WBAUnofficial
The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread (/showthread.php?tid=27265)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Slowpoke Gonzalez - 10-21-2022

Hodgson and Bilic have been the only two managers I felt were the absolute right appointment at the time.

I dropped a Bilic with Val though. I thought he was a good appointment and a sign that the club was forward-thinking.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Ted Maul - 10-21-2022

Two big ones for me.

Bilic - I was sucked in early doors and started to believe the hype, that was mostly pushed by himself when in reality he was nothing of substance, just lots of soundbites and backslapping. Should have been sacked in the July when we limped over the line.

Clarke: Unconvinced to begin with but did a great job for a year or so, lack of managerial experience told in the end but he's gone on to do well in the decade since.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - SW4Baggie - 10-21-2022

(10-21-2022, 12:20 PM)Baggie in Valley Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 10:54 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Megson: I’d never heard of him and had zero expectations
Robson: Was dead against his appointment.
Mowbray: Was totally convinced he’d be the messiah after Robbo!
RDM: quietly confident and thought he fitted where we’d had success previously
Roy: was the only candidate I wanted at the time given what he’d done with Fulham
Clarke: was 50/50, seemed sensible and had faith in our set-up but would have preferred a “name” at that time
Mel: thought he was going to take us to new levels and heights Big Grin
AFI: was very anti-it…. Just felt lazy
Pulis: was pro- initially. It just made sense.
Pardew: again, thought it made sense… completely misjudged that one.
Moore: think everyone wanted Dave after the revival!
Billic: was super excited!!!
Allardyce: didn’t want him, felt he’d spend money we didn’t have and was a pointless gamble
Val: wanted him as felt he’d rebuild
Bruce: didn’t want him, was concerned about his Newcastle time and being a dinosaur.

Overall, I’m confident in my judgement (shock…) but have got a few wrong.

I like hipster managers and those that promise good football or have a new idea. We tend to do better when managers are riding a wave when they join and bring a new optimism… the last thing we need are tired managers, ones with nothing to prove who view us as a meal ticket.

You'd never heard of Gary Megson?

I was about 14… the Internet back then was to slowly download grainy images of breasts and to fill my parents’ computer with viruses from Napster…


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Ournextstriker - 10-21-2022

Im always willing to support anyone that manages our club or at least give them the benefit of the doubt

Pardew was the only one that i disliked prior to his appointment and wished he had never been given the job


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Ted Maul - 10-21-2022

I sincerely hope I'm adding Carvalhal's name to this thread in six months time.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - HLS - 10-22-2022

I wanted Hughton and was disappointed we got Roy.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - SW4Baggie - 10-22-2022

(10-21-2022, 11:29 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).

I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)

You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).

My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.

A lot of it also comes down to whether you view a manager as being successful or not.

I think both Mowbray, Bilic and Val were successes and I guess you don’t.

Val wasn’t a success, he achieved diddly squat. 
Bilic a kind of success but his teams are far too easy to play against for any prolonged success and left any manager replacing him with an impossible task of staying up. 
Mowbray, best resources in league, promoted as expected and relegated as expected and did the almost impossible and made football pretentious

He kept a weaker squad than we currently have now in the top 6…  
Like I said, you have a very different view on success as and when it suits.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Cuzer - 10-22-2022

95% on here shoukd be saying Val….

Pardew for me, thought he would improve us and give us a chance of staying up, what a disaster he was

Mel I liked and that never worked however was thrown under the WBA bus before he reign started unfortunately

Cuzer


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Tom Joad - 10-22-2022

I've been wrong many times about managers. However, I knew Pardew would be a disaster.


RE: The admit who you got wrong with managers thread - Big Daddy Cool - 10-22-2022

(10-22-2022, 09:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:29 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).

I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)

You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).

My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.

A lot of it also comes down to whether you view a manager as being successful or not.

I think both Mowbray, Bilic and Val were successes and I guess you don’t.

Val wasn’t a success, he achieved diddly squat. 
Bilic a kind of success but his teams are far too easy to play against for any prolonged success and left any manager replacing him with an impossible task of staying up. 
Mowbray, best resources in league, promoted as expected and relegated as expected and did the almost impossible and made football pretentious

He kept a weaker squad than we currently have now in the top 6…  
Like I said, you have a very different view on success as and when it suits.

How can a manager who was given a 4 year deal with the objective to achieve promotion and then sacked within 7 months due to

Poor results (Near the bottom of the form table and heading out the top 6)
Poor football
Unpopular with supporters
Falling out with a number of players

How can he in any way be consider a success? Because he did better than Bruce? Come on..