WBAUnofficial
Adil Rashid - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Adil Rashid (/showthread.php?tid=22795)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: Adil Rashid - rsbaggy2 - 11-15-2021

(11-15-2021, 07:09 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 02:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 01:22 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Rafiq's ongoing silence to Gary Ballances statement needs addressing ASAP

You can't pick and choose the past, what was said and when it suits your timescales, the fact he's not responsed to a very open, frank and no doubt difficult statement is piss poor

As for Vaughan, always had an Ego the size of Yorkshire itself, " too many of you lot" I deemed from day one as referring to Asian cricketers, if he's deemed racist for that comment, he's nowhere to go

The fact Essex are now going back to 2001 to bring up comments, what next, the Jamaicans from the 60's moving over to London and being racially abused? You'll need to send 50,000 to jail for using terms which nowadays are found offesnive, too much of a "me too" movement going on for me, but that's just my take on it

Cuzer
Oh let's turn this onto the victims. So Cuzer.

I shouldn't have expected a logical response from you should I really?

Cuzer

(11-15-2021, 06:06 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.

Come on then mouth, back it up with facts, sorry FACTS?

Cuzer
From someone who regards pissing on team members as banter you can't demand anything with any credibility. 

And of course you resort to name calling .. again. You really do have a very high opinion of yourself. When asked for facts yourself you continually evade and talk crap. 

You are part of the problem and whilst there is your way of thinking by evasion and burying your head in  the sand these types of issues will remain. Its the way Cuzer says. Dare anyone say otherwise.


RE: Adil Rashid - Cheshire East Baggie - 11-15-2021

(11-15-2021, 07:14 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 06:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.

You may have a point, however, there is no way that England would ever not take Anderson and Broad.  I'm not at all sold on Overton. Wood is a liability in terms of being injury prone.

With the huge experience these two have and with so many bowlers injured, plus the fact that Wood, Stokes and Woakes have all had injury issues, Broad and Anderson definitely merit their places. But I do think they are both pretty much finished (especially Jimmy who hardly took a second innings wicket all summer long). They've never done well in Oz and I'm not expecting them to this winter. If the quick bowlers had been available, would both of the old fellows be on the plane as well? We'll never know.

I think Mahmood is the "next cab of the rank" as they say, I was surprised he wasn't taken to Oz, Overton has gone before and done little, it's classic Englad as he offers a bit with the bat so we'll take him, a proper 100% but until he bowls at high 80's and not low 80's he's going to find test cricket a challenge, especially on those Oz pitches

Mahmood was superb when England C team rolled Pakistan in the ODI series, problem is if you look at his 4 day form for Lancashire pre Ashes squad selection he really returned bang average figures and I'm sure this worked against him when they made the final decision

Cuzer

It's really difficult to get good at the long version of the game without playing the long version of the game. But lack of "red ball" experience is a very convenient excuse for making lazy selections in the Test side. For example, Sam Curran was bang average at best for England in 2021, his left arm medium pace is a useful variation but he lost the magic of previous years. It took a while for him to get dropped, what with him being an Old Wellingtonian and his late Dad being mates with Ed Smith. No need to take a risk with someone who hasn't played over a dozen Tests already.


RE: Adil Rashid - Cuzer - 11-15-2021

(11-15-2021, 07:37 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 07:09 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 02:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 01:22 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Rafiq's ongoing silence to Gary Ballances statement needs addressing ASAP

You can't pick and choose the past, what was said and when it suits your timescales, the fact he's not responsed to a very open, frank and no doubt difficult statement is piss poor

As for Vaughan, always had an Ego the size of Yorkshire itself, " too many of you lot" I deemed from day one as referring to Asian cricketers, if he's deemed racist for that comment, he's nowhere to go

The fact Essex are now going back to 2001 to bring up comments, what next, the Jamaicans from the 60's moving over to London and being racially abused? You'll need to send 50,000 to jail for using terms which nowadays are found offesnive, too much of a "me too" movement going on for me, but that's just my take on it

Cuzer
Oh let's turn this onto the victims. So Cuzer.

I shouldn't have expected a logical response from you should I really?

Cuzer

(11-15-2021, 06:06 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:21 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I'm not sure that racism is widespread in English cricket. Obviously, those affected will know more, and may provide anecdotal evidence to prove that it is unfortunately prevalent.  But England have selected a number of British Asain players, as well as black players, throughout the years, surely they wouldn't have been called up if the whole set up was institutionally racist. I know it's not as simple as that, but it's just a thought.

I think the issue is more at county level in academies. Do players from Asian background (who form a large part of the cricketing community in much of the country) get a fair crack at the opportunities, or do the counties still prefer to give contracts to Anglo-Saxon grammar school boys?

It's also a disappointment that Caribbean communities have fallen out of love with cricket, both in the West Indies and the UK. That's often attributed to the increase in popularity of American sports, and the relative accessibility of a lucrative career in basketball etc from the West indies.

Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.
Take it from me as FACT ... I know of at least several incidents relating to a much supported county on here where better, no significantly better, British Asian academy players were overlooked and released and drifted out of the county scene in favour of white British players.

Come on then mouth, back it up with facts, sorry FACTS?

Cuzer
From someone who regards pissing on team members as banter you can't demand anything with any credibility. 

And of course you resort to name calling .. again. You really do have a very high opinion of yourself. When asked for facts yourself you continually evade and talk crap. 

You are part of the problem and whilst there is your way of thinking by evasion and burying your head in  the sand these types of issues will remain. Its the way Cuzer says. Dare anyone say otherwise.

RS

This is a serious thread with a very serious subject matter so I will refrain from getting in a pathetic slanging match with you for the sake of others on this thread

Everything you’ve wrote above is fabrication, twisting my words to try and taint my comments to suit your argument. You’ve probably figured out by now I don’t have the biggest filter and tend to say it as I see it, never once did I ever say it’s acceptable to piss on team members I was clearly commenting on some things I’ve seen with my own eyes in the team changing room environment over the years…..but you know that…you just chose to ignore it to suit your argument

Very poor but predictable old bean, now let’s leave it to the others and drop your agenda

Cuzer

(11-15-2021, 08:45 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 07:14 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 06:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 05:30 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Having thought about it, I'll add to this. I do think Asian players have to do more to get selected for England. Saqib Mahmood was on fire for England's scratch ODI side in the summer. He made it into a Test squad, never played and is not in the Ashes squad. Does anyone think the elderly Anderson and Broad and the pedestrian Overton will cause the Aussies the slightest bother? Are they really going to replace the injured Archer and Stone effectively? If Mahmood had been white British or maybe South African/Zimbabwean etc, he'd be in the squad IMO.

You may have a point, however, there is no way that England would ever not take Anderson and Broad.  I'm not at all sold on Overton. Wood is a liability in terms of being injury prone.

With the huge experience these two have and with so many bowlers injured, plus the fact that Wood, Stokes and Woakes have all had injury issues, Broad and Anderson definitely merit their places. But I do think they are both pretty much finished (especially Jimmy who hardly took a second innings wicket all summer long). They've never done well in Oz and I'm not expecting them to this winter. If the quick bowlers had been available, would both of the old fellows be on the plane as well? We'll never know.

I think Mahmood is the "next cab of the rank" as they say, I was surprised he wasn't taken to Oz, Overton has gone before and done little, it's classic Englad as he offers a bit with the bat so we'll take him, a proper 100% but until he bowls at high 80's and not low 80's he's going to find test cricket a challenge, especially on those Oz pitches

Mahmood was superb when England C team rolled Pakistan in the ODI series, problem is if you look at his 4 day form for Lancashire pre Ashes squad selection he really returned bang average figures and I'm sure this worked against him when they made the final decision

Cuzer

It's really difficult to get good at the long version of the game without playing the long version of the game. But lack of "red ball" experience is a very convenient excuse for making lazy selections in the Test side. For example, Sam Curran was bang average at best for England in 2021, his left arm medium pace is a useful variation but he lost the magic of previous years. It took a while for him to get dropped, what with him being an Old Wellingtonian and his late Dad being mates with Ed Smith. No need to take a risk with someone who hasn't played over a dozen Tests already.

Agreed…..but he bats a bit, scores you a few points with Silverwood that

I like Curran but realistically he’s only ever going to be good enough at home in conditions where the ball swings, talking him to Oz would have been a disaster…..but we would have

Mahmood is with the Lions I believe and they play the Test side in two warm up games so hopefully he can make a case

Cuzer


RE: Adil Rashid - KratosBaggie - 11-16-2021

Allegations relating to Essex have now been made. Zoheb Sharif allegedly suffered racial abuse between 2001-2003.

Maurice Chambers alleges abuse over a ten year period. 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/59295933

I think it's important individuals are made to feel like they can speak out, make allegations, and that said allegations are taken seriously. However, I'm not sure how comfortable I am about making allegations about incidents that happened two decades ago. How do you prove guilt or innocence?

It's a very difficult subject, but i do feel a line has to be drawn somewhere, otherwise where do you stop? Do we punish Counties for actions by their staff or members from 40, 50 or even 100 years ago? I'm not sure where the line should be drawn, and it's not an easy decision. 

With that being said, this a worrying development, and is perhaps far more prevalent than I first expected (Ignorance on my part).

Less importantly, it's typical English cricket is facing a crisis, right before an Ashes series down under, while the Aussies have just won a World Cup.


RE: Adil Rashid - rsbaggy2 - 11-16-2021

Oh lord its hard to be humble ...
If you're Cuzer in every way

I will let the committee meeting today bring matters forward. If you are vindicated Cuzer I will acknowledge that here. I don't hold my breath that you will be so forthcoming, though you may yet surprise me!

(11-16-2021, 12:23 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Allegations relating to Essex have now been made. Zoheb Sharif allegedly suffered racial abuse between 2001-2003.

Maurice Chambers alleges abuse over a ten year period. 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/59295933

I think it's important individuals are made to feel like they can speak out, make allegations, and that said allegations are taken seriously. However, I'm not sure how comfortable I am about making allegations about incidents that happened two decades ago. How do you prove guilt or innocence?

It's a very difficult subject, but i do feel a line has to be drawn somewhere, otherwise where do you stop? Do we punish Counties for actions by their staff or members from 40, 50 or even 100 years ago? I'm not sure where the line should be drawn, and it's not an easy decision. 

With that being said, this a worrying development, and is perhaps far more prevalent than I first expected (Ignorance on my part).

Less importantly, it's typical English cricket is facing a crisis, right before an Ashes series down under, while the Aussies have just won a World Cup.

Agree that historical accusations are harder to prove so all we have are the words of others who were around at the time to form any judgement. But we have held to account many ''celebrities'' recently for allegations made several decades ago.


RE: Adil Rashid - CA Baggie - 11-16-2021

I’m not sure saying “I was racially abused 20 years ago” holds much merit these days. We know things were more racist yesteryear, I’d suggest 20 years ago was a damn sight better than 40 years ago. That doesn’t excuse it but it shows that education is working, maybe not at the pace that everyone would like but it’s getting better.

Rather than outing someone for views they expressed 20 years ago with today’s more accepting views I think we’d be much better served by looking at the here and now. What is it like today for non-white cricketing kids in academies, then also look at what it is like for state school kids in general within the ECB.

The Good Friday Peace Agreement managed to ignore bombers and murderers on both sides to forge a peaceful future, let’s apply the same thing to racial remarks and prejudices from the past and make sure we have equal opportunities right now for all youngsters.

RS - if you have known factual allegations raise them. I always struggle with the idea that any academy would release better players based on the colour of someone’s skin. The same with football, I don’t think there are many Albion fans who give 2 fucks about where our players come from, skin colour, religion, sexuality or even if they’re human! If they put the ball in the net they’ll get cheered. If there’s a young Asian cricketer for Warwickshire taking loads of wickets or scoring big runs they wouldn’t get chopped for someone not doing it. If 2 are on a par and they can only take one…


RE: Adil Rashid - KratosBaggie - 11-16-2021

(11-16-2021, 08:38 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Oh lord its hard to be humble ...
If you're Cuzer in every way

I will let the committee meeting today bring matters forward. If you are vindicated Cuzer I will acknowledge that here. I don't hold my breath that you will be so forthcoming, though you may yet surprise me!

(11-16-2021, 12:23 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Allegations relating to Essex have now been made. Zoheb Sharif allegedly suffered racial abuse between 2001-2003.

Maurice Chambers alleges abuse over a ten year period. 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/59295933

I think it's important individuals are made to feel like they can speak out, make allegations, and that said allegations are taken seriously. However, I'm not sure how comfortable I am about making allegations about incidents that happened two decades ago. How do you prove guilt or innocence?

It's a very difficult subject, but i do feel a line has to be drawn somewhere, otherwise where do you stop? Do we punish Counties for actions by their staff or members from 40, 50 or even 100 years ago? I'm not sure where the line should be drawn, and it's not an easy decision. 

With that being said, this a worrying development, and is perhaps far more prevalent than I first expected (Ignorance on my part).

Less importantly, it's typical English cricket is facing a crisis, right before an Ashes series down under, while the Aussies have just won a World Cup.

Agree that historical accusations are harder to prove so all we have are the words of others who were around at the time to form any judgement. But we have held to account many ''celebrities'' recently for allegations made several decades ago.

Exactly. It's such a tough situation.  On one hand you must eradicate any form of abuse, and part of that is making it easy for those affected to whistle blow and come forward, and take any allegations seriously. 

But on the other, how can the above be done on historical matters that span decades, where those involved may not even remember the incident, or sadly no longer with us? 

It's an issue, and it's a damn tough thing to get around. One thing that is clear is that those who have been abused don't feel like they can come forward. That must change. Once that changes, you can then weed out the racists, and put measures in place to prevent such abuse. But that's difficult until people come forward. 

I almost feel like historical abuse, while serious, is kind of irrelevant (for want of a better word) to the issue at hand, in terms of making society a better place. I don't see what punishing clubs or individuals for actions decades ago (which, rightly or wrongly, may have been deemed OK at that time period) achieves. Surely consigning that to history, and treating allegations that happen in a shorter time span, where there's more evidence (social media, texts, group chats etc) is more appropriate.


RE: Adil Rashid - rsbaggy2 - 11-16-2021

(11-16-2021, 09:06 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m not sure saying “I was racially abused 20 years ago” holds much merit these days.  We know things were more racist yesteryear, I’d suggest 20 years ago was a damn sight better than 40 years ago.  That doesn’t excuse it but it shows that education is working, maybe not at the pace that everyone would like but it’s getting better.

Rather than outing someone for views they expressed 20 years ago with today’s more accepting views I think we’d be much better served by looking at the here and now.  What is it like today for non-white cricketing kids in academies, then also look at what it is like for state school kids in general within the ECB.

The Good Friday Peace Agreement managed to ignore bombers and murderers on both sides to forge a peaceful future, let’s apply the same thing to racial remarks and prejudices from the past and make sure we have equal opportunities right now for all youngsters.

RS - if you have known factual allegations raise them.  I always struggle with the idea that any academy would release better players based on the colour of someone’s skin.  The same with football, I don’t think there are many Albion fans who give 2 fucks about where our players come from, skin colour, religion, sexuality or even if they’re human! If they put the ball in the net they’ll get cheered.  If there’s a young Asian cricketer for Warwickshire taking loads of wickets or scoring big runs they wouldn’t get chopped for someone not doing it.  If 2 are on a par and they can only take one…

CA I refrain from naming anyone as it is not my right to put their name in the public domain. In one instance however I will say that someone very close to me was directly involved. I agree Albion fans, on the whole, would not care of the background of any of our pool of players. I have my doubts that the decision makers in some cricket institutions are equally unbiased. 

I agree that we should look to right any wrongs within the system NOW as we cannot change what has gone before. However, that should not mean that we bury the past and not bring to book those that can be PROVEN to have acted in a discriminatory manner.

Radio 5 Live ...Rafeeq's submissions ...very emotional

Red wine poured down his throat ... as a muslim FFS

Moxon tearing him a new one the day he returned after his son was still born

Is that corner shop owned by your family!!

Bullying by Bresnan

Yes they are his words but I await the rebuttals ... Moxon has gone into hiding claiming STRESS. You cheeky fuck!!


RE: Adil Rashid - sideboardbilly - 11-16-2021

Quite emotional watching this.

It was obviously widespread at Yorkshire at all levels.


RE: Adil Rashid - Jacobthebaggie - 11-16-2021

Crickets Saville moment. Even Georgie Whitebread new it was going on in the 90's and he said what he liked and liked what he bloody well said.