Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
An extra 6 goals in the right games would have had us on nearly 100 points. Could have just learnt to dell with set pieces into the box.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
07-20-2020, 10:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2020, 10:04 AM by Sliced.)
(07-20-2020, 09:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2020, 07:02 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (07-20-2020, 05:13 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I think if I looked up and saw Charlie, HRK or Robinson in the centre, I’d quickly weigh up the odds and try myself
I disagree with that.. for Charlie.
I don't think he's having the service. He's a goalscorer, but I don't see him getting chances.
It might be his fault for lack of movement I guess, but I doubt that. As has been said, our highly talented midfield is guilty of over elaboration. And I include Pereira in that.
Hrk is not a striker.
Robinson I don't know, cos we haven't played him there. I'd like to see that... but now is not the time for experimentation!
Sorry JohnnyKaye, but Austin WAS a decent goalscorer, he no longer is.
His last 5 seasons before joining us, he scored 34 goals in 106 games with an xG of 37... essentially he scored 92% of chances it is anticipated a striker will score from which is outstanding... a good ratio is about 70%.
This season however his numbers are shocking. Charlie Austin has started 18 matches (plus 15 as a sub) and has had 24 shots on target from a total of 38 shots. He's scored 10 goals from an xG of 21.4 - he's effectively scored less than half of the chances a striker would be expected to score in which is VERY poor. Especially for a player who offers very little else, and has his numbers boosted by penalties. He's had plenty of service to have that number of chances, he's just not converted them... Watkins has 25 in xG32 and Mitrovic has 26 in xG37.
Watkins would have scored 16 vs Charlie's 10, and Mitrovic 15... Another 5/6 goals from our strikers would have seen us promoted quite some time ago..
This is misleading though. Being a good striker isn't just about finishing the chances, it's about putting yourself in the positions to finish those chances; something which xG actually penalises rather than rewards.
What this analysis tells us is that IF Watkins and Mitrovic had put themselves in the exact same positions as Austin then they would have scored more, but there's no guarantee they would have put themselves in those positions.
For balance, the minutes per goal:
Austin 149
Watkins 161
Mitrovic 135
Not a big difference there to be honest.....and certainly not "shocking"
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-20-2020, 10:02 AM)Sliced Wrote: (07-20-2020, 09:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2020, 07:02 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (07-20-2020, 05:13 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I think if I looked up and saw Charlie, HRK or Robinson in the centre, I’d quickly weigh up the odds and try myself
I disagree with that.. for Charlie.
I don't think he's having the service. He's a goalscorer, but I don't see him getting chances.
It might be his fault for lack of movement I guess, but I doubt that. As has been said, our highly talented midfield is guilty of over elaboration. And I include Pereira in that.
Hrk is not a striker.
Robinson I don't know, cos we haven't played him there. I'd like to see that... but now is not the time for experimentation!
Sorry JohnnyKaye, but Austin WAS a decent goalscorer, he no longer is.
His last 5 seasons before joining us, he scored 34 goals in 106 games with an xG of 37... essentially he scored 92% of chances it is anticipated a striker will score from which is outstanding... a good ratio is about 70%.
This season however his numbers are shocking. Charlie Austin has started 18 matches (plus 15 as a sub) and has had 24 shots on target from a total of 38 shots. He's scored 10 goals from an xG of 21.4 - he's effectively scored less than half of the chances a striker would be expected to score in which is VERY poor. Especially for a player who offers very little else, and has his numbers boosted by penalties. He's had plenty of service to have that number of chances, he's just not converted them... Watkins has 25 in xG32 and Mitrovic has 26 in xG37.
Watkins would have scored 16 vs Charlie's 10, and Mitrovic 15... Another 5/6 goals from our strikers would have seen us promoted quite some time ago..
This is misleading though. Being a good striker isn't just about finishing the chances, it's about putting yourself in the positions to finish those chances; something which xG actually penalises rather than rewards.
What this analysis tells us is that IF Watkins and Mitrovic had put themselves in the exact same positions as Austin then they would have scored more, but there's no guarantee they would have put themselves in those positions.
For balance, the minutes per goal:
Austin 149
Watkins 161
Mitrovic 135
Not a big difference there to be honest.....and certainly not "shocking"
Get what you're saying about the limitations of the xG as a metric Slice, but let's be realistic, the amount of xG chances Mitrovic and Watkins have found themselves with suggests they would have found themselves in the same positions as Austin.
Austin has scored 4 penalties as has Mitrovic, and Watkins none. Strip those out of Austin's numbers and it becomes a lot different... we're then at 6 out of 15.4, or sub 40%... For a player marketed at being a clinical finisher, it's shocking.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
07-20-2020, 10:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2020, 10:48 AM by Big Daddy Cool.)
Most of Austin's goals have been penalties. His main attribute should be scoring goals and he's missed too many chances lately so I don't see what else he offers because his overall play is poor.
We need to stop signing players who are on decline. He was training with Southamptons youth, that should have been a warning to us.
|