Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
You think Okays chance results in a goal 1/10 times?
I would expect that shit to hit the target 1/10 times, maybe.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 466
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
2
(03-13-2024, 07:11 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
You think Okays chance results in a goal 1/10 times? 
I would expect that shit to hit the target 1/10 times, maybe.
Please explain who the shit is as it can’t be Okay.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(03-13-2024, 08:01 AM)Jerry Wrote: (03-13-2024, 07:11 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
You think Okays chance results in a goal 1/10 times? 
I would expect that shit to hit the target 1/10 times, maybe.
Please explain who the shit is as it can’t be Okay.
Typo, it was meant to say shot
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
What a load of bollocks.
How many goals do you see like Okay's?
How mental did twitter and social media go with that goal? It went round all the big football accounts, all the media outlets etc. If that's a 1/10 goal, no way it has that impact.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-13-2024, 09:51 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
What a load of bollocks.
How many goals do you see like Okay's?
How mental did twitter and social media go with that goal? It went round all the big football accounts, all the media outlets etc. If that's a 1/10 goal, no way it has that impact.
It's a stunning goal, but not a difficult goal, it couldn't have come to him any better irrespective of how far out he was. Now if xG was saying it was a 100 to 1 chance the ball would fall to him in the manner it did I could get on board, but it doesn't, so I'm not.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(03-13-2024, 09:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: (03-13-2024, 09:51 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (03-12-2024, 05:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: Clear example on Sunday of why xG is flawed. The Yokuslu goal: xG suggests he 'should' only score that goal once if he had 100 attempts at it, but if you ask the player he'd be extremely disappointed to miss his timing 99 times out of 100 when the ball falls so perfectly to him to strike it clean and true into the net. I'd argue he'd expect score that goal at least 10 times more than the xG suggests if he had 100 goes at it, purely due to how it fell to him and how he was able to time the shot perfectly due to that. As opposed to the arbitrary distance/angle calculations done by the xG model/algorithm.
What a load of bollocks.
How many goals do you see like Okay's?
How mental did twitter and social media go with that goal? It went round all the big football accounts, all the media outlets etc. If that's a 1/10 goal, no way it has that impact.
It's a stunning goal, but not a difficult goal, it couldn't have come to him any better irrespective of how far out he was. Now if xG was saying it was a 100 to 1 chance the ball would fall to him in the manner it did I could get on board, but it doesn't, so I'm not.
Not a difficult goal?
Mate you HAVE to be trolling.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
03-13-2024, 12:11 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-13-2024, 12:13 PM by BurleyBaggie.)
There’s some truth in this as it’s not a 1 in 100 shot. This however back to indicators need to be used in conjunction with other indicators. On average that may be a 1-100 shot. However, that doesn’t factor in position of opposition players, quality of the pitch, quality of the player striking the ball, quality of the keeper etc etc. it’s a dumb indicator that can be made smart by combining other factors.
You could probably say it’s a 50-1 strike all things considered. I do not agree with xG Okay had a 0.01 chance if scoring in that moment.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
03-13-2024, 01:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-13-2024, 01:16 PM by Lurker#3.)
(03-13-2024, 12:11 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: There’s some truth in this as it’s not a 1 in 100 shot. This however back to indicators need to be used in conjunction with other indicators. On average that may be a 1-100 shot. However, that doesn’t factor in position of opposition players, quality of the pitch, quality of the player striking the ball, quality of the keeper etc etc. it’s a dumb indicator that can be made smart by combining other factors.
You could probably say it’s a 50-1 strike all things considered. I do not agree with xG Okay had a 0.01 chance if scoring in that moment.
xG isn't a standalone indicator, though. It is, in itself, a combination of attributing factors.
Amongst many others it is made up of:- Assist type (long ball, through ball etc)
- Type of shot (header, foot, other body part)
- Shot angle
- Distance of the shot
- How many blocking defenders there were
- Open play or set piece
You are right regarding quality of pitch and quality of player taking the shot, but that's where the context comes into looking at stats. Also the database of previous shots they use for xG will include efforst from players of all abilities so even that is roughly taken into account.
That 0.01xG chance in the hands of Okay is less likely to have a positive outcome than in the hands of say Dewsbury-Hall who would be more likely to execute a successful conversion low quality of chance. It doesn't change the fact that statistically its a very low percentage opportunity.
"IMO of course..."
|