![]() |
|
Starmer's Bane - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Starmer's Bane (/showthread.php?tid=25692) |
RE: Starmer's Bane - Offside - 07-12-2022 I see Starmer has resorted to Labour's favourite dog whistle appeal. No doubt driving private landlords out of the rented sector is high on his agenda. Michael Gove is already doing a really good job on that. "It’s why when I say we have a plan for investing in education, I also say it’ll be funded by closing the VAT loophole for private schools. Or when I say we need to sort out mental health treatment in this country, I also tell you that we’ll do it by closing tax loopholes used by private equity." I wonder how the state schools will cope with a sudden influx of kids whose parents can't afford the VAT on school fees. RE: Starmer's Bane - Fido - 07-12-2022 (07-12-2022, 09:37 AM)Offside Wrote: I see Starmer has resorted to Labour's favourite dog whistle appeal. No doubt driving private landlords out of the rented sector is high on his agenda. Michael Gove is already doing a really good job on that. Private education and private health care should be encouraged if it reduces the burden on the state-funded versions. This has little logic and just smacks of them vs us. RE: Starmer's Bane - Baggybenny - 07-12-2022 Next they will be saying we need private armies and police to take the burden off the State RE: Starmer's Bane - Fido - 07-12-2022 (07-12-2022, 09:45 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: Next they will be saying we need private armies and police to take the burden off the State That's not exactly a free choice unless you want to maintain your own security services. Think before you post. RE: Starmer's Bane - Offside - 07-12-2022 (07-12-2022, 09:45 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: Next they will be saying we need private armies and police to take the burden off the State Assuming that a proportion of their NI and income tax payments go towards state education, they are not depriving any other child of an education by putting their own kid through private school. I know a guy who drives a bus, his wife works in Sainsburys, and they are putting their language-gifted kid through private school The state school was not interested in her exceptional ability to pick up a language in about 12 weeks. I also have a distant cousin with similar abilities. She too had to go through private education to fulfil her potential. Not sure where she is now but she spent 12 years working at the UN in New York as an instantaneous interpreter. RE: Starmer's Bane - Ossian - 07-12-2022 My concern is the opposite: certain things will always need to remain under central or local government control - the armed forces; the police; the security and intelligence services. If everything else is slowly and surreptitiously 'outsourced' until all that remains under the jurisdiction of 'the state' are the mechanisms of surveillance, enforcement and control, we'll one morning find we've woken up in Erich Honecker's DDR. I have no issues with private education or healthcare, although the charitable status of private schools is widely abused; let's not sleepwalk into something far worse while the politicians divert our attention with class warfare. (Died in Santiago, Chile, by the way, did Erich; how's that for symmetry?) RE: Starmer's Bane - Derek Hardballs - 07-12-2022 (07-12-2022, 09:42 AM)Fido Wrote:(07-12-2022, 09:37 AM)Offside Wrote: I see Starmer has resorted to Labour's favourite dog whistle appeal. No doubt driving private landlords out of the rented sector is high on his agenda. Michael Gove is already doing a really good job on that. ‘Them and us’ Arf, twelve years of the Conservative’s putting massive social, cultural and economic divides in place and blaming everyone but themselves for it. Why should the state essentially subsidise private schools? Why should tax loopholes not be closed? RE: Starmer's Bane - Protheroe - 07-12-2022 Because it depends whether you believe private schools deserve exempt status or not. If you believe they do, then no VAT is due and there is no "loophole". If you believe they don't, then there's still no loophole but you must reclassify them as businesses. Personally, the huge endowments and landholdings of some of the best known private schools make them an obvious target - particularly for those who view them as elitist institutions. For many of the smaller private schools they already operate at the margin, and adding VAT to fees would probably push them over the edge in terms lost pupils. Universities are also elitist. Do you you VAT on fees for them too? I'm also curious as to which "loopholes" Starmer wishes to close in relation to PE. PE is often a shabby underhand sector with an awful track record in areas such as retail. If UK "loopholes" are closed then surely PE will just do even more of its business offshore. |