WBAUnofficial
Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... (/showthread.php?tid=21601)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Birdman1811 - 09-26-2021

Same Duffers.

I remember watching us while we were a making up the numbers laughing stock in Division 1. We didn't play good football then, and if it wasn't for Taylor, Hunt and then Hughes we weren't watching at all in any way, we were just a disaster.

It's been a golden period since then, even with relegations.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Brentbaggie - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 10:03 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
Huggybear Wrote:Like it or not but apart from Millwall I don’t really think we have looked like losing this season.Yes we have gone behind in games but in each one our pressure football has got it’s reward and we have deservedly got a result.It hardly looks like the players don’t like playing this style and if anything positive results always means that players believe in what there doing.What I would say is that Ismael for the first time looked upset about the supporters reaction to his substitution and was straight down the tunnel after the game.Also when prompted to praise the supporters after the game there seemed at best a lukewarm reaction compared to his previous interviews.

It is a concern that Ismael will be disappointed by the crowd reaction. I hear the argument that "we've paid our money so we can express our opinion", but that covers a lot of people just taking the opportunity to get the border-line Tourettes out of their system in a safe environment.

Now here's a controversial point. I've been visiting the shrine for over 50 years. I've also lived here and there and been to a whole lot of matches not involving the Albion. Boro, Sunderland, Newcastle, Forest, Leicester, Oldham, Stockport, most of the London grounds. I think we are among the least patient and most abusive of home crowds. We deride the Seals for their ineffectual clapping of any bit of positive play, but we switch very quickly into full-on abuse mode. Individuals are targeted and become scapegoats. Chris Brunt and the coin, Dean Kiely and Jonas Olsson having their issues with the crowd for example. Just my observation, but maybe we aren't much fun to play for, even when things are going well.
My experience is the opposite, albeit not particularly recent. The dings are renowned for their hostility to their own, villa will never, ever be as good as their fans loudly expect. But my first exposure to any real fickleness came when I lived t'other side of London. In the absence of easy access to The Hawthorns I tried every London club to get a saturday afternoon out. The first time I saw spurs at WHL (against villa ironically) I stood with the home fans on the shelf and heard them pull the team apart for 90 minutes. They'd toured the pitch with the FA cup before the game FFS!   West Ham was a similar story. Fulham was a better experience but they were resigned to being 2nd rate then.
I would add, these days Albion fans -like everyone in general- want it now, though over time we have been amazingly patient. Johnny Giles said as much when he expected the sack after initially going without a win for a time. It may be different in the Brummie Rd. but where I sit, apart from the boos when the double sub was made on Friday, the dissent has been barely heard.The boo boys make me sick but fortunately they are still a small minority.
Also, the infamous Brunty coin incident. I was right by that spot and the retribution that followed as fans attacked the alleged (incorrectly, as it turned out) culprits was prolonged. One idiot was all it took.

+ 1 Tom.  Funnily enough I was going to post a reply to much the same extent but pulled it.  Still, here we go.  Spurs are indeed notorious for getting at their team if they don't play the "right way", which basically means not being 2 up after twenty minutes.  Arsenal are almost as hateful and angry if you could only hear them - maybe that's why the new stadium was designed that way. Brentford and Fulham are grateful for anything and rarely get on the team's back.  Chelsea fans are too busy swearing, being pissed and gibbering to notice anything the team might be doing wrong, while Crystal Palace have a near pathological aversion to any half decent team sharing their pitch that they are generally amazed when their team score.  All clubs have twats.  I've never booed my own team regardless of how they played.  It's very rare for footballers en masse to play like they don't give a shit.  Individuals of course, and they can get stick at the Hawthorns like anywhere else but never the team.  Booing this lot, who may not be the most gifted bunch but clearly work their socks off by-and-large, is ridiculous.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Birdman1811 - 09-26-2021

Thats a point.

Many fans have said "So long as the team work hard I'm with them."

Well this is the hardest working team we've had since Megson, so why boo them? Do they think the players just shrug and go "Oh the manager isn't playing pretty football, it's directed at him, not us." Or do they think. "These fans are horrible, we're trying and they're still booing us."


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Wotty - 09-26-2021

As normal some excellent reasoned posts arguing different angles.

I don’t boo and I find a lot of the time it’s embarrassing to be honest. Half time on Friday was unnecessary for example

BUT

It is non abusive, non violent etc. Could it be that booing is just the opposite of clapping? 
Against Derby 1st half and against Millwall for example how would the fan relay their displeasure ?

Like I say, I’m not a fan of it but maybe if they’re happy to take the plaudits then the fans booing when they thought it was crap shouldn’t be a big deal?


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Duffers - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 11:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Duffers.

I remember watching us while we were a making up the numbers laughing stock in Division 1. We didn't play good football then, and if it wasn't for Taylor, Hunt and then Hughes we weren't watching at all in any way, we were just a disaster.

It's been a golden period since then, even with relegations.

I still remember, vividly, being in the Rainbow Stand for the Woking debacle.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - baggie_ray - 09-26-2021

Babbies, the pair on ya.

er...that's Duffers and Birdmon, in age terms


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - MassDebater - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 11:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Thats a point.

Many fans have said "So long as the team work hard I'm with them."

Well this is the hardest working team we've had since Megson, so why boo them? Do they think the players just shrug and go "Oh the manager isn't playing pretty football, it's directed at him, not us." Or do they think. "These fans are horrible, we're trying and they're still booing us."

Thing is, I only see that trotted out on here. Everyone I know, and those around us at the game are pretty bored with what we're being dished up already. No once heard someone (not on here) say well it's OK because we're finally working 'aaard and are fitter than we've been in ages.

My mate the other night turned to me and said ' Just think Daz, last time we were in this division we were being spoiled with good, entertaining football, now we have this.' I'd not even said anything about it, as I do try to not moan at the match (that's what this place is for), but all around us people were complaining of how boring and dull it now is.

(09-26-2021, 11:59 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 11:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Duffers.

I remember watching us while we were a making up the numbers laughing stock in Division 1. We didn't play good football then, and if it wasn't for Taylor, Hunt and then Hughes we weren't watching at all in any way, we were just a disaster.

It's been a golden period since then, even with relegations.

I still remember, vividly, being in the Rainbow Stand for the Woking debacle.

Stood on the BRE for that one...my dad cried in the car when we got back to it. Never forget that 'game'.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - Birdman1811 - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 01:23 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 11:19 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Thats a point.

Many fans have said "So long as the team work hard I'm with them."

Well this is the hardest working team we've had since Megson, so why boo them? Do they think the players just shrug and go "Oh the manager isn't playing pretty football, it's directed at him, not us." Or do they think. "These fans are horrible, we're trying and they're still booing us."

Thing is, I only see that trotted out on here. Everyone I know, and those around us at the game are pretty bored with what we're being dished up already. No once heard someone (not on here) say well it's OK because we're finally working 'aaard and are fitter than we've been in ages.

My mate the other night turned to me and said ' Just think Daz, last time we were in this division we were being spoiled with good, entertaining football, now we have this.' I'd not even said anything about it, as I do try to not moan at the match (that's what this place is for), but all around us people were complaining of how boring and dull it now is.

(09-26-2021, 11:59 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 11:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Duffers.

I remember watching us while we were a making up the numbers laughing stock in Division 1. We didn't play good football then, and if it wasn't for Taylor, Hunt and then Hughes we weren't watching at all in any way, we were just a disaster.

It's been a golden period since then, even with relegations.

I still remember, vividly, being in the Rainbow Stand for the Woking debacle.

Stood on the BRE for that one...my dad cried in the car when we got back to it. Never forget that 'game'.

I prefer this style, when it works, as it was more beginning of the season, to what Bilic had. Bilic's 'good football' was built on sand. Once other teams were better at keeping possession, better at finding space, fitter, more energetic, it was no longer good football. For the VAST majority of Bilic's time here, it was awful football, passing for the sake of it, often fucking backwards, the most frustrating thing in football for me. A backwards pass, especially long, is just possession for the sake of it, better lumping it forward to try to force a corner or something. 

But at no point did I ever want to boo Blilic or the team, we always looked like getting promotion, right up to the end of that season, then thankfully Brentford choked. IN the prem, yes he did an awful job, but in his defence somewhat, we did a shit job of getting the team ready for the prem.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - TETLEY74 - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 09:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Things aren't going great.

Unbeaten, in the top 3.

That's hardly bad is it?

At times i'm honestly lost for words with some of our fan base , i really don't know what than want, seem to  think the "we're Albion we've the best squad promotion is just a formality " morons don't help any. I've been going up the shrine  for 45yrs and no matter how we are doing folk still whinge and moan at every miss placed pass. I sit at the back of the brummie and some of vitriol aimed at certain players is frankly embarrassing, friday Hugill who had been on the pitch 5mins or so lost a tussle with a QPR defender one guy a few seats away from me was up out of his seat and telling Hugill "fuck off you useless wanker just fuck off" i despair i really do.


RE: Sorry, but this Manager ain't right for us.... - MrFizz - 09-26-2021

(09-26-2021, 02:11 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 09:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Things aren't going great.

Unbeaten, in the top 3.

That's hardly bad is it?

At times i'm honestly lost for words with some of our fan base , i really don't know what than want, seem to  think the "we're Albion we've the best squad promotion is just a formality " morons don't help any. I've been going up the shrine  for 45yrs and no matter how we are doing folk still whinge and moan at every miss placed pass. I sit at the back of the brummie and some of vitriol aimed at certain players is frankly embarrassing, friday Hugill who had been on the pitch 5mins or so lost a tussle with a QPR defender one guy a few seats away from me was up out of his seat and telling Hugill "fuck off you useless wanker just fuck off" i despair i really do.

Thats why i moved out of the Brummie 4yrs ago and went in the Smev. We reserve our vitriol for the away fans and the stewards if they dont open the back doors on time for a half-time puff. Much more civilised.  Big Grin

(09-26-2021, 11:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 09:53 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(09-26-2021, 09:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Things aren't going great.

Unbeaten, in the top 3.

That's hardly bad is it?


There seems to be a number of quite vociferous fans who think third IS bad as we should be in the top two by rights, and playing tikka talks football to get there.   Having grown up at the Hawthorns of the 80s and 90's I know that we have no divine right to be anywhere, that there is no "Albion way" of playing and generally still feel grateful that we are again competing at the right end of the table.  Maybe that just shows how scarred I am by my early experienced Smile

Anyone who grew up watching us in the late 80s up to 1999 should have a discount on tickets for life, such was the absolute shite on display week after week.

I'm up for that.  Big Grin