WBAUnofficial
Happy Brexit Day - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Happy Brexit Day (/showthread.php?tid=41887)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Borin' Baggie - 06-30-2026

Do you care to engage with the actual point about the fact that the BoE needed to do something to prevent the cascading effects from the measured data that supports the credit conditions (actual, quantifiable data and not conjecture) filtering into the wider economy?

Also, ark at the guy who voted to hamstring the economy by loading it with loads of red tape acting like he's some kind of economic expert. Absolutely priceless.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - man in the corner shop - 07-01-2026

(06-30-2026, 07:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Start with the first bit Proth - admit the mistake

I have admitted that I was mistaken in my belief that Parliament was capable of statecraft.

Oh Christ. Not this failure of statecraft bullshit again.
It was never up to the UK parliament. Despite the Brexiter fantasy that "we have all the cards" the UK had no cards in reality and the EU was always going to dictate terms. Absolutely deluded to believe anything else.

"I was mistaken."

Well I will bookmark that as that is a first ever for you on this bored. Bravo, you are moving into adulthood.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Protheroe - 07-01-2026

(06-30-2026, 10:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you care to engage with the actual point about the fact that the BoE needed to do something to prevent the cascading effects from the measured data that supports the credit conditions (actual, quantifiable data and not conjecture) filtering into the wider economy?

Also, ark at the guy who voted to hamstring the economy by loading it with loads of red tape acting like he's some kind of economic expert. Absolutely priceless.

There is no point to engage with. The BoE can prepare any hullshit report to justify any bullshit decision.

I am bemused by the faith you have in the opinions of an organisation that has failed so persistently.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - baggy1 - 07-01-2026

(06-30-2026, 10:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The former Chief Economist at the BoE said “I consider myself moderately financially literate — yet I confess to not being able to make the remotest sense of pensions.”  That makes him an idiot in my book, as pensions are remarkably simple. 

(06-30-2026, 10:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And how exactly were we harmed by being part of it?

I prefer to vote for who governs. But maybe that's just me.

Two points here, a better quote to give is the full quote and a bit of context. It was a relatively off the cuff remark about the mechanics of pensions and not the general concept. A bit more from the same quote that you have shortened “He said: “To give a personal example, I consider myself moderately financially literate. Yet I confess to not being able to make the remotest sense of pensions. Conversations with countless experts and independent financial advisers have confirmed for me only one thing – that they have no clue either.

“That is a desperately poor basis for sound financial planning.”

What he was getting at was likely to be the mechanics of how Pensions work, are valued and how the investments actually get calculated. And he is right on that point, having worked for the largest Pension company in the UK and having looked at the funds in real detail I can tell you that there is a reason actuaries get paid what they do. If you consider financial advisors have the same knowledge and expertise as actuaries then you have to wonder why they wouldn’t want to earn their money.

When you consider that someone is an idiot because you have been misquoted and had words taken out of the context in which they were set it may not be the person that is being quoted that is the idiot here.

And secondly, we have and were never governed by the EU, this was the biggest myth that fooled the masses. The EU set out guidelines and recommendations that the ‘club’ needed to interpret. The fact that we interpreted them in the way we did was entirely up to us. The reason for this is that as a block we have more strength to deal with the rest of the world and the global superpowers - this benefitted us greatly. And the irony that you view a group of States that have a wider governing body as the ideal is not lost here. We benefitted greatly by being a part of the EU, this was always clear before and has been proven now with 10 years of losing about £100bn a year in trade, the result is clear to see without even focussing on the £40bn in extra taxes that have been lost (the very same black hole amount as it stands).

The fact that 10 years on people can’t see what is in our interest and are suffering mass psychosis still and a massive dose of being too proud means that we will always be fucked


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Borin' Baggie - 07-01-2026

(07-01-2026, 05:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 10:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you care to engage with the actual point about the fact that the BoE needed to do something to prevent the cascading effects from the measured data that supports the credit conditions (actual, quantifiable data and not conjecture) filtering into the wider economy?

Also, ark at the guy who voted to hamstring the economy by loading it with loads of red tape acting like he's some kind of economic expert. Absolutely priceless.

There is no point to engage with. The BoE can prepare any hullshit report to justify any bullshit decision.

I am bemused by the faith you have in the opinions of an organisation that has failed so persistently.

The BoE do not magic up swap rates, wholesale funding spreads, deposit rates, transfer prices and long-term bank debt. These are all measured data, read the fucking credit conditions report, you do not need to trust any organisation to acknowledge data points and trends. For fucks sakes man you're coming across as a bloody conspiracy theory, all because of what? To avoid admitting how stupid Brexit was, to avoid admitting that red tape constricts economic activity? It's pathetic.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Protheroe - 07-01-2026

(07-01-2026, 07:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-01-2026, 05:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 10:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do you care to engage with the actual point about the fact that the BoE needed to do something to prevent the cascading effects from the measured data that supports the credit conditions (actual, quantifiable data and not conjecture) filtering into the wider economy?

Also, ark at the guy who voted to hamstring the economy by loading it with loads of red tape acting like he's some kind of economic expert. Absolutely priceless.

There is no point to engage with. The BoE can prepare any hullshit report to justify any bullshit decision.

I am bemused by the faith you have in the opinions of an organisation that has failed so persistently.

The BoE do not magic up swap rates, wholesale funding spreads, deposit rates, transfer prices and long-term bank debt. These are all measured data, read the fucking credit conditions report, you do not need to trust any organisation to acknowledge data points and trends. For fucks sakes man you're coming across as a bloody conspiracy theory, all because of what? To avoid admitting how stupid Brexit was, to avoid admitting that red tape constricts economic activity? It's pathetic.

The BoE managed to actively distort markets for over a decade and a half BB. Markets would work a lot better and governments would be a lot more responsible without such distortion.

(07-01-2026, 06:09 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 10:26 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The former Chief Economist at the BoE said “I consider myself moderately financially literate — yet I confess to not being able to make the remotest sense of pensions.”  That makes him an idiot in my book, as pensions are remarkably simple. 

(06-30-2026, 10:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And how exactly were we harmed by being part of it?

I prefer to vote for who governs. But maybe that's just me.

Two points here, a better quote to give is the full quote and a bit of context. It was a relatively off the cuff remark about the mechanics of pensions and not the general concept. A bit more from the same quote that you have shortened “He said: “To give a personal example, I consider myself moderately financially literate. Yet I confess to not being able to make the remotest sense of pensions. Conversations with countless experts and independent financial advisers have confirmed for me only one thing – that they have no clue either.

“That is a desperately poor basis for sound financial planning.”

What he was getting at was likely to be the mechanics of how Pensions work, are valued and how the investments actually get calculated. And he is right on that point, having worked for the largest Pension company in the UK and having looked at the funds in real detail I can tell you that there is a reason actuaries get paid what they do. If you consider financial advisors have the same knowledge and expertise as actuaries then you have to wonder why they wouldn’t want to earn their money.

When you consider that someone is an idiot because you have been misquoted and had words taken out of the context in which they were set it may not be the person that is being quoted that is the idiot here.

And secondly, we have and were never governed by the EU, this was the biggest myth that fooled the masses. The EU set out guidelines and recommendations that the ‘club’ needed to interpret. The fact that we interpreted them in the way we did was entirely up to us. The reason for this is that as a block we have more strength to deal with the rest of the world and the global superpowers - this benefitted us greatly. And the irony that you view a group of States that have a wider governing body as the ideal is not lost here. We benefitted greatly by being a part of the EU, this was always clear before and has been proven now with 10 years of losing about £100bn a year in trade, the result is clear to see without even focussing on the £40bn in extra taxes that have been lost (the very same black hole amount as it stands).

The fact that 10 years on people can’t see what is in our interest and are suffering mass psychosis still and a massive dose of being too proud means that we will always be fucked

Use my full quote "Guess who's now advising Smart Casual Starmer on things like pensions. Perhaps he should look in the mirror and consider a decade or more of loose monetary policy so distorted market returns that it is still hard to find a chart that isn’t hinting at a bubble."

I'd say BoE policy is "a desperately poor basis for sound financial planning." So yes, I consider him an idiot. And in my experience IFAs know very little more than the anyone remotely financially literate. Far better for most people to get a clutch of cheap index funds or ETFs.

You have your opinion on the EU, I have mine. You're not going to alter yours, neither am I.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Borin' Baggie - 07-01-2026

The BoE in 2016 cutting interest rates by 0.25% to prevent the fallout of all of those metrics filtering into the wider economy until the certainty of how Brexit was to be managed before raising them again a year later after they had settled is not the same as what happened post-2008 (which I would like to point out to you again was extended because of the Brexit vote as Carney had explicitly indicated he was looking to raise rates prior to the vote).


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Protheroe - 07-01-2026

The BoE wrote it's own justification for a needless interest rate cut, the same as it lies every quarter about when inflation will return to target BB. The BoE has been chronically wrong about everything since the world fell apart (on its watch) in 2008.


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Borin' Baggie - 07-01-2026

The BoE do not control the fucking metrics, they are publicly viewable and traceable. What the hell are you on about, seriously? Do you think that the BoE somehow conspired with the international banking system and credit authorities to manipulate the data to justify the reasons for the temporary 0.25% cut or something? All without any pushback?

And the BoE were looking to raise rates prior to the vote to leave, they have to balance the effect on inflation with public and private debt and the economic conditions were improving slower than hoped to enable that, and then we voted to leave which cut that route off. Why do you think they hired the noted monetary hawk who pushed for the BoC to hold rates post-financial crisis instead of someone else in the doveish Mervyn King mould?


RE: Happy Brexit Day - Protheroe - 07-01-2026

(07-01-2026, 11:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What the hell are you on about, seriously? 

The BoE policy was a qualitative assessment of quantitative data. Just as the decision NOT to raise rates was when faced with the blindingly obvious post-Covid inflation juggernaut.