Carney abuse
#61
(12-31-2020, 11:37 AM)steviedm Wrote: The biggest surprise for me in this story is that the GIANTS Leeds have only 665,000+ Twitter followers whereas the TINY Baggies have more than a million...

They still have gas lamps up north! Big Grin
Reply
#62
I can read perfectly my facts was that the USA women's team got smashed by a u15 academy side...... she has no credibility to Me only commenting on a premier league game....... I'm not the only one she simply isn't very good at it.
Reply
#63
(12-31-2020, 11:42 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 10:23 AM)Winst_Baggie Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:48 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:24 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 08:54 AM)Winst_Baggie Wrote: She has 144 England caps & 32 goals. I'm not sure how much more justification you need?

Good point, well argued.

I was captain of the school team, but they don't ask me.

I take it you're disagreeing with me.... I'm curious - what criteria does a pundit have to meet to comment on a game?

They don't. You can even play 144 times for your country and be a shit pundit.

I agree that having an illustrious career doesn't automatically make you a good pundit: but that's not what you were saying before: 

But with respect, Birdy, I don't think your wife has played the game, so they wouldn't ask her.


"This for me is all about "bigging up" these people as some kind of experts, so tv can appear to tick all the politically correct boxes. I dont want to listen to someone I have never heard of, that doesn't command my respect.

Why not ask someone who has played for both clubs, there are plenty out there."

Firstly - your first two sentences contradict each other. Birdy's misses isn't in a position to summarise a game of football because she hasn't played the game yet Carney meets that criteria and so you now feel she isn't good enough because you've never heard of her, and thus she doesn't command your respect & she must've been chosen to fit some sort of box. 

You think that there an ex WBA/Leeds player should've been chosen. When challenged on this - you suggested Bob Taylor would've made a better option. Taylor last played for Leeds in 1989 the Albion in 2003 & to my knowledge has never worked as a pundit at any level. Taylor is a legend for sure, but come on.   

You should just say why you don't think women should commentate, and stop trying to deflect with contradictory or ridiculous statements.

Just like Brexit - when you put it on paper the arguments fall apart. 
Reply
#64
(12-31-2020, 12:41 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I can read perfectly my facts was that the USA women's team got smashed by a u15 academy side...... she has no credibility to Me only commenting on a premier league game....... I'm not the only one she simply isn't very good at it.

Yes but plenty of people think covid is a hoax.

This isn't about her ability bybthecway, its the general attitude by many that women shouldn't ever comment on football.
Reply
#65
It was me -I'm am Spartacus . I was the one who described her as 'cockney tart'

During half time her conduct as a presenter was unprofessional
She was talking so fast she sounded like a extra from Eastenders
Even though she's from the Midlands
It was extremely amateurish 
She did improve after the game

What she says about the game or teams is of no interest to me


Criticising her as a presenter is no different to criticising Lee Hendry Stan Collymore or Dingle Don
Or in balance, should that not be allowed any more on here?

As others have mentioned
If they are knowledgeable then the job is theirs regardless of who they are
For the record just because someone has played 1000 times does not always make them great pundits 
In the same way great footballers often don't  make great managers
Usually a sports journalist is ideal

At present its more important to media outlets to hire someone who is x y z rather than an expert

Why not hire Bomber Brown or Tom Ross?
They are well respected local guys who are extremely knowledgeable 

Oh I though Jimmy FHB did a good job
Reply
#66
(12-31-2020, 12:42 PM)Winst_Baggie Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 11:42 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 10:23 AM)Winst_Baggie Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:48 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:24 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Good point, well argued.

I was captain of the school team, but they don't ask me.

I take it you're disagreeing with me.... I'm curious - what criteria does a pundit have to meet to comment on a game?

They don't. You can even play 144 times for your country and be a shit pundit.

I agree that having an illustrious career doesn't automatically make you a good pundit: but that's not what you were saying before: 

But with respect, Birdy, I don't think your wife has played the game, so they wouldn't ask her.


"This for me is all about "bigging up" these people as some kind of experts, so tv can appear to tick all the politically correct boxes. I dont want to listen to someone I have never heard of, that doesn't command my respect.

Why not ask someone who has played for both clubs, there are plenty out there."

Firstly - your first two sentences contradict each other. Birdy's misses isn't in a position to summarise a game of football because she hasn't played the game yet Carney meets that criteria and so you now feel she isn't good enough because you've never heard of her, and thus she doesn't command your respect & she must've been chosen to fit some sort of box. 

You think that there an ex WBA/Leeds player should've been chosen. When challenged on this - you suggested Bob Taylor would've made a better option. Taylor last played for Leeds in 1989 the Albion in 2003 & to my knowledge has never worked as a pundit at any level. Taylor is a legend for sure, but come on.   

You should just say why you don't think women should commentate, and stop trying to deflect with contradictory or ridiculous statements.

Just like Brexit - when you put it on paper the arguments fall apart. 

Thanks for your measured reply. I'm not going to get into a pointless debate, I've just placed you on my ignore list.

Happy New Year.
Reply
#67
(12-31-2020, 11:37 AM)steviedm Wrote: The biggest surprise for me in this story is that the GIANTS Leeds have only 665,000+ Twitter followers whereas the TINY Baggies have more than a million...

They're all on Tik Tok mate
Reply
#68
(12-31-2020, 12:42 PM)Winst_Baggie Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 11:42 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 10:23 AM)Winst_Baggie Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:48 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-31-2020, 09:24 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Good point, well argued.

I was captain of the school team, but they don't ask me.

I take it you're disagreeing with me.... I'm curious - what criteria does a pundit have to meet to comment on a game?

They don't. You can even play 144 times for your country and be a shit pundit.

I agree that having an illustrious career doesn't automatically make you a good pundit: but that's not what you were saying before: 

But with respect, Birdy, I don't think your wife has played the game, so they wouldn't ask her.


"This for me is all about "bigging up" these people as some kind of experts, so tv can appear to tick all the politically correct boxes. I dont want to listen to someone I have never heard of, that doesn't command my respect.

Why not ask someone who has played for both clubs, there are plenty out there."

Firstly - your first two sentences contradict each other. Birdy's misses isn't in a position to summarise a game of football because she hasn't played the game yet Carney meets that criteria and so you now feel she isn't good enough because you've never heard of her, and thus she doesn't command your respect & she must've been chosen to fit some sort of box. 

You think that there an ex WBA/Leeds player should've been chosen. When challenged on this - you suggested Bob Taylor would've made a better option. Taylor last played for Leeds in 1989 the Albion in 2003 & to my knowledge has never worked as a pundit at any level. Taylor is a legend for sure, but come on.   

You should just say why you don't think women should commentate, and stop trying to deflect with contradictory or ridiculous statements.

Just like Brexit - when you put it on paper the arguments fall apart. 

Regarding Brexit.. 

Is that reference to them there Stayers or them there Goers?
Reply
#69
I won't rest until Andy Johnson comments on all our tv games. (In the interests of balanced reporting).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: