WBAUnofficial
My take on Moore - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: My take on Moore (/showthread.php?tid=2513)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: My take on Moore - Albionmad - 03-03-2019

(03-03-2019, 09:02 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(03-03-2019, 09:45 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: I don't know if he is sticking to plans too long - sometimes they can take time and it is worth it when they come  to  fruition - and you can be discouraged and give up too soon when it's not going right. Then you just lurch from one plan to another. Not saying that's what's happening here - I just don't know and of course any plan requires fkexibility. 

This is a key part of management getting the balance right between sticking to your guns and being flexible to change when things clearly aren't working. As you say, you can't just change plan every time there's a setback it would be total chaos but on the other hand there's been loads of managers done for in the past by refusing to admit their way of doing things wasn't working and sticking with it to the bitter end.
We'll let's hope this week has been a huge wake up call. It's now or never to go on a winning run. If the top three have us looking over their shoulder and suffer squeeky bum times we might make it.
The big if however, is will DM make the necessary changes?


RE: My take on Moore - WorcBaggie - 03-03-2019

(03-03-2019, 09:28 AM)richbaggie Wrote: At the start of the season, I thought play offs would be a good return after the disaster and mess created by TP and AP. The squad is decent at this level but nowhere near as good as some pundits and Baggies make out. Losing Barnes was huge, MP injuries too. Pace gone.

Darren Moore took on an almighty mess. A split club with a poisonous centre.The job he has done to change that around and put us into a relatively strong position is one that deserves huge credit, certainly not the abuse I sadly heard on Friday night.

I always felt that giving him the job was a job too big for a novice but understood why we gave it him after the way he galvanised us. Once that decision was made, it was important to then to give him time, more than this season unless it was a disaster. And it clearly isn't disaster. So we should continue to support him to let him grow and learn. Hes one heck of a man manager. The players would run through brick walls for him. What he lacks at the moment he can learn. You cant learn what he already has. Its given to you at birth.

However, and this is key, he has to stop repeating mistakes. Novice or not, you can't continually repeat mistakes. Persevering with a plan when clearly flawed is poor management. We have flexibility in the squad to try different things. It's time for Darren to learn and adapt.

I am absolutely behind DM and if we reach the play offs and fail I would still be inclined to keep him for next season too. The way he rescued us from the debacle of last season and the way the club stunk, seemingly, from top to bottom it would be the least he deserves. Your last 2 sentences are key and this is why I am so disappointed in the last 2 games because we, as fans, could see what was going to happen. Dumbo makes a great point elsewhere that we have no idea what goes on behind closed doors but equally if nothing appears to be changing DM and the rest of his team need to be questioned. Finally, I don't buy this inexperienced excuse either. He has been in the professional game for, what, 20 years or more (??) and coaching at the Alboin in various guises for a number of years within that 20. There is enough experience from that and from within his hand picked coaching unit to be 'flexible' and to 'learn and adapt'.


RE: My take on Moore - The liquidator - 03-03-2019

His refusal to play gayle down the centre is worrying someone should show him a video of stoke at home and see what we are missing . either murphy or phillips have to play if fit they are our only out let who can run with the ball .


RE: My take on Moore - BombersFlask - 03-03-2019

Excellent man manager but thick as mince meat when it comes to any kind of footballing tactics.


RE: My take on Moore - CA Baggie - 03-03-2019

(03-03-2019, 03:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I agree with most of the post. Not sure about the repeating mistakes part.

Earlier in the season we had a run of poor results and performances that saw us take 1 point from 12 . Moore and his team changed things and we went on a run between the Leeds home and QPR away that saw us take around 2 points per game. That run has come to an end, but it would seem that Moore was prepared to change things when we were going through a poor run of results and performances.

Since then despite there being some obstacles to progress, some of which Rich mentioned. Results have been good up to the Sheff Utd game . So it is difficult to know exactly what are these repeated mistakes.

Like any other Albion there are things I find frustrating and there are genuine and justified concerns. 

The primary one being midfield, not sure we have the personnel available to get a consistently cohesive midfield. It's not something that Moore can do much about. It would be nice if Harper and Field were older with more experience. It would be nice if Barry and Hoolihan were younger and Morrison not so injury prone. But that's not what we have to work with.

Another concern is Rodriguez and Gayle. Good forwards in this division, but can they play together, Certainly since Barnes left and Phiilips has been injured, they have not been effective as a partnership. This is something that Moore can do something about, be interesting to see if he does.

Overall I would like to see him managing us next season . 

But at the end of the day whoever is manager next season, they will be very dependent on the recruitment department. B

The form from Leeds home to QPR away has 2 wins at home.  No wins in 2019.

He changed the shape for the Leeds game and it worked, not worked since bar Wigan.  What changes to the shape has he made? None.  Doggedly keeping Gayle in an unnatural position and playing a midfield 3 that has no one capable of running with the ball or getting ahead of the ball and joining the attack.  Injuries have played a part, but we’be not been crippled with them.  By and large it works away, but it doesn’t at home.  Change it, then those almost 2 points per game you mentioned may have been closer to a total for automatic promotion.

Don’t throw the baby out with the bath water, but a change to the water once in a while is needed.


RE: My take on Moore - coxy134 - 03-04-2019

Think we have to bare in mind a couple of facts pointed out in the opening post.

He inherited a squad based on a slow sit back and defend ethic.
Along with a squad that needed investment around 3 seasons ago at least or rather the signing of the RIGHT players.

My concern with Dm however is he is trying to play tactics on a more attacking approach with players that simply cannot do it but if you look at our bench most weeks it gives an idea of how weak our squad is.

The main problem is the simple fact our chairman is not backing him in the transfer market and the fact our recruitment is woeful.

I feel sorry for DM but I feel he may either be the cheapest option in keeping him or a scapegoat for all the above.

My take on all our problems is the very poor recruitment.


RE: My take on Moore - MGalea - 03-04-2019

Big words there Rich.

<winky face>


RE: My take on Moore - brada_wba - 03-04-2019

'players would run through brick walls for him'

Are you watching the same West Brom that I have all season? Laziest bunch of players I've seen in many years for us.

This was absolutely proven on Friday night when Leeds completely dominated us off the ball, despite having less rest before the game.

Darren Moore's inability to motivate the team until they go a goal down at home is somehow being blamed on the home fans for not singing enough. Bizarre.


RE: My take on Moore - richbaggie - 03-04-2019

(03-04-2019, 10:36 AM)brada_wba Wrote: 'players would run through brick walls for him'

Are you watching the same West Brom that I have all season? Laziest bunch of players I've seen in many years for us.

This was absolutely proven on Friday night when Leeds completely dominated us off the ball, despite having less rest before the game.

Darren Moore's inability to motivate the team until they go a goal down at home is somehow being blamed on the home fans for not singing enough. Bizarre.

You are the only person I have seen call them lazy since DM took over. 
Given the hundreds, thousands of comments made by so many, I would suggest you are talking out your arse.


RE: My take on Moore - Wednesburybaggie - 03-04-2019

(03-04-2019, 10:58 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(03-04-2019, 10:36 AM)brada_wba Wrote: 'players would run through brick walls for him'

Are you watching the same West Brom that I have all season? Laziest bunch of players I've seen in many years for us.

This was absolutely proven on Friday night when Leeds completely dominated us off the ball, despite having less rest before the game.

Darren Moore's inability to motivate the team until they go a goal down at home is somehow being blamed on the home fans for not singing enough. Bizarre.

You are the only person I have seen call them lazy since DM took over. 
Given the hundreds, thousands of comments made by so many, I would suggest you are talking out your arse.

Definitely not lazy, just one paced and ponderous .  I'm sure that the players are trying, but in a lot of cases, are just not what is required, or are not suitable for the formation we use.