WBAUnofficial
Confirmed Shan in charge - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Confirmed Shan in charge (/showthread.php?tid=3363)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - SW4Baggie - 04-17-2019

For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Derek Hardballs - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 11:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.

+1


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - George Stagefright - 04-17-2019

I'll give him a lot of credit for the way we changed our approach at HT against Swansea, Blues and Bristol City even though we were fugged at half time in the latter.

His subs & the timing of them seem pretty good too.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Albion - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 12:56 PM)George Stagefright Wrote: I'll give him a lot of credit for the way we changed our approach at HT against Swansea, Blues and Bristol City even though we were fugged at half time in the latter.

His subs & the timing of them seem pretty good too.

I like his in game management so far. I always felt Darren was more reactive rather than pro active


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Remi_Moses - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 11:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.

Shan +1 spot on post
Dowling - I wondered what he did, remind me who he has done so far?


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Birdman1811 - 04-17-2019

To be fair to Dowling, it took 2 to 3 years to see what Ashworth was doing.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Squid - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 01:10 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 11:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.

Shan +1 spot on post
Dowling - I wondered what he did, remind me who he has done so far?

Dowling - Got in four players in the January transfer window and told Newcastle to behave when they were trying to use Jacob Murphy to get Rondon on the cheap. Also told Jones to do one when he wanted Oviedo despite us having no need for a left back. Also seems to have seen through Jones in general, sadly at the cost of losing Moore.


Agree with Shan's astuteness. Not surprised Thompson on WM was scathing, Sneekes was the same and it all comes down to Shan not being an ex-pro.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Tom Joad - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 11:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.
Agree with this. Also with Birdmon and Squid who point out we haven't had time to judge Dowling yet.
I'm comfortable with Shan for now as the timing of BD's exit left us in a difficult situation.
And in reply to Derek's  (correct IMO)  statement of how good we were having things;  The problem with Lai is that he thought he was buying an established Prem club that ran at a profit, with a manager that doesn't get relegated. I don't know how much of a businessman Lai is,  whether he is normally more hands on or just a shrewd investor, but it is safe to say he has had his fingers burned. Peace had the knack of making sure that what was good for Albion was good for him too. Nowt wrong there, that is, until he decided he was going to cash out.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - Statto - 04-17-2019

It's easy to slag Peace for selling to Lai, but who really knows about any new owner?

We all liked the sound of Williams and on the fan side certain things improved under Goodman. However, if they'd been in charge now, we'd be heading for financial Armageddon. That's why I maintain, however shit it is, we need Jenkins right now for the finances. He isn't the problem, but the total control he has been given over the whole club is the problem. We were solid when he set the parameters and others worked within them.

I will also accept that our position is fairly unique. I can't think of another club has had so many variables to think of when appointing a manager. Can anyone name a club that's been in a similar situation? The jobs normally come up when the team is doing shit.

I was gutted when Moore went, but the more I hear about it, the more it seems the club had no option but to act before it imploded. We can all slate the club for not having a plan, but I am sure that they wanted Moore to bin Jones and carry on with Shan. He had enough opportunities and it's a shame he wouldn't.


RE: Confirmed Shan in charge - SW4Baggie - 04-17-2019

(04-17-2019, 05:36 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 11:46 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: For me, Shan is showing a tactical flexibility and a level of reading the game that is far higher than most managers out there, he also comes across as determined, motivated and honest, with just the right amount of arrogance required.

The main criticism of him appears to be his lack of experience but there are plenty of young managers out there doing very well after stepping up from coaching youth (Nagelsman, Tedesco etc...) who are respected for their understanding of the game and Shan is just is qualified as they are. We’ve rejected several approaches from other clubs to talk to him about their top jobs. 

At the moment Shan’s only concern is to get the best out of the players he has, and he appears to be getting more than his predecessors have with this group. Dowling’s job is to scout players, build the infrastructure and give Shan the environment to thrive in.
Agree with this. Also with Birdmon and Squid who point out we haven't had time to judge Dowling yet.
I'm comfortable with Shan for now as the timing of BD's exit left us in a difficult situation.
And in reply to Derek's  (correct IMO)  statement of how good we were having things;  The problem with Lai is that he thought he was buying an established Prem club that ran at a profit, with a manager that doesn't get relegated. I don't know how much of a businessman Lai is,  whether he is normally more hands on or just a shrewd investor, but it is safe to say he has had his fingers burned. Peace had the knack of making sure that what was good for Albion was good for him too. Nowt wrong there, that is, until he decided he was going to cash out.

I’ve not got any criticism yet for Dowling, as as has been said, he’s delivered players in Jan, and appears to have seen through Jones when Moore was blind to it. His time to shine will be this summer when we need to rebuild regardless of division... and I just hope he’s capable of looking further afield than we seem to have for January loans and a manager!