WBAUnofficial
Johnstone - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Johnstone (/showthread.php?tid=7021)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Johnstone - rsbaggy2 - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.

Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air. 

Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he  flapping like a seal?

We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.

I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.

I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.

By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.

As pointed out by ''Everything Zin'' it sure sounds like a damning critique of Johnstone's performance. One that is seriously flawed. You are blaming him for both goals ... that is evident.

Think you must have something personal against our keeper when you contradict yourself and muddle your own mind.


RE: Johnstone - KratosBaggie - 10-23-2019

I doubt there's any blame to be assigned to Johnstone for either goal. Certainly not the first. I'd like to see the second goal again, I was right behind that and it looked liked the ball went through him, as he dived, but it was a hell of a hit from their player.

He's improved of late and is starting to reach the level I expect from a Championship GK.


RE: Johnstone - chasetownbaggie - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 09:16 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I doubt there's any blame to be assigned to Johnstone for either goal. Certainly not the first. I'd like to see the second goal again, I was right behind that and it looked liked the ball went through him, as he dived, but it was a hell of a hit from their player.

He's improved of late and is starting to reach the level I expect from a Championship GK.

The Barnsley player shouldn't have had time to get the shot away. We were way too slow closing him down.


RE: Johnstone - KratosBaggie - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 09:23 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 09:16 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I doubt there's any blame to be assigned to Johnstone for either goal. Certainly not the first. I'd like to see the second goal again, I was right behind that and it looked liked the ball went through him, as he dived, but it was a hell of a hit from their player.

He's improved of late and is starting to reach the level I expect from a Championship GK.

The Barnsley player shouldn't have had time to get the shot away. We were way too slow closing him down.

Agreed. We do seem to concede our fair amount of goals from distance. That's a team problem.


RE: Johnstone - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 09:00 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 01:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: He was great tonight.

Let one in on his near post, from an admittedly good header, when the defence should have protected him. Clawing at thin air. 

Second one was a very good shot, but at a savable height, when he was positioned too far to his left. A full stretch save didn't cover his posts. I doubt a Chump keeper would have saved it, but a Prem Keeper would be closer at that height, and from that distance. It wasn't "top corner". A Chump goal. He had no right to save either, and no blame attaches, but his feet were in treacle. How about that mess when Barnsley hit the bar in the second half, when Woodrow should have completed his hat-trick? Was that good? Why was he  flapping like a seal?

We played out from the back at times, and this was a good time to do it. Don't play out against a high press, do it when the opposition are sitting deep. I get it. Fuck me, he played the Centre Halves into trouble on more than one occasion, by giving them them the ball when they were facing him, with players on their back.

I fear if we don't get promoted then we are stuck with him. If we do get promoted, we should do like The Seals have done, and sign someone who is actually reliable and competent. Tom Heaton or Johnstone - who would you rather have? He is 27 in March, for FFS. Foster played for England when he was 24 last cap at 31. SJ isn't a young inexperienced keeper any more.

I don't blame him for the goals tonight, but as Clint Eastwood once said "A man has to know his limitations"; and Sam has plenty.

By contrast, Bradley Collins in the Barnsley goal is 22 years old. Yes he has limitations. He isn't a classy keeper, and didn't make any "worldies". He only conceded 2 goals tonight though, came through the Chelsea Academy, and cost Barnsley nothing.

As pointed out by ''Everything Zin'' it sure sounds like a damning critique of Johnstone's performance. One that is seriously flawed. You are blaming him for both goals ... that is evident.

Think you must have something personal against our keeper when you contradict yourself and muddle your own mind.

I'm not blaming him at all, and I have made this perfectly clear in my critique.

I think SJ will play for England one day, just like Scott Carson did whilst wearing our colours. That will be a proud day for us all


RE: Johnstone - TETLEY74 - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 09:23 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 09:16 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I doubt there's any blame to be assigned to Johnstone for either goal. Certainly not the first. I'd like to see the second goal again, I was right behind that and it looked liked the ball went through him, as he dived, but it was a hell of a hit from their player.

He's improved of late and is starting to reach the level I expect from a Championship GK.

The Barnsley player shouldn't have had time to get the shot away. We were way too slow closing him down.
Note had time to get a shot away, contrast that with our tendency to over play things when on the edge of the opposition box!


RE: Johnstone - Remi_Moses - 10-23-2019

KKC I think we know you made your mind up about Sam
Josh we know you detest Bartley.
I would love you pair to try and post something good about some of the other 23 players. Apart from that have a nice day - we are top of the league.


RE: Johnstone - KratosBaggie - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 02:08 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: KKC I think we know you made your mind up about Sam
Josh we know you detest Bartley.
I would love you pair to try and post something good about some of the other 23 players. Apart from that have a nice day - we are top of the league.

I'm positive about plenty of our players...


RE: Johnstone - Remi_Moses - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 02:15 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 02:08 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: KKC I think we know you made your mind up about Sam
Josh we know you detest Bartley.
I would love you pair to try and post something good about some of the other 23 players. Apart from that have a nice day - we are top of the league.

I'm positive about plenty of our players...

You maybe, but you can't see past Bartley Huh - your posts about him out number the posts on the other 24 players.
That's why you are completely biased but can't see it. Go back and count them up, you may then see you how big a problem you have.

I'd much rather you sing the praises of one player then continually knock one player and never! never! never! do it during a game. 

I'm not sure if your trying to get your crown back from Ziz - if you are it's working.


RE: Johnstone - KratosBaggie - 10-23-2019

(10-23-2019, 04:16 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 02:15 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2019, 02:08 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: KKC I think we know you made your mind up about Sam
Josh we know you detest Bartley.
I would love you pair to try and post something good about some of the other 23 players. Apart from that have a nice day - we are top of the league.

I'm positive about plenty of our players...

You maybe, but you can't see past Bartley Huh - your posts about him out number the posts on the other 24 players.
That's why you are completely biased but can't see it. Go back and count them up, you may then see you how big a problem you have.

I'd much rather you sing the praises of one player then continually knock one player and never! never! never! do it during a game. 

I'm not sure if your trying to get your crown back from Ziz - if you are it's working.

I'm not the only one to criticise his performances.