![]() |
|
The cost of living crisis - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: The cost of living crisis (/showthread.php?tid=23621) |
RE: The cost of living crisis - baggy1 - 02-04-2022 You've conflated two of my points there; I didn't say levelling up would be achieved by cutting VAT. Maybe i should have bullet pointed it: It's no good:
I agree with you on the training and education, but again this is an area that has been chronically underfunded and kids are left to rot in the pit they find themselves in. That is where levelling up needs to start, not by installing regional mayors and all of the layering of government that involves. Rewarding of benefactors with contracts, peerages and policy decisions to give those benefactors the licence to print money, be that in housing, gambling, energy or finance, with one eye on their own future beyond politics is not thinking of the countries best interest. It is damaging the country by funnelling funds and efforts in the wrong direction - away from the public. That is where the status (beliefs of the right to be PM), wealth (future income and current questionable transactions), kudos (look at me, I'm in charge and can do what I want approach) come from. And this is the same party that made the policy decisions through idealism and Don Quixote style crusades that have led us to this position, you don't have the luxury of distancing them from the past 12 years of a party shifting further to the right until it got stung and found out by the pandemic. And you absolutely can't unwind these issues when that involves admitting you were wrong 1st - something this party simply will not do. Austerity was wrong, Brexit was, at best, pointless and probably wrong in the longer term (look at the situation in NI). And you proactively did what you could to create the political environment we find ourselves in, pulling up the ladder when the going gets a bit tough is probably not the right approach. RE: The cost of living crisis - Sotv - 02-04-2022 (02-04-2022, 02:04 PM)Baggybenny Wrote: do whatever they can for themselves and their families. and what' wrong with anarchy? RE: The cost of living crisis - Protheroe - 02-04-2022 (02-04-2022, 02:04 PM)Baggybenny Wrote: do whatever they can for themselves and their families. Enlightened self interest is actually the basis for civilised society. (02-04-2022, 02:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You've conflated two of my points there; I didn't say levelling up would be achieved by cutting VAT. Maybe i should have bullet pointed it: I'm afraid I don't recognise your caricature of a party moving to the right. It hasn't. Quite the opposite. The party could admit it was wrong about zero interest rates, QE and slavishly falling into line with Brown over the bank bailout. The state got bigger every year that Osborne was Chancellor. Austerity? Like I said the other week - if you thought that was austere just wait for the next 24-months. I did what I did to further the cause of economic and social liberalism. You'd never have achieved the former under Brown, Miliband or Corbyn. I am sadly disappointed that successive Tory governments have moved further away from sound money and the supply side. I have better things to do than swim against the tide. RE: The cost of living crisis - baggy1 - 02-04-2022 By 2019 it had to morph itself into the Brexit party to win votes, that's pretty far right as far as I can see. The nationalism and popularism that was spouted at around that time has led us to this point directly where your theories have been destroyed and shown to be unworkable. Economic and social liberalism in simple terms is I'll do what I like with my money and my life and suffer the consequences in theory, but the reality is that people don't want to suffer the consequences so it's an unworkable theory. Your economic theories have failed because they ultimately need the state to bail us all out, as has been proven beyond doubt over the last couple of years. We are a spoilt generation that had to learn this the hard way and some still don't see it, our parents / grandparents had to rely on the state because otherwise we would have been under Nazi rule and once that enemy was defeated there was a realisation that we needed to build for the greater protection of our society. We are at a similar point now and can either realise that we need to build a better safety net or throw it all to the wind in the name of social and economic liberalism. Your view that you will look after your family is fine, until you can't. RE: The cost of living crisis - backsidebaggie - 02-04-2022 I think generalising about moving to the right or left is a nonsense personally. I’m some ways the tories have moved to the right, I agree Baggy1. But in some ways Proth is spot on (economically). I still say the current inflation is nothing to do with things like brexit or this government particularly. Inflation is happening in NZ, Oz, USA, Canada, U.K., EU, all over the place. It’s surely more to do with the bigger economic world picture? Money supply, massive quantitative easing in the major economies etc? RE: The cost of living crisis - backsidebaggie - 02-10-2022 Inflation spiralling to 20% at least is my guess. The economic carnage is beginning. Why did the b of e try to pretend inflation would stop at 4%? Was never going to happen. https://www.google.com/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/lifting-wages-in-line-with-inflation-could-add-momentum-to-price-spiral-boe-official-warns-12537473 RE: The cost of living crisis - Protheroe - 02-10-2022 (02-10-2022, 09:55 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Inflation spiralling to 20% at least is my guess. The economic carnage is beginning. Why did the b of e try to pretend inflation would stop at 4%? Was never going to happen. Although I don't believe CPI inflation will reach double figures here (I think it will in the US), I do think anyone who was moaning about Tory "austerity" has no concept of the actual austerity coming via inflation, interest rate rises, tax increases and Rishi's fiscal drag. Corporate earnings and valuations are likely to hold up as we emerge from the Pandemic, but personal finances will be in all sorts of trouble for many many people. RE: The cost of living crisis - Derek Hardballs - 02-10-2022 (02-04-2022, 04:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By 2019 it had to morph itself into the Brexit party to win votes, that's pretty far right as far as I can see. The nationalism and popularism that was spouted at around that time has led us to this point directly where your theories have been destroyed and shown to be unworkable. Economic and social liberalism in simple terms is I'll do what I like with my money and my life and suffer the consequences in theory, but the reality is that people don't want to suffer the consequences so it's an unworkable theory. Your economic theories have failed because they ultimately need the state to bail us all out, as has been proven beyond doubt over the last couple of years. Great post. Sadly Proth will never admit he’s wrong or take responsibility for helping the worst government this country has had to endure in living memory. Like a naughty school boy getting caught, he’s now casually walking away trying to pretend it has nothing to do with him. RE: The cost of living crisis - backsidebaggie - 02-10-2022 (02-10-2022, 10:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(02-04-2022, 04:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By 2019 it had to morph itself into the Brexit party to win votes, that's pretty far right as far as I can see. The nationalism and popularism that was spouted at around that time has led us to this point directly where your theories have been destroyed and shown to be unworkable. Economic and social liberalism in simple terms is I'll do what I like with my money and my life and suffer the consequences in theory, but the reality is that people don't want to suffer the consequences so it's an unworkable theory. Your economic theories have failed because they ultimately need the state to bail us all out, as has been proven beyond doubt over the last couple of years. The current inflation increase is nothing to do with brexit or this government particularly (and I’m a remainer and not a Tory voter) though DH. It’s worldwide. People are really barking up the wrong tree if they think it’s a national issue. Just look around the world. The same is happening in America, Europe, Canada, Oz, everywhere. Proth, you may be right about CPI, but that in itself is a very conservative measure of true inflation. I really think it’s going to spiral. RE: The cost of living crisis - Protheroe - 02-10-2022 (02-10-2022, 10:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(02-04-2022, 04:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By 2019 it had to morph itself into the Brexit party to win votes, that's pretty far right as far as I can see. The nationalism and popularism that was spouted at around that time has led us to this point directly where your theories have been destroyed and shown to be unworkable. Economic and social liberalism in simple terms is I'll do what I like with my money and my life and suffer the consequences in theory, but the reality is that people don't want to suffer the consequences so it's an unworkable theory. Your economic theories have failed because they ultimately need the state to bail us all out, as has been proven beyond doubt over the last couple of years. I have no idea what you're sniffing Baggy1. You talk about the "failure" of economic liberalism - yet we only began making progress towards it in the 1980s - never reached the destination and progress stopped dead in 2008 when governments nationalised individual and corporate risk, embraced moral hazard as an old friend and dropped the concept of sound money. The whole point of liberalism is that individuals and corporations bear risk. As it is we've all been sucking on the teat of the state since 2008, revelling in free money and asset price inflation. Do you think any of that is in anyway liberal? The problems we've had in the last two years have been compounded by our whole approach since the financial crisis. The shakeout due from 2008 has been delayed again, the fallout will now be greater and the cost of living crisis will prove to be the foothills in something far more long term and insidious - unless we break the cycle. An ever dwindling number of Tory MPs hold the flickering flame of economic liberalism. That's the Party I willingly campaigned for. That flame is about to be snuffed out. You're right that the challenge we face is as big as it was after WW2, that big state experiment ended up in the carnage of the 1970s. The experiment started in 2008 will end up the same. What's the definition of insanity? |