WBAUnofficial
Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? (/showthread.php?tid=10110)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - Protheroe - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 02:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It doesn't matter about what the rulings are in this, people simply wouldn't be going into bars, restaurants and clubs at the moment (well not enough to sustain the business) anyway. As for other businesses, construction is still allowed, manufacturing will be back soon and quite a number of different shops have started opening again. I would imagine the next step will to allow shopping malls to open with guidelines in place as to what to do to protect, but again there will be limited customers and probably not enough to sustain business.

A lot of businesses have continued with working from home, so what businesses are you referring to? There is movement in the direction of getting back to work so it hasn't been a total shutdown, and the 6 week hit (so far) has been mitigated with furlough and other government schemes.

It could be argued that the number of people hit financially (and terminally at that) will be far less than the number that would have died if we'd continued along the line of free trade to all.

Construction isn't back yet. I have a supply of hard hats with faceguards to hand over to a contractor tomorrow who won't start until Monday. Given that construction in the UK pretty much runs at full capacity at all times I doubt you'll have more than half of the sites open - and then with far fewer contractors on site.

I don't think enough attention has been paid to fixed non-salary overheads which are already killing retailers. The death of retail in the UK has been brought forward by a decade, so I'd expect huge job losses in that sector. BA has announced today that it might not resume operations from Gatwick. Universities will have a long term income hit as travel costs and health worries hit foreign student numbers. One of the country's two office supplies wholesalers has gone into administration with no buyer looking likely. The hospitaility sector is facing total wipeout. Corporate landlords have already foregone a quarters rent in March and are facing the same in June.

This isn't remotely comparable with 2008.


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - The liquidator - 04-30-2020

I've seen the link but it has been misquoted to be honest it says we are prepared to open up in june BUT we are following government guidelines so if not we will be closed .


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - baggy1 - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 02:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 02:16 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It doesn't matter about what the rulings are in this, people simply wouldn't be going into bars, restaurants and clubs at the moment (well not enough to sustain the business) anyway. As for other businesses, construction is still allowed, manufacturing will be back soon and quite a number of different shops have started opening again. I would imagine the next step will to allow shopping malls to open with guidelines in place as to what to do to protect, but again there will be limited customers and probably not enough to sustain business.

A lot of businesses have continued with working from home, so what businesses are you referring to? There is movement in the direction of getting back to work so it hasn't been a total shutdown, and the 6 week hit (so far) has been mitigated with furlough and other government schemes.

It could be argued that the number of people hit financially (and terminally at that) will be far less than the number that would have died if we'd continued along the line of free trade to all.

Construction isn't back yet. I have a supply of hard hats with faceguards to hand over to a contractor tomorrow who won't start until Monday. Given that construction in the UK pretty much runs at full capacity at all times I doubt you'll have more than half of the sites open - and then with far fewer contractors on site.

I don't think enough attention has been paid to fixed non-salary overheads which are already killing retailers. The death of retail in the UK has been brought forward by a decade, so I'd expect huge job losses in that sector. BA has announced today that it might not resume operations from Gatwick. Universities will have a long term income hit as travel costs and health worries hit foreign student numbers. One of the country's two office supplies wholesalers has gone into administration with no buyer looking likely. The hospitaility sector is facing total wipeout. Corporate landlords has already foregone a quarters rent in March and are facing the same in June.

This isn't remotely comparable with 2008.

Construction isn't back that is correct, but that is not driven by the government, that is individual company choices. The BoE were keen to point out (3 times) in last weeks business call that they should be back. 

I agree on the retail side but that has been on the cards for years and the government has done next to nothing to protect them, and this will bring forward a new way of working for both landlords and tenants so this has driven change rather than destroying, people will still shop and congregate in bars and cafes when this is over.

Again I agree on travel but it will come back in a better form, and again this may force the industry to look at the other side issues of pollution and product on sale / customer service. People will still ravel when this is over, 2020 will mean that the names on the planes will change.

Universities are already looking at online programmes and developing their offerings along those lines, I have a very good friend that is involved in the student recruitment from China and has been flat out redesigning their offerings (again moving things forward at a quicker rate).

Corporate landlords are fucked.

And you brought up 2008 as an example, not me.

All I see there is innovation moving quicker than it would have and the old school having to hand over the reigns or, god forbid, share the wealth.

(04-30-2020, 02:42 PM)The liquidator Wrote: I've seen the link but it has been misquoted to be honest it says we are prepared to open up in june BUT  we are following government guidelines so if not we will be closed .

Fair do's Liq, I hadn't read the article but the government will have to make some decisions about furlough and they may say certain businesses can open so that they don't qualify for the payments. I personally don't see pubs reopening until the end of the year.


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - TETLEY74 - 04-30-2020

I'll just throw this question out there, how many deaths are "acceptable" in order to protect jobs and the economy?


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - Shabby Russian - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 11:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:10 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Stop revolving your life around opportunity costs for people's livelihoods FFS, there's no point running a business if all of the customers have died.

But that's the point isn't it? In the greater scheme of things very few people are going to die. Whereas hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of livelihoods are going to be ruined.

I'm fortunate that I've put enough away for a rainy day, which has finally arrived. The vast majority of people in this country live from paycheck  to paycheck and don't have that luxury - just as they didn't in 2008.

Well there's 2 way of looking at this.

In the long term we are all going to die, In the short term if unchecked covid 19 has the potential to take 200 -400 k uk citizens, that's not an insubstantial amount.


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - Shabby Russian - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 03:22 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: I'll just throw this question out there, how many deaths are "acceptable" in order to protect jobs and the economy?

It's a good question.

I'll throw another one out there, does your answer change given the knowledge that it will be the most vulnerable (and dare I say the least economically productive) that are the ones most likely to die.


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - baggy1 - 04-30-2020

And that's the point Shabbs, the answer is none from my point of view. If we have to learn new ways of working and live with a short term fix of say 18 months, to do as much as we can, then that's what we do. The businesses will recover in some form - we have 80 years on this planet on average, if I have to sacrifice less than 2% of that time with less freedom or rights to literally save lives then I'm ok with that.


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - TETLEY74 - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 03:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And that's the point Shabbs, the answer is none from my point of view. If we have to learn new ways of working and live with a short term fix of say 18 months, to do as much as we can, then that's what we do. The businesses will recover in some form - we have 80 years on this planet on average, if I have to sacrifice less than 2% of that time with less freedom or rights to literally save lives then I'm ok with that.

Pretty much my own thoughts, what's the point of a strong economy if half of those that work in it have died or are dying or are unable to work again, the economy will recover at some point it always does I've yet to find someone who has recovered from death!


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - billybassett - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 11:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:10 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Stop revolving your life around opportunity costs for people's livelihoods FFS, there's no point running a business if all of the customers have died.

But that's the point isn't it? In the greater scheme of things very few people are going to die. Whereas hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of livelihoods are going to be ruined.

I'm fortunate that I've put enough away for a rainy day, which has finally arrived. The vast majority of people in this country live from paycheck  to paycheck and don't have that luxury - just as they didn't in 2008.

Well there's 2 way of looking at this.

In the long term we are all going to die, In the short term if unchecked covid 19 has the potential to take 200 -400 k uk citizens, that's not an insubstantial amount.

Another made up death number. I'll make one up as well. If we don't start getting back to something like normal soon then the indirect deaths of covid over the next 10 years, due to a multitude of factors such s quiet health, mental health, poverty, blah blah will be circa 200,000


RE: Is Lockdown Counter Productive? - Derek Hardballs - 04-30-2020

(04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.

Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism. 

A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery. 

The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example? 

What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?