor at times.
This!
The discussions about Gibbs all stems from people's judgements on full backs, which in the last 20 years have followed an increasing trend not to look at their basic defending. So many fans look at full backs performances based on what they do overlapping/passing/going forward. But their main job is DEFENDING (that's not to say an overlap and good cross isn't handy - it is).
So many times in games a good full back will just "get in the way", block a cross, force a player to go backwards, push someone down a blind alley, head a ball away at the back post etc. So many fans simply don't judge them on these things, they judge them on a nice move going forwards instead.
Ridgewell was a great example. Absolutely slated from pillar to post by so many people on here, yet Hodgson (a good manager who knew how to keep the goals out) played him every week! And guess what, we finished high up the league. Ridgewell looked clumsy, not a great technical footballer - but he got in the way, he blocked, he marked, he headed it away at the back post. He did the basics of defending that hardly anyone seems to notice in full backs these days as they're too busy looking for the nice run and overlap down the wing. Its a nonsense!
And that's not to say the stuff in possession should be ignored, but the fact is its secondary to solid defending for a full back. Gibbs is technically one of our best, in nearly 4 seasons I don't think I've seen him have a bad first touch. His passing is accurate. But this is no good if you can't stop crosses, can't block, can't head it. And Gibbs is crap at those things at this level (and only ok at champ level). That's why no one has bid for him while he's been with us, simple as that.
Judge full backs on defending first and foremost. The attacking side to them is a bonus, not the most important thing.
Spot on.
It's no coincidence that Pulis played 4 good defenders across the backline, and kept it tight as a consequence.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Such an oxymoron of a Pulis signing.
British - tick
Experienced PL - tick
From a top 6 club - tick
That part of Gibbs fits everything that Pulis likes and yet he's nothing at all like a Pulis player and most definitely not a defender you'd associate with him.
He has a good touch and is technically head and shoulders above most of our team which is why many, myslef included, see him as a better footballer than Townsend. His flawa are the heart the size of a pea and he has no defensive instinct whatsoever. He doesn't spot danger, weak in the challenge and appears at the moment to not be up for the fight at all.
Let's not pretend Townsend is the answer though, he too has been at fault for goals conceded and doesn't have the technical side of the game anything near to Gibbs. But he does try and he does have some defensive nous. Ultimately they're defenders first and formost. Whoever up above said that is something I wholeheartedly agree with.
Gibbs gets away with it when we have O'Shea at RB, or certainly did so in the Champo. It was a bizarre selection v Man City to play 2 attacking FBs (I use that term very lightly with Furlong).
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Re Gibbs signed by, but not, not a Pulis player. I get the point although Pulis did like one marauding full back to get the ball forward quickly, i.e.Etherington at Stoke and the guy at Palace. Pulis was never bothered about stopping crosses (much to my dismay!), he seemed happy that the centre halves would deal with crosses. I'm in agrrement with most on here, Gibbs isn't very good at defending.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(01-28-2021, 06:02 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Such an oxymoron of a Pulis signing.
British - tick
Experienced PL - tick
From a top 6 club - tick
That part of Gibbs fits everything that Pulis likes and yet he's nothing at all like a Pulis player and most definitely not a defender you'd associate with him.
He has a good touch and is technically head and shoulders above most of our team which is why many, myslef included, see him as a better footballer than Townsend. His flawa are the heart the size of a pea and he has no defensive instinct whatsoever. He doesn't spot danger, weak in the challenge and appears at the moment to not be up for the fight at all.
Let's not pretend Townsend is the answer though, he too has been at fault for goals conceded and doesn't have the technical side of the game anything near to Gibbs. But he does try and he does have some defensive nous. Ultimately they're defenders first and formost. Whoever up above said that is something I wholeheartedly agree with.
Gibbs gets away with it when we have O'Shea at RB, or certainly did so in the Champo. It was a bizarre selection v Man City to play 2 attacking FBs (I use that term very lightly with Furlong).
They both have their qualities and flaws, it's a toss up now really. Our players are certainly making mistakes but not as many as the so-called experienced manager we've employed who picked an attacking side against Man City. We could all see the problem in the first 5 minutes with Furlong (it's the same every time he plays there) and let's face it Sam should have spotted it by now but he needed to get off his fat arse and tell Furlong and the CBS to keep his shape and position and also Snodgrass who was appalling. The right hand side of our defence - both really were like an empty dancefloor. When the first went in why not take off an attacker and put another centre half on, it still gives you the potential to get fwd with wing-backs but I'm afraid Sam is completely clueless. And then after the match he says he can't work out why we're conceding goals lol
|