WBAUnofficial
Playing out from the back - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Playing out from the back (/showthread.php?tid=8301)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Playing out from the back - SW4Baggie - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 03:48 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: it's not a straight binary between POFTB or Pulisball though is it?  I don't think we do either at the minute and IMO Johnstone will pick whichever seems the best option for distribution at the time, whether that be rolling it to a CB, pinging it to a winger, punting it long etc etc.

As has been alluded to, fashions come and go in football and currently making your keeper roll it to your CB seems to be it. I'm glad that we don't do it (always...) any more though.

Playing it out from the back should be used when teams have sat back and there is little threat to making the pass. When players are clearly closing the CBs down you go longer into the space they’ve vacated.

In Johnstone we have a keeper who can distribute well, he can also throw a long distance. We should be varying this distribution a lot more than we do.

With the lack of pace we have up top we rarely have the option to go long over the top, hence the push towards playing out from the back. If we can get that ounce of pace to sit on the shoulder of the last man, we will have more options IMO.


RE: Playing out from the back - Derek Hardballs - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 03:48 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: it's not a straight binary between POFTB or Pulisball though is it?  I don't think we do either at the minute and IMO Johnstone will pick whichever seems the best option for distribution at the time, whether that be rolling it to a CB, pinging it to a winger, punting it long etc etc.

As has been alluded to, fashions come and go in football and currently making your keeper roll it to your CB seems to be it. I'm glad that we don't do it (always...) any more though.

Exactly why is it if there is any criticism of playing out from the back, you’re suggesting playing aggressive long / direct football instead? It’s as if teams didn’t play good football until this obessesion with playing out from the back to the point of over playing.


RE: Playing out from the back - Baggie Rick - 01-12-2020

Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.


RE: Playing out from the back - ChamonixBaggie - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 03:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Playing it out from the back should be used when teams have sat back and there is little threat to making the pass. When players are clearly closing the CBs down you go longer into the space they’ve vacated.

In Johnstone we have a keeper who can distribute well, he can also throw a long distance. We should be varying this distribution a lot more than we do.

With the lack of pace we have up top we rarely have the option to go long over the top, hence the push towards playing out from the back. If we can get that ounce of pace to sit on the shoulder of the last man, we will have more options IMO.

Agreed, except that I think that SJs distribution is reasonably varied as it is.  I definitely agree that a pacy striker sitting on the shoulder of the last man would give another option and possibly prevent sides committing players forward into the high press.

FWIW my favourite type of football to watch is Ferguson-era United. We've got the ball, we want it in their goal. Let's do that as quickly and efficient as possible, fast and direct. Need quick and intelligent runners for that though.


RE: Playing out from the back - Birdman1811 - 01-12-2020

There is a balance, it's not a binary system.

When applicable play out, when applicable, get it into the channels.

Both have strengths and weaknesses, but both can be used by the same team throughout a game.


RE: Playing out from the back - Fido - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 04:16 PM)Baggie Rick Wrote: Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Have to say I don’t agree with this. In my lad’s U12 team the options are as follows:

1) Hoof the ball out from a goal kick that invariably won’t get to the halfway line. Defenders have time with the ball in the air to close down a player who is then trying to receive a ball at head or chest height and flick on or bring down and then play in most cases backwards to a defender.
2) The godsend of the rule that allows the ball to be played to a defender inside the area means they have a bit of time to work the ball wide or to a midfielder in space who is receiving the ball to feet and is the more at ease to control and do something with it.

They’re kids so either of the above can go very right or very wrong but in terms of playing football my preference is for 2) more often that not. There’s always a risk of something going wrong but if you accept that and make the players understand it too it leads to a better mentality than lumping in to the big/fast kid up front.


RE: Playing out from the back - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-12-2020

I understand the principle that you have possession while the goalie holds the ball and risk losing it when he hoofs it. But there needs to be variety in the play, otherwise the opposition just close everyone down and stupid errors result.


RE: Playing out from the back - Bloke who lives abroad - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 03:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Two problems with the fad of playing it out from the back.

1 any team with a competent manager but limited squad simply ignores ours and other teams desperate attempts to cajole them into over committing or losing shape.

2 you need good players to do it properly or you get caught out time after time which we do less this year but still do and it’s nit a tactic for a solid defence at Championship level imo.

Exactly.

It's a fad. Other teams see through it. So it doesn't work. And, too often, it leads to conceding a goal or, at least, possession in a dangerous place.

Just like VAR; a half-decent idea, but totally unnecessary and (mostly) badly executed.


RE: Playing out from the back - Baggie Rick - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 04:48 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 04:16 PM)Baggie Rick Wrote: Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Have to say I don’t agree with this. In my lad’s U12 team the options are as follows:

1) Hoof the ball out from a goal kick that invariably won’t get to the halfway line. Defenders have time with the ball in the air to close down a player who is then trying to receive a ball at head or chest height and flick on or bring down and then play in most cases backwards to a defender.
2) The godsend of the rule that allows the ball to be played to a defender inside the area means they have a bit of time to work the ball wide or to a midfielder in space who is receiving the ball to feet and is the more at ease to control and do something with it.

They’re kids so either of the above can go very right or very wrong but in terms of playing football my preference is for 2) more often that not. There’s always a risk of something going wrong but if you accept that and make the players understand it too it leads to a better mentality than lumping in to the big/fast kid up front.

Perhaps your lad plays at a higher level than my daughter, although on Sundays they are in the top tier for under 12s. But I can assure you, we’ve played against teams and won simply because they insist on playing it out from the back when they aren’t good enough to use the ball, so they end up losing it and we’ve scored. As birdman said, there are more than 1 option, we tend to vary it, also helps
our keeper is better with his feet than most of the leagues outfield players.


RE: Playing out from the back - Fido - 01-12-2020

(01-12-2020, 05:57 PM)Baggie Rick Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 04:48 PM)Fido Wrote:
(01-12-2020, 04:16 PM)Baggie Rick Wrote: Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Coaching my Daughter who plays for an all girls team on a Saturday and a mixed team on a Sunday, you may be surprised how many kids teams try to play in out from the back. It causes fucking havoc, and ruins kids confidence, but the Peps and Klopps of kids football continue with it.

Have to say I don’t agree with this. In my lad’s U12 team the options are as follows:

1) Hoof the ball out from a goal kick that invariably won’t get to the halfway line. Defenders have time with the ball in the air to close down a player who is then trying to receive a ball at head or chest height and flick on or bring down and then play in most cases backwards to a defender.
2) The godsend of the rule that allows the ball to be played to a defender inside the area means they have a bit of time to work the ball wide or to a midfielder in space who is receiving the ball to feet and is the more at ease to control and do something with it.

They’re kids so either of the above can go very right or very wrong but in terms of playing football my preference is for 2) more often that not. There’s always a risk of something going wrong but if you accept that and make the players understand it too it leads to a better mentality than lumping in to the big/fast kid up front.

Perhaps your lad plays at a higher level than my daughter, although on Sundays they are in the top tier for under 12s. But I can assure you, we’ve played against teams and won simply because they insist on playing it out from the back when they aren’t good enough to use the ball, so they end up losing it and we’ve scored. As birdman said, there are more than 1 option, we tend to vary it, also helps
our keeper is better with his feet than most of the leagues outfield players.

Of course there's more than one option but in my experience we lose possession more readily when the ball is hoofed up field from a goal kick. This is the second tier of a local league so no great shakes by any means. This doesn't mean pissing about between defenders more a midfielder gets into space and then can control and lay off, bringing more of the team into play.