WBAUnofficial
Mason and Nestor - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Mason and Nestor (/showthread.php?tid=39100)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Mason and Nestor - MrBater - 10-22-2025

(10-22-2025, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing devils advocate, how quickly did fans think it would take to build a young squad capable of exciting but crucially winning football? We have barely stabilised the club and now fans want us to still be more than just a makeweight in the league. Moneyball is not an exact science as we are discovering.

Football is simple, but we're over complicating it.

Moneyball so far is a load of old wank. Sure it might work if your data is solid, and excludes broken players, we just seem to buy injured players.

After 10 games I expected to see some semblance of a plan. To me, that seemed reasonable. We seem to work on the getting lucky model, if we score then we hopefully can hang on. It all falls apart once they score though.


RE: Mason and Nestor - Sheffieldbaggie - 10-22-2025

Yep - there’s no cohesion. Hate to say it but not unlike under dear old uncle Tony and to a similar extent Bruce: throw 11 players out on the pitch- individually we’re better than them. Go out lads, have a feeling and win the game.

Ah but we concede, go behind and then there’s no way back.


RE: Mason and Nestor - Malcolm Tucker - 10-23-2025

(10-22-2025, 09:28 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: You are forgetting Bielik who is looking like the biggest waste of £2m ever for a cash strapped club.

Also Bany - £4m on a total crock. It’s not like he had a great injury record before we signed him and then we’ve got a bit unlucky. Never played anywhere near a full season of football in his career.


RE: Mason and Nestor - Shabby Russian - 10-23-2025

I am generally wondering what people were expecting.

There was a consensus before a ball was kicked that contending for the play offs was as good as it was likely to be, and so far this season that is the level we seem to be at.

Last night was a bad performance but that's going to happen in the Championship. It's a slog, there are too many games and that affects quality.

I'm a little concerned by what I am seeing, but prepared to be patient. And not greet every iffy performance with an It's all gone wrong attitude.


RE: Mason and Nestor - CarlosCorbewrong - 10-23-2025

Fickle Sandwell Horse Fiddlers


RE: Mason and Nestor - Noibla - 10-23-2025

Sideways passing tippy tappy shite, bang average side to go with the bang average season


RE: Mason and Nestor - MGalea - 10-23-2025

Transition. Food chain. Put the bed sheets away for a couple of seasons.


RE: Mason and Nestor - AnelkasBeard - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 06:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am generally wondering what people were expecting.

There was a consensus before a ball was kicked that contending for the play offs was as good as it was likely to be, and so far this season that is the level we seem to be at.

Last night was a bad performance but that's going to happen in the Championship. It's a slog, there are too many games and that affects quality.

I'm a little concerned by what I am seeing, but prepared to be patient. And not greet every iffy performance with an It's all gone wrong attitude.

This.


RE: Mason and Nestor - Tom Joad 25 - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 06:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am generally wondering what people were expecting.

There was a consensus before a ball was kicked that contending for the play offs was as good as it was likely to be, and so far this season that is the level we seem to be at.

Last night was a bad performance but that's going to happen in the Championship. It's a slog, there are too many games and that affects quality.

I'm a little concerned by what I am seeing, but prepared to be patient. And not greet every iffy performance with an It's all gone wrong attitude.
Exactly.


RE: Mason and Nestor - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 08:57 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-23-2025, 06:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am generally wondering what people were expecting.

There was a consensus before a ball was kicked that contending for the play offs was as good as it was likely to be, and so far this season that is the level we seem to be at.

Last night was a bad performance but that's going to happen in the Championship. It's a slog, there are too many games and that affects quality.

I'm a little concerned by what I am seeing, but prepared to be patient. And not greet every iffy performance with an It's all gone wrong attitude.
Exactly.

Yep, that. 

Plus, it seems like we have a talent for signing players sometimes who have all the right ingredients, but whom for one reason or another we either can’t develop or get the best out of at the time. Heggebo seems to fit that mold right now, yet I could easily see him thriving somewhere else. In fact there is another example on a thread not so far from this one, one currently still playing in the EPL, and countless others. 

It all adds up to a continuation of the patchwork club we’ve become (both on and off the pitch) since being sold to people who don’t seem to know what they’re doing. Whilst I still think it’s a little early to cast judgement on the Patel era, I too am far from convinced about the balance of our transfer activity, and that does lie at Nestor’s door. We knew what the variables were likely to be, and injuries are a given for any club. I’m also unconvinced by Mason so far, but it would help if he had a balanced and semi-fit side to choose from. Instead, his tenure seems to becoming being defined by a wait for players to get fit, and selecting a back line from a roster too-full of centre backs, and little to no change/improvement anywhere else save for a loss of experience. But, were the plug pulled on him, I could just as easily see him faring better somewhere that balance was assured (very similar to some of those I alluded to to above).

The whole club strategy probably looks great on a .ppt, but is still very hit-and-hope from where I sit.