RE: Adam Reach - BaggieTom89 - 07-30-2021
Living in Sheffield I see and hear a lot about Reach and his form clearly hasn't been as good the last year or 2 as it was when he was being touted as a £10m+ premier league option.
That being said he's 28, great left foot and can play the wing-back role. On a free transfer he would be perfect cover for Townsend.
Left footed players that have started at Boro and come through Wednesday have never let us down in the past!
RE: Adam Reach - Lurker#3 - 07-30-2021
(07-30-2021, 10:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 08:55 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 07:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Their opinion has to be questioned when they describe us as “huge budget club”
Compared to the rest of the Champ, we are.
Seriously, think you're being a bit of a crying baby over this. Premiership teams are struggling for transfer funds, we've just been relegated, what are you expecting?
I'm not expecting much at all BM... However, with a week to go til the season starts, we have a squad of 19 first team players, including 3 goalkeepers, and 2 of those players haven't been involved in any pre-season games.
We have let 15 players leave since the end of last season, and brought 2 in to replace them alongside Zohore and Kipre returning from loans.
We're going into probably the most important season in our recent history given the impact of the pandemic and our despondent leadership with Livermore looking likely to start in central midfield and Matt Phillips as our first choice striker. I'm not expecting us to spend millions of pounds on players, however I expect us to be a damn sight more prepared for this season than we currently are with a week to go.
Whilst I completely understand concerns about squad depth. The 15 players who have left, none of them were players many wanted to keep. HrK aside. None are for me.
We have Diagnana who will be effectively a new signing and the 2 new lads will be in the first team I would have thought. Add this ti players like Livermore and Sawyers being more than good enough at Chump level. Its not as gloomy as it may seem.
If we can make 2 signings next week. 1 CF definitely and a utility wingback. We won't be too far away.
RE: Adam Reach - SW4Baggie - 07-30-2021
(07-30-2021, 09:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Reach on a free is a no brainer for me, sure he'll demand a decent wage but he's very similar player to Brunty in the fact he's never been the quickest but has a left foot to die for
Big yes from me as competition to Townsend and back up in the midfield
Cuzer
I'll accept I was probably overly critical of Reach. His numbers are pretty good in a struggling side, and the last couple years it's harsh to judge anyone's performance given the basket case of a club Wednesday were.
Free transfer, reasonable wages, he's a decent bench option.
Not one of the "Big 4" though 
(07-30-2021, 10:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 10:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 08:55 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 07:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Their opinion has to be questioned when they describe us as “huge budget club”
Compared to the rest of the Champ, we are.
Seriously, think you're being a bit of a crying baby over this. Premiership teams are struggling for transfer funds, we've just been relegated, what are you expecting?
I'm not expecting much at all BM... However, with a week to go til the season starts, we have a squad of 19 first team players, including 3 goalkeepers, and 2 of those players haven't been involved in any pre-season games.
We have let 15 players leave since the end of last season, and brought 2 in to replace them alongside Zohore and Kipre returning from loans.
We're going into probably the most important season in our recent history given the impact of the pandemic and our despondent leadership with Livermore looking likely to start in central midfield and Matt Phillips as our first choice striker. I'm not expecting us to spend millions of pounds on players, however I expect us to be a damn sight more prepared for this season than we currently are with a week to go.
Whilst I completely understand concerns about squad depth. The 15 players who have left, none of them were players many wanted to keep. HrK aside. None are for me.
We have Diagnana who will be effectively a new signing and the 2 new lads will be in the first team I would have thought. Add this ti players like Livermore and Sawyers being more than good enough at Chump level. Its not as gloomy as it may seem.
If we can make 2 signings next week. 1 CF definitely and a utility wingback. We won't be too far away.
I think it's more that we have lost Diagne, AMN, Gallagher, Okay... That's our midfield and main striker from last season, and Mowatt aside, we've not added anyone to key positions yet.
We need another 5 bodies in by the end of the window, 2 forwards, a midfielder and 2 wide/fullback players. This reduces to 4 if Pereira stays.
The closer to kick off we get, the more it seems we ought to have bitten the bullet on SJ and let him go to WHU for £7-8m.... with the current state EFL clubs are in we'd have managed to get a couple of very decent players in from our competitors for that...
RE: Adam Reach - Birdman1811 - 07-30-2021
Val likes Livermore apparently, and if he gets him fit and lean, he's a good player at this level.
We are short of a striker. And one will come in, but the free transfer options aren't good, and getting teams to sell strikers isn't easy.
RE: Adam Reach - SW4Baggie - 07-30-2021
(07-30-2021, 10:59 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Val likes Livermore apparently, and if he gets him fit and lean, he's a good player at this level.
We are short of a striker. And one will come in, but the free transfer options aren't good, and getting teams to sell strikers isn't easy.
Given how strong our budget apparently is, most clubs ought to be hawking them desperately to us... then again, given we failed to take an interest when Coventry were desperately trying to get us to take Callum Wilson and James Maddison and Blues were touting Redmond and Gray to stay afloat, we probably wouldn't even pick up the phone!
Fit and Lean? Christ. Let's see if we can get him to last til November... The German market will be back this year and those bratwurst wont eat themselves!
RE: Adam Reach - Birdman1811 - 07-30-2021
(07-30-2021, 11:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 10:59 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Val likes Livermore apparently, and if he gets him fit and lean, he's a good player at this level.
We are short of a striker. And one will come in, but the free transfer options aren't good, and getting teams to sell strikers isn't easy.
Given how strong our budget apparently is, most clubs ought to be hawking them desperately to us... then again, given we failed to take an interest when Coventry were desperately trying to get us to take Callum Wilson and James Maddison and Blues were touting Redmond and Gray to stay afloat, we probably wouldn't even pick up the phone!
Fit and Lean? Christ. Let's see if we can get him to last til November... The German market will be back this year and those bratwurst wont eat themselves!
What has events from years ago got to do with now?
Our budget is strong for wages, very little for dead transfer fees, like a lot of clubs without Champions League money or someone prepared to loan the club the cash.
That changes if we can raise some real cash via transfers out. Only two players have enough value or interest, and its likely they'll move late in the window.
RE: Adam Reach - Sliced - 07-30-2021
It’s also worth pointing out that we have strikers. They might not be perfectly suited for a central role but in the champ they’ll be good enough. If Phillips is being played as a central striker it’s Val’s choosing. There’s also Robinson and Grant who can play that role……Zohore as a last resort
RE: Adam Reach - MGalea - 07-30-2021
Shame he's not signing for Coventry. Easy headline for that...which sounds like an old blues (not Birmingham) song.
Reach for the Sky Blues.
My two pennies worth is that he probably fits as a decent back up - as long as he can convince Val that he's up for the aaaard work.
RE: Adam Reach - Hopalong - 07-30-2021
(07-30-2021, 10:48 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 09:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Reach on a free is a no brainer for me, sure he'll demand a decent wage but he's very similar player to Brunty in the fact he's never been the quickest but has a left foot to die for
Big yes from me as competition to Townsend and back up in the midfield
Cuzer
I'll accept I was probably overly critical of Reach. His numbers are pretty good in a struggling side, and the last couple years it's harsh to judge anyone's performance given the basket case of a club Wednesday were.
Free transfer, reasonable wages, he's a decent bench option.
Not one of the "Big 4" though 
(07-30-2021, 10:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 10:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 08:55 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 07:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Their opinion has to be questioned when they describe us as “huge budget club”
Compared to the rest of the Champ, we are.
Seriously, think you're being a bit of a crying baby over this. Premiership teams are struggling for transfer funds, we've just been relegated, what are you expecting?
I'm not expecting much at all BM... However, with a week to go til the season starts, we have a squad of 19 first team players, including 3 goalkeepers, and 2 of those players haven't been involved in any pre-season games.
We have let 15 players leave since the end of last season, and brought 2 in to replace them alongside Zohore and Kipre returning from loans.
We're going into probably the most important season in our recent history given the impact of the pandemic and our despondent leadership with Livermore looking likely to start in central midfield and Matt Phillips as our first choice striker. I'm not expecting us to spend millions of pounds on players, however I expect us to be a damn sight more prepared for this season than we currently are with a week to go.
Whilst I completely understand concerns about squad depth. The 15 players who have left, none of them were players many wanted to keep. HrK aside. None are for me.
We have Diagnana who will be effectively a new signing and the 2 new lads will be in the first team I would have thought. Add this ti players like Livermore and Sawyers being more than good enough at Chump level. Its not as gloomy as it may seem.
If we can make 2 signings next week. 1 CF definitely and a utility wingback. We won't be too far away.
I think it's more that we have lost Diagne, AMN, Gallagher, Okay... That's our midfield and main striker from last season, and Mowatt aside, we've not added anyone to key positions yet.
We need another 5 bodies in by the end of the window, 2 forwards, a midfielder and 2 wide/fullback players. This reduces to 4 if Pereira stays.
The closer to kick off we get, the more it seems we ought to have bitten the bullet on SJ and let him go to WHU for £7-8m.... with the current state EFL clubs are in we'd have managed to get a couple of very decent players in from our competitors for that...
Clarke is a key signing - Val's word not mine!
(07-30-2021, 10:48 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 09:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Reach on a free is a no brainer for me, sure he'll demand a decent wage but he's very similar player to Brunty in the fact he's never been the quickest but has a left foot to die for
Big yes from me as competition to Townsend and back up in the midfield
Cuzer
I'll accept I was probably overly critical of Reach. His numbers are pretty good in a struggling side, and the last couple years it's harsh to judge anyone's performance given the basket case of a club Wednesday were.
Free transfer, reasonable wages, he's a decent bench option.
Not one of the "Big 4" though 
(07-30-2021, 10:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 10:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-30-2021, 08:55 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (07-30-2021, 07:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Their opinion has to be questioned when they describe us as “huge budget club”
Compared to the rest of the Champ, we are.
Seriously, think you're being a bit of a crying baby over this. Premiership teams are struggling for transfer funds, we've just been relegated, what are you expecting?
I'm not expecting much at all BM... However, with a week to go til the season starts, we have a squad of 19 first team players, including 3 goalkeepers, and 2 of those players haven't been involved in any pre-season games.
We have let 15 players leave since the end of last season, and brought 2 in to replace them alongside Zohore and Kipre returning from loans.
We're going into probably the most important season in our recent history given the impact of the pandemic and our despondent leadership with Livermore looking likely to start in central midfield and Matt Phillips as our first choice striker. I'm not expecting us to spend millions of pounds on players, however I expect us to be a damn sight more prepared for this season than we currently are with a week to go.
Whilst I completely understand concerns about squad depth. The 15 players who have left, none of them were players many wanted to keep. HrK aside. None are for me.
We have Diagnana who will be effectively a new signing and the 2 new lads will be in the first team I would have thought. Add this ti players like Livermore and Sawyers being more than good enough at Chump level. Its not as gloomy as it may seem.
If we can make 2 signings next week. 1 CF definitely and a utility wingback. We won't be too far away.
I think it's more that we have lost Diagne, AMN, Gallagher, Okay... That's our midfield and main striker from last season, and Mowatt aside, we've not added anyone to key positions yet.
We need another 5 bodies in by the end of the window, 2 forwards, a midfielder and 2 wide/fullback players. This reduces to 4 if Pereira stays.
The closer to kick off we get, the more it seems we ought to have bitten the bullet on SJ and let him go to WHU for £7-8m.... with the current state EFL clubs are in we'd have managed to get a couple of very decent players in from our competitors for that...
West Ham have signed Areola from PSG.
RE: Adam Reach - Psalm23 - 07-30-2021
Incoming imminent, according to Birmingham live.
|