Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
(02-22-2020, 11:37 AM)MassDebater Wrote: In the pub one, I suspect that it was more to do with the perpetrator going out with a knife on him that led to the longer minimum term. In the abusive one it sounds like he probably grabbed a kitchen knife and did it 'on a whim' rather than with intent...although he clearly had plenty of intent in going round to beat the shit out of her. As I say the courts / Police seem to view that as less of a crime though, which is wrong. I don't think these are two to do with race/ names etc...
It's a bit like Eastenders are running the racism storyline, with the young black lad being stopped and searched a lot... Trouble is he's on an illegal moped and has a helmet on so the police can't tell what race he is, but the story is that they are being racist.
There does seem to have been a distinction between the premeditation of the murder of the landlord and the escalation in the domestic case. Whether that in itself is enough for an 11-year minimum sentencing discrepancy to make sense to a layperson is debatable; there was clearly 'intent' from the outset in both cases.
It's hard to see any clear racial overtones in these two examples, but that's all they are - two examples. It's a long way from my usual reading matter, but not so long back, on impulse, I bought and read Akala's book Natives; I didn't find it to be quite the classic some had suggested - and it's all a bit egocentric for my tastes - but it is nonetheless an interesting insight into the formative years of a young black male.
Posts: 2,431
Threads: 137
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Punishment vs rehabilitation
Every crime and criminal is different
Admissions of guilt vs insistences of innocence
Quick process for crime admitted vs bigger traumatic, social & administrative costs of processes where obvious guilt is denied.
One hat does not fit all
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
02-22-2020, 12:24 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-22-2020, 12:29 PM by fuzzbox.)
This is the problem with emotive reactions based on scant facts.
We don't actually know why each was given different sentences or why they were given the sentences they were given, but despite this race and lenient sentences have been given as the reasons.
The facts are that prison sentences have actually increased for identical crimes
Statistically, black males get longer sentences for the same crimes.
You can argue whether we are still too lenient, but it can't be claimed it's political correctness or a 'nanny state' - quite the opposite.
FWIW, I think what's more interesting is that if you are poorer - black or white - you are more likely to get longer sentences and they are more likely to be custodial. More contentiously, you're also more likely to commit a crime the further down the socioeconomic scale you go. You're also more likely to suffer from severe mental illness and be more poorly educated - especially if you are a white 'working class' boy. Worse still, your children will have less opportunity for social mobility than at any time since the 50's meaning they are more likely to be condemned to the same fate.
As a black man, I actually find that more interesting than racism. Solve that, and I honestly believe racism will be a thing of the past.
I sometimes wonder whether like electoral reform in the 19thC, the ruling classes figure it's better to let a few token black men into the club than face competition from whole swathes of the 'great unwashed'.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(02-22-2020, 12:24 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: This is the problem with emotive reactions based on scant facts.
We don't actually know why each was given different sentences or why they were given the sentences they were given, but despite this race and lenient sentences have been given as the reasons.
The facts are that prison sentences have actually increased for identical crimes
Statistically, black males get longer sentences for the same crimes.
You can argue whether we are still too lenient, but it can't be claimed it's political correctness or a 'nanny state' - quite the opposite.
FWIW, I think what's more interesting is that if you are poorer - black or white - you are more likely to get longer sentences and they are more likely to be custodial. More contentiously, you're also more likely to commit a crime the further down the socioeconomic scale you go. You're also more likely to suffer from severe mental illness and be more poorly educated - especially if you are a white 'working class' boy. Worse still, your children will have less opportunity for social mobility than at any time since the 50's meaning they are more likely to be condemned to the same fate.
As a black man, I actually find that more interesting than racism. Solve that, and I honestly believe racism will be a thing of the past.
In addition, the lower down the ladder you travel the more opportunities for making a quick buck through crime (drugs being the obvious one), present themselves. Ergo, it's easier to get involved with crime when you're broke and desperate than it is when you're working and stable. Which will come as no surprise to anyone at all. I suppose higher up the ladder you don't need the money that drug runners get, and you possibly have more opportunity to get involved in the higher end crimes that really earn the money, yet seem to carry more lenient sentencing...
In short, crime and poverty is like life in general, the better off you are the better the opportunities arise.
Maybe the longer sentences stem from the lower level crimes tend to involve more violence? Personally I have less anger towards bank robbers who hurt nobody, than I would local drug dealers who stab / maim / shoot their rivals. I think that sums it up?
Which I realise has bugger all to do with the original post, there it's a known nutter going out with a knife and stabbing someone in the wrong place at the wrong time, but obviously the criminal went out expecting to do someone over vs a wife beater who beat the living daylights out of a woman and then stabbed her during one of his assaults, possibly he went out not looking to kill someone.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-22-2020, 12:24 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: This is the problem with emotive reactions based on scant facts.
We don't actually know why each was given different sentences or why they were given the sentences they were given, but despite this race and lenient sentences have been given as the reasons.
The facts are that prison sentences have actually increased for identical crimes
Statistically, black males get longer sentences for the same crimes.
You can argue whether we are still too lenient, but it can't be claimed it's political correctness or a 'nanny state' - quite the opposite.
FWIW, I think what's more interesting is that if you are poorer - black or white - you are more likely to get longer sentences and they are more likely to be custodial. More contentiously, you're also more likely to commit a crime the further down the socioeconomic scale you go. You're also more likely to suffer from severe mental illness and be more poorly educated - especially if you are a white 'working class' boy. Worse still, your children will have less opportunity for social mobility than at any time since the 50's meaning they are more likely to be condemned to the same fate.
As a black man, I actually find that more interesting than racism. Solve that, and I honestly believe racism will be a thing of the past.
I sometimes wonder whether like electoral reform in the 19thC, the ruling classes figure it's better to let a few token black men into the club than face competition from whole swathes of the 'great unwashed'.
All these facts, well thought out reasons and interesting hypothesis have absolutely no place in our Post Truth Brexit land where how you / what you feel is more important than seeking out the truth, the opinions of experts or having an empathy towards a subject.
Down with these types of posts, we want more knee jerk reactions and calling people names instead!
Posts: 8,086
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
09-22-2020, 02:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-22-2020, 02:47 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Ched Evans got years for Tit Cricket.
Big corporations illegally import drugs. Huge corporations don't pay tax.
However neither either do most moaning about it. How ironic! Some of us do.
Some famous kids and US ambassadors get wrapped on the knuckles for death by dangerous driving. Poorer kids rot in a cell
Injustice and poor sentencing is everywhere, as per your other discourse with me! Unless it is better not to be Scottish (but then we knew that anyway  )
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
"It's the same the whole world over
It's the poor what gets the blame
It's the rich what gets the pleasure
Ain't it all a blooming' shame?"
|