RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Mancbaggies - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.
Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.
Winners
1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.
2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.
3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.
Losers
1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.
2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?
As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones. As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. Can’t think of any other way. Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable. Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.
With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away. An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone? Not a bad idea to pool the £120mill
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - wba13 - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 04:00 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.
Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.
Winners
1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.
2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.
3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.
Losers
1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.
2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?
As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones. As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. Can’t think of any other way. Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable. Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.
With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away. An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone? Not a bad idea to pool the £120mill
I will be getting my granddaughter and my own season ticket in the next couple of weeks. The way I look at this is no matter when or how this season finishes it will finish , wether we are gifted promotion, have to play out the rest of season or not. Whatever league we are in and whenever the new season starts , it will still be great value for money.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Tom Joad - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 03:03 PM)hudds Wrote: (03-15-2020, 02:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It's only an opinion- mine at that(!); but maybe we should just finish the season however long it takes. The loan, player contracts business will have to be dealt with but that surely cannot be beyond possible? Scrap the euros, finish the season, then make plans for what happens next time out.
We are going round in circles TJ. Of course finish it if possible but I think highly improbable not matter how desirable it would be. But it is also conceivable that it won't be finished and the current suspension is just a pause before the lot get cancellled. Then what? Nice if we got promoted but that's the choice of the Prem clubs. They might just haul up the ladder. Not sure about that. Assuming football is to resume at some point, then resume it as we stand. The Euros will almost certainly be cancelled anyway so there should be time. If this is still going on into Autumn, then we delay until deemed safe, then next season is just a half a season. Everyone plays everyone once only.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - SW4Baggie - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 04:00 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.
Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.
Winners
1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.
2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.
3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.
Losers
1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.
2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?
As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones. As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. Can’t think of any other way. Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable. Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.
With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away. An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone? Not a bad idea to pool the £120mill
Problem is is that they’ll have to pay TV rights to 22 teams, not the usual 20, so it would require the other clubs to agree to take a %-reduction and who can see that happening?
Sure Sky would argue it wasnt their decision to expand the PL so they won’t be increasing what they pay to cater for extra clubs as they won’t have additional TV slots.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Pragmatist - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 06:22 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-15-2020, 04:00 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.
Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.
Winners
1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.
2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.
3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.
Losers
1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.
2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?
As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones. As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. Can’t think of any other way. Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable. Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.
With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away. An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone? Not a bad idea to pool the £120mill
Problem is is that they’ll have to pay TV rights to 22 teams, not the usual 20, so it would require the other clubs to agree to take a %-reduction and who can see that happening?
Sure Sky would argue it wasnt their decision to expand the PL so they won’t be increasing what they pay to cater for extra clubs as they won’t have additional TV slots.
Rumour is that £750m has been set aside to pay compensation.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - MassDebater - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 06:23 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 06:22 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-15-2020, 04:00 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:55 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-15-2020, 01:21 PM)Squid Wrote: The 22 club PL seems the most feasible. A five-way relegation battle will also add plenty of interest for the following season.
Let's look at the winners and losers if this were to happen.
Winners
1) Liverpool will lift the PL title. They've all but won it anyway, the media all love them so will gleefully froth. No one else in the PL can really complain.
2)PL clubs facing relegation. Considering the financial ruin relegation will bring upon them, (especially West Ham and Vile), they will be very happy indeed to avoid it.
3)Albion and Leeds. Both clubs have pretty much been head and shoulders above the rest this year. Leeds have a massive fan base, now back within the PL fold. In the modern era of football coverage being as much about managerial soap operas as what is on the pitch, the PL will be gaining two charismatic figures in Bilić and Bielsa.
Losers
1) Teams outside the top 5 of the PL who may have made the Champions League. They can still have the Europa league instead. However, European football may be off the agenda for a while anyway.
2) Teams in and around the Play-offs. Considering it's a lottery only one team can win, how much of a claim do they have?
As soon as the decision is made, the 22 club PL then will become a package Sky et al can merrily sell and considering subscriptions have been falling, this could be the boost they need. Playing matches behind closed doors isn't nearly as appealling.
I suspect the play-off teams would be the problem ones. As you say, a lottery for the 4 teams placed 3-6th, and maybe the answer is to share one season’s pot of PL money (£120m?) between them so £30m each, to compensate them. Can’t think of any other way. Fulham would probably say it’s not enough, but the other 3 would find it far more acceptable. Only way is to make it a 23-team PL and bring Fulham up too, with 6 down the following season.
With 5 (or 6) going down the following season, maybe PL2 is not far away. An 18-team PL1 and an 18-team PL2 including Celtic and Rangers anyone? Not a bad idea to pool the £120mill
Problem is is that they’ll have to pay TV rights to 22 teams, not the usual 20, so it would require the other clubs to agree to take a %-reduction and who can see that happening?
Sure Sky would argue it wasnt their decision to expand the PL so they won’t be increasing what they pay to cater for extra clubs as they won’t have additional TV slots.
Rumour is that £750m has been set aside to pay compensation.
What, to the Premier League teams that are affected? Can't see them doing anything for the smaller clubs.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - hudds - 03-15-2020
Some stuff:
A Premier League club executive, who did not want to be named given the acute sensitivities of this crisis, said sports scientists’ advice is that a player needs one day of training for every day of isolation before they can be match fit. So the advisory 14-day isolation doubles to 28 days out of action. It appears close to impossible for squads, managers, coaching and other staff to operate at full strength as the virus spreads, peaks and runs its course. The chief executive, like other senior figures, believes it is “almost certain the league will finish at this point”.
Even if Uefa vacates the month of Euro 2020, from the 12 June scheduled first game in Rome to the 12 July final at Wembley, the idea of stretching the season into the summer and beyond is more complicated than it looks. Players’ contracts run to 30 June so the idea of carrying on with squads after that is described as so fraught as to be almost impossible.
The question of how to decide the title, promotion and relegation, Champions League qualification places, if the season ends now, moved in days from an interesting hypothetical to a genuine practical issue. West Ham’s Karren Brady, who wrote in Saturday’s Sun that the season should be declared null and void, is not the only Premier League club executive advancing that as a solution. A director of another club, who did not want to air his thoughts as publicly, said that while clubs could still garner enough points to change their positions, none will want to accept a disadvantage, especially given the huge sporting and financial gap between the Premier League and Championship.
Scrapping the season is the only solution that avoids a descent into litigation by those who would lose out if current places are converted into permanence, he said.
Another executive said they could do that, but avoid rancourous battles with a more creative solution: reward the winners but reprieve the losers. If the season needs to be considered finished at this stage, Liverpool, 25 points ahead at the top, would be awarded the title they have waited 30 years to reclaim and nobody could justifiably argue. Leeds and West Brom should go up, he said, but no club be relegated and the Premier League could play next season with 22 clubs.
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2020/mar/15/questions-but-few-answers-coronavirus-premeir-league-football-shutdown
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Tom Joad - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 06:47 PM)hudds Wrote: Some stuff:
A Premier League club executive, who did not want to be named given the acute sensitivities of this crisis, said sports scientists’ advice is that a player needs one day of training for every day of isolation before they can be match fit. So the advisory 14-day isolation doubles to 28 days out of action. It appears close to impossible for squads, managers, coaching and other staff to operate at full strength as the virus spreads, peaks and runs its course. The chief executive, like other senior figures, believes it is “almost certain the league will finish at this point”.
Even if Uefa vacates the month of Euro 2020, from the 12 June scheduled first game in Rome to the 12 July final at Wembley, the idea of stretching the season into the summer and beyond is more complicated than it looks. Players’ contracts run to 30 June so the idea of carrying on with squads after that is described as so fraught as to be almost impossible.
The question of how to decide the title, promotion and relegation, Champions League qualification places, if the season ends now, moved in days from an interesting hypothetical to a genuine practical issue. West Ham’s Karren Brady, who wrote in Saturday’s Sun that the season should be declared null and void, is not the only Premier League club executive advancing that as a solution. A director of another club, who did not want to air his thoughts as publicly, said that while clubs could still garner enough points to change their positions, none will want to accept a disadvantage, especially given the huge sporting and financial gap between the Premier League and Championship.
Scrapping the season is the only solution that avoids a descent into litigation by those who would lose out if current places are converted into permanence, he said.
Another executive said they could do that, but avoid rancourous battles with a more creative solution: reward the winners but reprieve the losers. If the season needs to be considered finished at this stage, Liverpool, 25 points ahead at the top, would be awarded the title they have waited 30 years to reclaim and nobody could justifiably argue. Leeds and West Brom should go up, he said, but no club be relegated and the Premier League could play next season with 22 clubs.
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2020/mar/15/questions-but-few-answers-coronavirus-premeir-league-football-shutdown
That's pretty depressing, Hudds. Mainly because, and this is no surprise to anyone, it reeks of keeping the status quo. As around 12 or 13 prem clubs have the sole ambition simply to stay in the prem, then I can well see them all voting for that.
It probably isn't the time to put forward my own self interest although I'll be gutted not to see us (perhaps), lifting a trophy.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - Ampadu's Left Boot - 03-15-2020
(03-15-2020, 06:47 PM)hudds Wrote: Some stuff:
A Premier League club executive, who did not want to be named given the acute sensitivities of this crisis, said sports scientists’ advice is that a player needs one day of training for every day of isolation before they can be match fit. So the advisory 14-day isolation doubles to 28 days out of action. It appears close to impossible for squads, managers, coaching and other staff to operate at full strength as the virus spreads, peaks and runs its course. The chief executive, like other senior figures, believes it is “almost certain the league will finish at this point”.
Even if Uefa vacates the month of Euro 2020, from the 12 June scheduled first game in Rome to the 12 July final at Wembley, the idea of stretching the season into the summer and beyond is more complicated than it looks. Players’ contracts run to 30 June so the idea of carrying on with squads after that is described as so fraught as to be almost impossible.
The question of how to decide the title, promotion and relegation, Champions League qualification places, if the season ends now, moved in days from an interesting hypothetical to a genuine practical issue. West Ham’s Karren Brady, who wrote in Saturday’s Sun that the season should be declared null and void, is not the only Premier League club executive advancing that as a solution. A director of another club, who did not want to air his thoughts as publicly, said that while clubs could still garner enough points to change their positions, none will want to accept a disadvantage, especially given the huge sporting and financial gap between the Premier League and Championship.
Scrapping the season is the only solution that avoids a descent into litigation by those who would lose out if current places are converted into permanence, he said.
Another executive said they could do that, but avoid rancourous battles with a more creative solution: reward the winners but reprieve the losers. If the season needs to be considered finished at this stage, Liverpool, 25 points ahead at the top, would be awarded the title they have waited 30 years to reclaim and nobody could justifiably argue. Leeds and West Brom should go up, he said, but no club be relegated and the Premier League could play next season with 22 clubs.
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2020/mar/15/questions-but-few-answers-coronavirus-premeir-league-football-shutdown
A 'Premier League club executive'. So someone from West Ham or the Vile then.
The fact is, if all of those points in bold are agreed to be correct and fair by all clubs (and they are highly debatable points to say the least) then that unequivocally means no 20/21 season, guaranteed.
That being the case, and as incredible as it may seem, then this season can be delayed for 12 months if necessary.
If players contracts are up, then that's tough, but it's the same situation for all teams. You either negotiate new contracts with those players, or use the fact you have a new window to sign new players to your advantage.
RE: So...possibly us and Leeds promoted - HugeHons - 03-15-2020
What will happen with Pereira??
|