WBAUnofficial
An Outsider's View - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: An Outsider's View (/showthread.php?tid=12731)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: An Outsider's View - Dreamkiller - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 03:42 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: It is. Come back DK!!

God help him if he starts a Christmas cake thread.


RE: An Outsider's View - Psalm23 - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 04:03 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 03:42 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: It is. Come back DK!!

God help him if he starts a Christmas cake thread.


God help him if he mentions 1982. FFS   Big Grin


RE: An Outsider's View - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?

I'm just still astounded that one of them actually tried to make sense/logic, and/or didn't work in 1982 somewhere. Incredible.


RE: An Outsider's View - baggie_ray - 09-20-2020

Begley Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
I liked Sam when he was at Villa and I was majorly pissed off we could not afford to keep him and even more pissed off when you guys took him. I felt he was our keeper (although a Man U GK) and we needed him and he was suddenly a Baggie. He is not a spectacular GK but I do think he is competent. Like most GKs he needs a decent 4 in front of him and he just doesn't have that now so it is very easy to jump on his back and blame him. A defense needs a leader who will marshal the back 4 and constantly tell them where they should be. In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4. The next season when we lost his influence during a game we fell apart and Mings did not step up. So we had poor and inexperienced defenders who did not know what to do.

Johnstone organised his defenders you say...?  Dodgy


RE: An Outsider's View - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 07:14 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
Begley Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
I liked Sam when he was at Villa and I was majorly pissed off we could not afford to keep him and even more pissed off when you guys took him. I felt he was our keeper (although a Man U GK) and we needed him and he was suddenly a Baggie. He is not a spectacular GK but I do think he is competent. Like most GKs he needs a decent 4 in front of him and he just doesn't have that now so it is very easy to jump on his back and blame him. A defense needs a leader who will marshal the back 4 and constantly tell them where they should be. In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4. The next season when we lost his influence during a game we fell apart and Mings did not step up. So we had poor and inexperienced defenders who did not know what to do.

Johnstone organised his defenders you say...?  Dodgy

Little logic test for you:

"Johnstone organised his defenders", said the knowledgeable Villa fan. 

Which of the two arguments in this sentence is false, and which is also false?


RE: An Outsider's View - albion_pigeon - 09-20-2020

Two words Begley

Hawk eye

Or should it be; Sheffield United

Fuck me, we were in the prem a couple of seasons ago for 8 straight years, we know what it takes. Cheers for the advice though old tata!


RE: An Outsider's View - Begley - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 07:14 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
Begley Wrote:
Super_Slav Wrote:FAO Begley.

Great post.

Quick question - as an outsider looking in what are your thoughts on Sam Johnstone? I really hope Ivanovic is the Terry moment he had at Villa, as I recall he struggled initially but became a fans favourite in your run to the final when you lost to Fulham.

Are we overly critical as we compare him to Foster?

Intrigued to know.
I liked Sam when he was at Villa and I was majorly pissed off we could not afford to keep him and even more pissed off when you guys took him. I felt he was our keeper (although a Man U GK) and we needed him and he was suddenly a Baggie. He is not a spectacular GK but I do think he is competent. Like most GKs he needs a decent 4 in front of him and he just doesn't have that now so it is very easy to jump on his back and blame him. A defense needs a leader who will marshal the back 4 and constantly tell them where they should be. In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4. The next season when we lost his influence during a game we fell apart and Mings did not step up. So we had poor and inexperienced defenders who did not know what to do.

Johnstone organised his defenders you say...?  Dodgy
In our year before promotion when JT was in the back 4 he was brilliant and he covered up a lot of the cracks in the defense as he managed the back 4.

I think that says JT managed our defense. Dodgy

(09-20-2020, 07:37 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Two words Begley

Hawk eye

Or should it be; Sheffield United

Fuck me, we were in the prem a couple of seasons ago for 8 straight years, we know what it takes. Cheers for the advice though old tata!
Yes the goal should have been allowed, just like Hand of Rod should have been disallowed, what point are you making? Are you suggesting that was the only decision that impacted Villa last season? What about the Palace goal?

And yes I am well aware that you spent 8 years in the PL, again what point are you making? Is it simply that if you are not a Baggies supporter that you can't comment?


RE: An Outsider's View - yeoman lai - 09-20-2020

OP FODTV

Patronising Twat.


RE: An Outsider's View - HawkingsHalfpint - 09-20-2020

I think it was the veteran tone used, rather than not being a Baggies fan; particularly after the odd and rather wonky standpoint of what follows your first relegation from the modern top flight. It was as if you know more about the subject of new survival, having only survived a newly-promoted season one year yourselves (by the skin of your fucking teeth I may add).

You can't really speak from the standpoint of the old Villa. That era doesn't exist any more, beyond the remerging gulf between not just EPL and the rest, but EPL/parachute and the rest; which given how debt-laden you still are (and with a much bigger commitment in a sell-on market that will feel the COVID pinch) currently gives you no grounds for claim to superiority, any more than it does Brighton and Hove Albion over you. It is almost as if we are heading for EPL1 and 2 anyway, so who cares.


RE: An Outsider's View - Spandaubaggie - 09-20-2020

(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?

No it’s not just you. It’s Baggie Nick too, possibly the most infamous poster on here.
For what it’s worth, I like to hear balanced views from other clubs fans, even Villas.
I miss the rivals days when other fans could say their bit. All clubs have good and bad fans, and Begley comes here in peace.