WBAUnofficial
Championship - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Championship (/showthread.php?tid=29279)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Championship - Calgary_Baggie - 03-19-2023

(03-19-2023, 10:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: We have 2 decent keepers;
Kipre and Taylor back - Ajayi, Bryan & Pieters (maybe harsh but Father Time and wages).  If we could do a deal to release Kelly early that would be great;
Chalobah was signed on 18mth deal so stuck with him, Livermore will free up wages (and loads of space!);
Rogic - probably decent wages that can be saved too, Mowatt should be loaned again;
Albrighton can go back to Leicester; and
Find a home for Grant, a loan fee and his wages paid for would be great.

Needed:
2 full backs unless the kids are ready to step up, don’t believe so from what I’ve seen and heard;
2 midfielders, one a no10 type and the other a box to box leader;
A winger to cover/challenge Phillips, Grady and Wallace; and
A centre forward.

6 signings shouldn’t be difficult if 2 or 3 are loans.  Getting the loans right can be the difference between top 6 or not, look at Harvey Barnes, Dwight Gayle and Jordan Hugill as perfect examples.

Hugill??


RE: Championship - CA Baggie - 03-19-2023

(03-19-2023, 10:55 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 10:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: We have 2 decent keepers;
Kipre and Taylor back - Ajayi, Bryan & Pieters (maybe harsh but Father Time and wages).  If we could do a deal to release Kelly early that would be great;
Chalobah was signed on 18mth deal so stuck with him, Livermore will free up wages (and loads of space!);
Rogic - probably decent wages that can be saved too, Mowatt should be loaned again;
Albrighton can go back to Leicester; and
Find a home for Grant, a loan fee and his wages paid for would be great.

Needed:
2 full backs unless the kids are ready to step up, don’t believe so from what I’ve seen and heard;
2 midfielders, one a no10 type and the other a box to box leader;
A winger to cover/challenge Phillips, Grady and Wallace; and
A centre forward.

6 signings shouldn’t be difficult if 2 or 3 are loans.  Getting the loans right can be the difference between top 6 or not, look at Harvey Barnes, Dwight Gayle and Jordan Hugill as perfect examples.

Hugill??

He was the example of getting it wrong Nick.  The definition of cheap, nasty and lazy.


RE: Championship - Calgary_Baggie - 03-19-2023

(03-19-2023, 10:57 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 10:55 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 10:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: We have 2 decent keepers;
Kipre and Taylor back - Ajayi, Bryan & Pieters (maybe harsh but Father Time and wages).  If we could do a deal to release Kelly early that would be great;
Chalobah was signed on 18mth deal so stuck with him, Livermore will free up wages (and loads of space!);
Rogic - probably decent wages that can be saved too, Mowatt should be loaned again;
Albrighton can go back to Leicester; and
Find a home for Grant, a loan fee and his wages paid for would be great.

Needed:
2 full backs unless the kids are ready to step up, don’t believe so from what I’ve seen and heard;
2 midfielders, one a no10 type and the other a box to box leader;
A winger to cover/challenge Phillips, Grady and Wallace; and
A centre forward.

6 signings shouldn’t be difficult if 2 or 3 are loans.  Getting the loans right can be the difference between top 6 or not, look at Harvey Barnes, Dwight Gayle and Jordan Hugill as perfect examples.

Hugill??

He was the example of getting it wrong Nick.  The definition of cheap, nasty and lazy.

Very much. But you mentioned him amongst Barnes and Gayle.

An absolutely diabolical signing. Completely laughable in fact.


RE: Championship - BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine - 03-19-2023

(03-19-2023, 09:06 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Pieters has been class but he will soon hit an age where his legs go. He already survives on nous. Whether we keep him on depends on what options we have in front of him. I’d call back Kipre and Taylor and ship out Ajayi

Exactly. Also depends on his wages when ideally he'd be a back-up rather than a definite starter.

(03-19-2023, 10:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: We have 2 decent keepers;
Kipre and Taylor back - Ajayi, Bryan & Pieters (maybe harsh but Father Time and wages).  If we could do a deal to release Kelly early that would be great;
Chalobah was signed on 18mth deal so stuck with him, Livermore will free up wages (and loads of space!);
Rogic - probably decent wages that can be saved too, Mowatt should be loaned again;
Albrighton can go back to Leicester; and
Find a home for Grant, a loan fee and his wages paid for would be great.

Needed:
2 full backs unless the kids are ready to step up, don’t believe so from what I’ve seen and heard;
2 midfielders, one a no10 type and the other a box to box leader;
A winger to cover/challenge Phillips, Grady and Wallace; and
A centre forward.

6 signings shouldn’t be difficult if 2 or 3 are loans.  Getting the loans right can be the difference between top 6 or not, look at Harvey Barnes, Dwight Gayle and Jordan Hugill as perfect examples.


Agree with everything you say we will need but would still like to see Grady moved on. I expect him to be a bench warmer at best next season if CC and he is still here.


RE: Championship - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-20-2023

(03-19-2023, 10:50 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: We have 2 decent keepers;
Kipre and Taylor back - Ajayi, Bryan & Pieters (maybe harsh but Father Time and wages).  If we could do a deal to release Kelly early that would be great;
Chalobah was signed on 18mth deal so stuck with him, Livermore will free up wages (and loads of space!);
Rogic - probably decent wages that can be saved too, Mowatt should be loaned again;
Albrighton can go back to Leicester; and
Find a home for Grant, a loan fee and his wages paid for would be great.

Needed:
2 full backs unless the kids are ready to step up, don’t believe so from what I’ve seen and heard;
2 midfielders, one a no10 type and the other a box to box leader;
A winger to cover/challenge Phillips, Grady and Wallace; and
A centre forward.

6 signings shouldn’t be difficult if 2 or 3 are loans.  Getting the loans right can be the difference between top 6 or not, look at Harvey Barnes, Dwight Gayle and Jordan Hugill as perfect examples.

Six signings of any quality will be nigh-on impossible.

They don't sign for nothing. Lukaku cost £1M as an unproven striker all those years ago, for example


RE: Championship - AnelkasBeard - 03-20-2023

(03-19-2023, 02:01 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 12:23 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: The only question mark for summer 23 (apart from kids) will be, Rogic?  Worth keeping? Talent but not sure myself and will be on good wages.  Can we find a more mobile number 10?

If you look at the players here until summer 24, the form that both Phillip's and the Bartman showed under CC before injuries suggest that far from being the liability we envisaged on extending, they can both be first 11 come start of season and will be valuable to squad for their final year.

Yes we could do with a real leader either at the back or in CM but that's a valuable commodity, maybe we can add in the fullback area.  Thinking of the impact Clememt, Reid made and also the much maligned Ridgewell, surely they will look at competition for both full backs regardless. 

Maybe a left footed CB, but Pieters must be thinking he's earned another year? Cf I would only expect a loanee as they will be third choice.  Another runner for CM? So Mumby cam ve rested. Hoped TGH might step up, but doesn't seem to have trust of manager yet. 

The big question really is around Grady and Grant?? That's were a lot of our book value still sits.  I'm presuming they will be looking for a loan for Grant, as I dont think he suits the Corberan way.  His exit allows space for a youngster with some real pace to come in, as we nearly did with Hutchinson in the Jan window. 

Grady continues to be the conundrum.  Frustrating for months, then finds some form and gets injured.  Personally think a loan would be best for all, but we continue to hope next season it all comes together again.  At least his book value is going down, so we may even be open to offers.

So if we do fall short, I dont see the need to despair.  Good manager, decent squad (not top 2, but good enough to be in the mixer) and a bit of squad strengthening/freshening leaves us good to go again next year.  After that, who knows?

Rogic, Pieters, Grady, Grant, Button, Kipre and Livermore all need moving on this summer. If that means letting both Grady and Grant go out on loan (or selling Grady for a nominal fee) then it has to happen, no ifs, no buts. With those wages off the books it will be possible to build a squad of promising, hungry younger players and 2-3 Prem loans.

Palmer, Griffiths, O'Shea, Yokuslu, Molumby, Swift, Wallace, Dike and BTA would be the only ones I'd definitely keep. 

Not even sure about Philips, Bartley, Ajayi, Chalobah, Townsend and Furlong. If we could ship them out too they can be replaced with players at least as good but on less money. I've always liked Philips but we can't afford another 4-5 month season from him. I'd fancy the chance of a fee for Chalobah and the others would have suitors from Champ clubs.

I think what you describe is a bit naive and dangerous. Changing 10-15 players in a squad is an absolute recipe for disaster. CC would have to again impart his tactics and philosophy to 2/3rds of the squad instead of improving the understanding. It would take time for the players to learn each others strengths and get use to playing with each other. Time we can't afford to take. This is fine if you're talking about 5/6 players swapping around, but that many is asking for trouble. Continuity is hugely important.

Button, Livermore and one of Kipre/Ajayi are dead certs to leave I think. We were also clearly okay with letting Grant go in January, so if we can find another suitor, he will go too. That's a player from each part of the pitch.

Pieters should absolutely stay for another year. He starts the season, and hopefully be replaced by Kipre/Taylor or another when they improve. His experience is invaluable. I don't see Grady going anyway because of his injury rehab, and his wages. Rogic, has shown flashes but not enough. I'd be fine seeing him go if we get another similar player in.

Phillips and Bartley should absolutely stay. But for injuries, they'd probably be in the starting 11 now and proved useful players. Same idea as Pieters, they start the season and hopefully get usurped by younger players as the season goes on. Chalobah has been disappointing, but he won't be going anywhere. And the full backs have to stay. If you're getting rid of both fullbacks and Pieters, that's a whole new defence. Again, continuity is important. By all means sign a new fullback or two, or promote a youngster, but make it a competition.


RE: Championship - Spandaubaggie - 03-20-2023

Presuming we don't go up it really is a case of as Anelka said, of evolution over revolution.

Given a full-season we would certainly have been top 3 or 4 with this squad under CC. The fringe players now will go and I expect to see those 4-5 replaced with likewise and maybe a couple of youngsters finding their way through.

I certainly wouldn't write Grady off yet either, but if we do get good money for him wouldn't be averse to seeing him go.


RE: Championship - SW4Baggie - 03-20-2023

(03-20-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 02:01 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(03-19-2023, 12:23 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: The only question mark for summer 23 (apart from kids) will be, Rogic?  Worth keeping? Talent but not sure myself and will be on good wages.  Can we find a more mobile number 10?

If you look at the players here until summer 24, the form that both Phillip's and the Bartman showed under CC before injuries suggest that far from being the liability we envisaged on extending, they can both be first 11 come start of season and will be valuable to squad for their final year.

Yes we could do with a real leader either at the back or in CM but that's a valuable commodity, maybe we can add in the fullback area.  Thinking of the impact Clememt, Reid made and also the much maligned Ridgewell, surely they will look at competition for both full backs regardless. 

Maybe a left footed CB, but Pieters must be thinking he's earned another year? Cf I would only expect a loanee as they will be third choice.  Another runner for CM? So Mumby cam ve rested. Hoped TGH might step up, but doesn't seem to have trust of manager yet. 

The big question really is around Grady and Grant?? That's were a lot of our book value still sits.  I'm presuming they will be looking for a loan for Grant, as I dont think he suits the Corberan way.  His exit allows space for a youngster with some real pace to come in, as we nearly did with Hutchinson in the Jan window. 

Grady continues to be the conundrum.  Frustrating for months, then finds some form and gets injured.  Personally think a loan would be best for all, but we continue to hope next season it all comes together again.  At least his book value is going down, so we may even be open to offers.

So if we do fall short, I dont see the need to despair.  Good manager, decent squad (not top 2, but good enough to be in the mixer) and a bit of squad strengthening/freshening leaves us good to go again next year.  After that, who knows?

Rogic, Pieters, Grady, Grant, Button, Kipre and Livermore all need moving on this summer. If that means letting both Grady and Grant go out on loan (or selling Grady for a nominal fee) then it has to happen, no ifs, no buts. With those wages off the books it will be possible to build a squad of promising, hungry younger players and 2-3 Prem loans.

Palmer, Griffiths, O'Shea, Yokuslu, Molumby, Swift, Wallace, Dike and BTA would be the only ones I'd definitely keep. 

Not even sure about Philips, Bartley, Ajayi, Chalobah, Townsend and Furlong. If we could ship them out too they can be replaced with players at least as good but on less money. I've always liked Philips but we can't afford another 4-5 month season from him. I'd fancy the chance of a fee for Chalobah and the others would have suitors from Champ clubs.

I think what you describe is a bit naive and dangerous. Changing 10-15 players in a squad is an absolute recipe for disaster. CC would have to again impart his tactics and philosophy to 2/3rds of the squad instead of improving the understanding. It would take time for the players to learn each others strengths and get use to playing with each other. Time we can't afford to take. This is fine if you're talking about 5/6 players swapping around, but that many is asking for trouble. Continuity is hugely important.

Button, Livermore and one of Kipre/Ajayi are dead certs to leave I think. We were also clearly okay with letting Grant go in January, so if we can find another suitor, he will go too. That's a player from each part of the pitch.

Pieters should absolutely stay for another year. He starts the season, and hopefully be replaced by Kipre/Taylor or another when they improve. His experience is invaluable. I don't see Grady going anyway because of his injury rehab, and his wages. Rogic, has shown flashes but not enough. I'd be fine seeing him go if we get another similar player in.

Phillips and Bartley should absolutely stay. But for injuries, they'd probably be in the starting 11 now and proved useful players. Same idea as Pieters, they start the season and hopefully get usurped by younger players as the season goes on. Chalobah has been disappointing, but he won't be going anywhere. And the full backs have to stay. If you're getting rid of both fullbacks and Pieters, that's a whole new defence. Again, continuity is important. By all means sign a new fullback or two, or promote a youngster, but make it a competition.

Agree with a lot of this, but think both Pieters and Rogic need to be given our thanks and packed off - we have spent far too much of our wage budget over the last few years letting sentiment get in the way. Pieters has done well since coming in, but he's a short term fix and definitely not someone we should be relying on next year. 

Rogic, Livermore, Pieters, Bryan and Albrighton all should leave this summer... I'd argue this is north of £100k/wk off the wage bill, and we will have Kipre, Kelly and Mowatt returning (for argument's sake, about £45k/wk back on).

We will need to cut our spending again this summer, so think even with those savings we'll need to raise some additional funds, especially as I imagine we'll want to enter negotiations with the likes of Ashworth and Taylor on extensions.

For me, Ashworth will be pushing Townsend next season, he's playing well at Burton, and Taylor is showing at Cheltenham he's got bags of ability. 

In the summer, we really need to find a way to get Button, Ajayi, Reach and Kelly off the wage bill. They are earning big wages relative to what they're offering, and even if it means letting them all go on frees, we need to prioritise shifting them. You'd think they'd all be able to get a nice career ending move to the MLS or A-League at the very least. 

I expect we'll see 3-4 come in - but these will be lower wages, Assante types and younger PL loanees. We need to get back to doing what we've done best years ago, finding players in markets other teams aren't scouting, taking chances on players in their early 20s doing well in Leagues One and Two, and finding talent looking for an opportunity in PL academies.


RE: Championship - BaggieBaggieBromBrom - 03-20-2023

(03-20-2023, 09:49 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Presuming we don't go up it really is a case of as Anelka said, of evolution over revolution.

Given a full-season we would certainly have been top 3 or 4 with this squad under CC. The fringe players now will go and I expect to see those 4-5 replaced with likewise and maybe a couple of youngsters finding their way through.

I certainly wouldn't write Grady off yet either, but if we do get good money for him wouldn't be averse to seeing him go.

Grady is a busted flush . For everyone’s sake he needs a new club


RE: Championship - AnelkasBeard - 03-20-2023

(03-20-2023, 09:49 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Presuming we don't go up it really is a case of as Anelka said, of evolution over revolution.

Given a full-season we would certainly have been top 3 or 4 with this squad under CC. The fringe players now will go and I expect to see those 4-5 replaced with likewise and maybe a couple of youngsters finding their way through.

I certainly wouldn't write Grady off yet either, but if we do get good money for him wouldn't be averse to seeing him go.

An excellent way of putting what I was trying to say. We need to augment the squad, rather than have wholesale changes. If we somehow miraculously get promoted, all bets are off though.