WBAUnofficial
The Better Alternative in 2019 - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Better Alternative in 2019 (/showthread.php?tid=25944)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Derek Hardballs - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters

That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Protheroe - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 11:52 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Most polling suggests that 70% of Labour voters, voted remain.

Hence the term solidly remain.

Clearly voters in cities were more likely to vote remain than voters in urban towns such as Dudley.

But even in places like Dudley there wasn't unanimous support for brexit, there were remain voters too, many of whom would also vote Labour.

And again we get thus stereotypical view that all city dwellers are metropolitan elites, who spend their days drinking expensive coffee and reading the Guardian. It denies the reality that cities have substantial working class populations.

I think I was quite specific in referring to Moseley & Kings Heath - the bleeding heart of Birmingham.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Ted Maul - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters

That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Derek Hardballs - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters

That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

Yes they were conned. So whilst they stubbornly getting angry at Labour, liberal elites whoever they are  their lives aren’t improving, instead they are to a greater or lesser extent they are still believing Brexit lies and Tory divide and rule.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Fido - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters

That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

Yes they were conned. So whilst they stubbornly getting angry at Labour, liberal elites whoever they are  their lives aren’t improving, instead they are to a greater or lesser extent they are still believing Brexit lies and Tory divide and rule.

Do you ever think "What am I adding to this conversation?" before you start typing? 

I know the answer, of course, but you've followed up a perfectly valid post with a standard Derek caterwaul.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Ted Maul - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters

That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

Yes they were conned. So whilst they stubbornly getting angry at Labour, liberal elites whoever they are  their lives aren’t improving, instead they are to a greater or lesser extent they are still believing Brexit lies and Tory divide and rule.

It's not surprising is it? Telling people they're stupid is not the way to bring them around to a new way of thinking. The vast majority of the votes and seats the Labour party lost in 2019, paving the way for Johnson and his cronies were leave areas that were deserted the second Labour reneged on their 2017 pledge to honour the result of the referendum.

I live in one these such areas and I am angry with the Labour party over it. To the point where I've given up my membership, I despair at the direction the party is going. We're facing many more years of #LeastWorst and absolutely nothing will be done to improve the lives of people that need it most. They're just collateral in the ongoing argument between the ardent Brexiteers and fundamental Remainers who can't cope with something interfering in their nice middle class bubble.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Derek Hardballs - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:20 PM)Fido Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote: That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

Yes they were conned. So whilst they stubbornly getting angry at Labour, liberal elites whoever they are  their lives aren’t improving, instead they are to a greater or lesser extent they are still believing Brexit lies and Tory divide and rule.

Do you ever think "What am I adding to this conversation?" before you start typing? 

I know the answer, of course, but you've followed up a perfectly valid post with a standard Derek caterwaul.

Do you ever post anything of interest in response or just to have a pop at me? 

Perfectly reasonable to point out that those Red Wall areas were made to believe it was the fault of the EU and foreigners for the state of their towns and cities when it was underinvestment from U.K. government, notably during austerity. So why isn’t it pertinent or adding to the conversation to ask what positive change has happened since we left the EU that couldn’t have happened if we had stayed within it? Could we not have invested in those towns and cities? Have we got more money to invest in those towns and cities since we left the EU? Have we got better public services? Have we got better standards of living? 13 years we have had a Conservative government and they have blamed numerous people, establishments and services for their failures and yet you get upset with a random poster on a football message board for pointing it out.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Protheroe - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

How were people with "shit lives" told their lives would be better exactly? I'm curious because I campaigned and voted to leave an undemocratic and sclerotic political bloc.

As it is, the vast majority of us will notice no difference in or out of the the EU, and the effects of real issues like Covid, Covid Recovery, Ukraine and Chinese sabre rattling show Brexit up, comparatively, for what it actually is - Barely discernable minor disruption which will lessen over time.

I agree with the rest of your post btw.

(08-05-2022, 01:20 PM)Fido Wrote: Do you ever think "What am I adding to this conversation?" before you start typing? 

I know the answer, of course, but you've followed up a perfectly valid post with a standard Derek caterwaul.

Given that he usually hasn't even read the previous post, you know your answer.


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Derek Hardballs - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 01:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2022, 10:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote: That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.

What have they got for believing the Brexit bullshit?

Here’s Sunak levelling up in Royal Tumbridge Wells 

"We inherited a formula from the Labour party, which shoveled money to deprived urban areas and that needed to be undone - I started the work of doing that"

Rishi Sunak speaking to Tunbridge Wells Conservatives.

People in places like Dudley etc were told their shit lives (no fault of the EU) would be made better if we voted to leave the EU. Not much blame should lie with those who voted for it for me. A good chunk of those who voted remain then spent a couple of years telling those who voted for Brexit that they were stupid and trying to reverse their decision. It's not hard to see why those who voted for Brexit, for whatever reason were keen to see it done. The Labour party only have themselves to blame for abandoning it's traditional voter base in 'Red Wall', predominantly Brexit voting areas. 

I say all this as a former Labour party member who voted to remain in the EU.

Yes they were conned. So whilst they stubbornly getting angry at Labour, liberal elites whoever they are  their lives aren’t improving, instead they are to a greater or lesser extent they are still believing Brexit lies and Tory divide and rule.

It's not surprising is it? Telling people they're stupid is not the way to bring them around to a new way of thinking. The vast majority of the votes and seats the Labour party lost in 2019, paving the way for Johnson and his cronies were leave areas that were deserted the second Labour reneged on their 2017 pledge to honour the result of the referendum.

I live in one these such areas and I am angry with the Labour party over it. To the point where I've given up my membership, I despair at the direction the party is going. We're facing many more years of #LeastWorst and absolutely nothing will be done to improve the lives of people that need it most. They're just collateral in the ongoing argument between the ardent Brexiteers and fundamental Remainers who can't cope with something interfering in their nice middle class bubble.

Some big assumptions being made here. I know plenty of people who live in Red Wall areas who are working class and voted remain and they are pissed off that their opinions have been completely marginalised because they are in the minority. What olive branch has been given to those who wanted to stay in the EU? What conciliatory language has been used? Their incomes have stagnated or gone backwards every bit as much as those who voted to leave. The reason Brexit is still an issue is because it doesn’t work, it was and is akin to inflicting economic and social sanctions on ourselves. If people can’t be honest about this, then we will never be able to address it. We now have people trying to argue that Brexit wasn’t done properly and if it was, we would be fine but the whole problem with that is no one agrees what better means. If you’re going to argue this Conservative party is least worse for Red Wall voters I complete disagree and wonder what possible rationale there is for that opinion given the mountain of evidence to the contrary of the past 13yrs.

Protheroe


RE: The Better Alternative in 2019 - Ossian - 08-05-2022

(08-05-2022, 01:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: It's not surprising is it? Telling people they're stupid is not the way to bring them around to a new way of thinking. The vast majority of the votes and seats the Labour party lost in 2019, paving the way for Johnson and his cronies were leave areas that were deserted the second Labour reneged on their 2017 pledge to honour the result of the referendum.

I live in one these such areas and I am angry with the Labour party over it. To the point where I've given up my membership, I despair at the direction the party is going. We're facing many more years of #LeastWorst and absolutely nothing will be done to improve the lives of people that need it most. They're just collateral in the ongoing argument between the ardent Brexiteers and fundamental Remainers who can't cope with something interfering in their nice middle class bubble.

I see today that Starmer has been found in default of a number of - minor admittedly - breaches of the ministerial code of conduct. I find this surprising for someone who seems both meticulously pedantic and simultaneously afraid of his own shadow. Neither of which would be the worst characteristics of someone in high office, by the way - not by some distance.

He does need to start energising both himself and the Labour Party soon though; the goal won't remain this open forever.