Best goalkeeper Johnstone
#31
(07-07-2020, 08:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s a decent modern keeper. Not many command their area like in previous generations. Swings and roundabouts in some respects, I remember keepers ten / fifteen years ago could barely kick a ball to teammate unless it was hoofed in the general direction.

I think the criticism he gets is way over the top. Why we have to find players to single out for criticism week after is a mystery.

You don’t think it’s fair to criticise and discuss and obvious weakness in his game?  He’s very weak on crosses, both in decision making as to when to come and when does what he actually achieves.  Grosicki shouldn’t have been on his heels for the first equaliser but Johnson made the initial mistake that resulted in the chance.

No Hegazi and Rooney’s crossing ability from the inevitable fouls gifted by Sawyers are the stuff of nightmares.
Reply
#32
(07-07-2020, 08:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s a decent modern keeper. Not many command their area like in previous generations. Swings and roundabouts in some respects, I remember keepers ten / fifteen years ago could barely kick a ball to teammate unless it was hoofed in the general direction.

I think the criticism he gets is way over the top. Why we have to find players to single out for criticism week after is a mystery.

You don’t think it’s fair to criticise and discuss and obvious weakness in his game?  He’s very weak on crosses, both in decision making as to when to come and when does what he actually achieves.  Grosicki shouldn’t have been on his heels for the first equaliser but Johnson made the initial mistake that resulted in the chance.

No Hegazi and Rooney’s crossing ability from the inevitable fouls gifted by Sawyers are the stuff of nightmares.

Every player has weaknesses but the amount of stick Johnstone receives is ott. We are a Championship club currently and he’s a decent keeper for where we currently are as a club.
Reply
#33
Johnstone has taken stick where not deserved. Although, let's face it, he's dropped more than a few bollocks.

He's a passable keeper at this level but if we're serious about next season in the Prem then he shouldn't be in the squad. A new keeper, along with a new forward line, would be absolutely critical.

(07-07-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s a decent modern keeper. Not many command their area like in previous generations. Swings and roundabouts in some respects, I remember keepers ten / fifteen years ago could barely kick a ball to teammate unless it was hoofed in the general direction.

I think the criticism he gets is way over the top. Why we have to find players to single out for criticism week after is a mystery.

You don’t think it’s fair to criticise and discuss and obvious weakness in his game?  He’s very weak on crosses, both in decision making as to when to come and when does what he actually achieves.  Grosicki shouldn’t have been on his heels for the first equaliser but Johnson made the initial mistake that resulted in the chance.

No Hegazi and Rooney’s crossing ability from the inevitable fouls gifted by Sawyers are the stuff of nightmares.

Every player has weaknesses but the amount of stick Johnstone receives is ott. We are a Championship club currently and he’s a decent keeper for where we currently are as a club.

Agreed. Adequate for where we are.
Reply
#34
(07-07-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s a decent modern keeper. Not many command their area like in previous generations. Swings and roundabouts in some respects, I remember keepers ten / fifteen years ago could barely kick a ball to teammate unless it was hoofed in the general direction.

I think the criticism he gets is way over the top. Why we have to find players to single out for criticism week after is a mystery.

You don’t think it’s fair to criticise and discuss and obvious weakness in his game?  He’s very weak on crosses, both in decision making as to when to come and when does what he actually achieves.  Grosicki shouldn’t have been on his heels for the first equaliser but Johnson made the initial mistake that resulted in the chance.

No Hegazi and Rooney’s crossing ability from the inevitable fouls gifted by Sawyers are the stuff of nightmares.

Every player has weaknesses but the amount of stick Johnstone receives is ott. We are a Championship club currently and he’s a decent keeper for where we currently are as a club.

What would you thoughts be if we achieve promotion?  Your thoughts, not what you think the club will do.
Reply
#35
He is not one of the best keepers in the Championship

He had one very good season with the Seals, where JT made him look very good. His lack of organisation and ability to deal with crosses is his weakness, and he has not improved on this.

I hope we do a Stockwell with him.
Reply
#36
(07-07-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2020, 08:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He’s a decent modern keeper. Not many command their area like in previous generations. Swings and roundabouts in some respects, I remember keepers ten / fifteen years ago could barely kick a ball to teammate unless it was hoofed in the general direction.

I think the criticism he gets is way over the top. Why we have to find players to single out for criticism week after is a mystery.

You don’t think it’s fair to criticise and discuss and obvious weakness in his game?  He’s very weak on crosses, both in decision making as to when to come and when does what he actually achieves.  Grosicki shouldn’t have been on his heels for the first equaliser but Johnson made the initial mistake that resulted in the chance.

No Hegazi and Rooney’s crossing ability from the inevitable fouls gifted by Sawyers are the stuff of nightmares.

Every player has weaknesses but the amount of stick Johnstone receives is ott. We are a Championship club currently and he’s a decent keeper for where we currently are as a club.

Don't think he gets too much stick tbh. I think some of us are polarised on here about him. I like a goalkeeper that is big, commanding, vocal and puts the defence at ease even if on occasion it goes wrong. I also like a keeper who can make those point blank saves more often than not. It was telling on the commentary on Sunday when AJ said he'd never heard a GK so quiet.

No doubt SJ is good at the shot stopping but he can't jump and doesn't take command. For the price we paid, for the team he plays behind he should be better and as we saw against Hull as soon as anyone puts balls under the cross bar or in the 6 yard box we are all over the place
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)