The yoof that went onto the bigger and better things
#21
(08-20-2020, 01:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:43 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:37 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:31 AM)Duffers Wrote: The young players who stayed have hardly fared better.

But these were supposedly are brightest stars.

And they weren’t good enough for the elite, that’s fine. They may never have been good enough for us either, talent tends to rise and players find their level in time. At least these kids aren’t sitting at the likes of Swansea and Wednesday right now wondering what might have been if they had taken the big move. They believed they had the talent to make it at these clubs, I don’t blame them for trying. 

I find it weird that grown men on here seem to take such pleasure in watching the likes of Izzy Brown fail to make it in the PL because of a decision he made when he was 16.

I can see why it pisses people off.

To the fans it seems as though these kids are throwing away a chance 99% of us would jump at. Who didn't dream of playing for the Albion when they were a kid (sad I know). 

Generally I wish them well but can see why it leaves a sour taste for some.

Works two ways though - how many kids who dream of playing for Albion do we cut each year because we don’t think they’re good enough? Fans can’t have it both ways.

Give a teenager a chance to sign for a club with access to world class facilities and players they can watch every day in training and what do you think will happen? That’s before you consider the financial benefits.

Said many times, it’s the system that allows the big boys to pluck these kids away that’s fucked, not the players.

Yep.  Read the recent article about the lad who turned into a boxer.
Reply
#22
(08-20-2020, 01:12 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 01:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:43 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:37 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-20-2020, 10:31 AM)Duffers Wrote: The young players who stayed have hardly fared better.

But these were supposedly are brightest stars.

And they weren’t good enough for the elite, that’s fine. They may never have been good enough for us either, talent tends to rise and players find their level in time. At least these kids aren’t sitting at the likes of Swansea and Wednesday right now wondering what might have been if they had taken the big move. They believed they had the talent to make it at these clubs, I don’t blame them for trying. 

I find it weird that grown men on here seem to take such pleasure in watching the likes of Izzy Brown fail to make it in the PL because of a decision he made when he was 16.

I can see why it pisses people off.

To the fans it seems as though these kids are throwing away a chance 99% of us would jump at. Who didn't dream of playing for the Albion when they were a kid (sad I know). 

Generally I wish them well but can see why it leaves a sour taste for some.

Works two ways though - how many kids who dream of playing for Albion do we cut each year because we don’t think they’re good enough? Fans can’t have it both ways.

Give a teenager a chance to sign for a club with access to world class facilities and players they can watch every day in training and what do you think will happen? That’s before you consider the financial benefits.

Said many times, it’s the system that allows the big boys to pluck these kids away that’s fucked, not the players.

100% 

Listening to Sky discussing them as if they're Chelsea, Liverpool academy graduates when the Albion have found them and done the hard yards is infuriating.
Reply
#23
It is the system that is flawed as has been said.
The mega bucks clubs can hoover up all the best 16-year-olds taking punts on them for loose change in their budget.
However, being fans of the club can flaw our thinking. Top class football is ruthless. You could be a mad Albion fan, get to be signed as a child and dropped at any time. .
A mate of my son has been at Blues 3 years and they binned him a few months back, at 13.
Regarding FF's post it's good in that it illustrates how many don't make the grade. After all there's a hissy fit on social media whenever we lose a bright young star.
Despite the youth that have left, the biggest disappointment though of the last several years has been Berahino. He evolved into someone who could have been an England regular, where on the right trajectory we could have got £40m for and another season of memories, where he left like a modern Regis. He lost the plot and we did well to cart him off to Stoke and get that £12m with hindsight.
Reply
#24
One of the things that mitigates against these kids when they reach the 'ready or not' stage is the fear factor which influences - dominates in many cases - the mentality of many Premiership and Championship clubs. Can we afford to risk blooding this kid (beyond a few token sub appearances in league games, or as part of a weakened cup side)?

It could cost us relegation and potential financial disaster; it could cost us promotion and parachute money is finite; best wait. Eventually there'll always be somebody ready to wave a cheque book and not much care if they ever get to play or not, because they're a club who are never going to have to worry about relegation or the drying up of parachute payments, so the financial risk is small.

Deciding whether a young player is ready or not is often no longer a footballing decision. Which is obviously a poor reflection on the direction football has taken.
Reply
#25
James Hurst 4 England
Reply
#26
Interesting debate. There are of course exceptions, but most lads I played alongside who were good enough to (or indeed did) go on ti play pro/semi-pro actually played so much as kids around the time we all followed the Albion etc. that they didn’t get into the fan side anywhere near as much. So for many yoof - including ours - the whole concept of loyalty, pulling on the holy shirt etc. never existed. They just don’t and won’t get it. This in spite of the development bestowed on them, which offers probably little glory/payback per hour invested initially and it is the promise of the big pay check that probably pulls you through the hours or monotony trying to form a bond with but above all defeat the hordes of other selfish spoilt cunts just as quick and talented and tricky but replaceable as you. And they sacrifice a lot, socially (especially if lodging). At a time your social life is more important than your blood relatives.

I recall taking one lad from school who went on to play for Hednesford to a game once. I think it was one of the many times Worzel Claridge destroyed us, don’t recall much except for it being midweek, conceding 3 and being a little puzzled/embarrassed by my mate. He didn’t get it at all and seemed to think it was all funny.

A lass I went to school with went out with one of the wolves lads who made it. I think she dumped him in the end, she said he was never allowed out or was away from home.

It’s a different view from within.
Reply
#27
Read the OP but haven't read all of this thread so apologies if someone's mentioned it already but it's ironic that those mentioned in the OP haven't done much in their careers but some that we released or chose to drop down the leagues have gone on to prove themselves and. Have better careers.

Sawyers - Left to go to Walsall and worked his way up to the Prem now.

Roofe - Left and went to Oxford before getting his chump move to Leeds and then abroad and now at Glasgow Rangers.

Chris Wood - Sold and proved himself in league one and Chump with Millwall and Leicester and now a sought after Premier league striker.

Probably others I've forgotten too. Just goes to show that chasing the early money/lifestyle trappings of a "big club" very rarely pays off in the long run.

Those mentioned have used the rejection as a catalyst to go and prove themselves and backed their ability to get them to the top. It's all horses for courses I guess but there's no doubt that short term riches don't always pay off in the long run.

Tyler Roberts is the median in this I guess. Choosing to leave and making the Prem the same time as us.
Reply
#28
Jack Fitzwater is in the SPL team of the week.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: