WBAUnofficial
“The Squad isn’t good enough” - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: “The Squad isn’t good enough” (/showthread.php?tid=24901)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - Duffers - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 07:06 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Don't agree Duffers.id say their career record and the fact they have not lasted at any higher level shows they are not good enough. Take Kanu and Pereira out and we're left with a mid table championship side.

We’ll have to agree to disagree. I look at the below and I see a group of players who are vastly underperforming, not through lack of ability, but through lack of heart and application.

Johnstone - proven PL quality, part of the England setup.
Bartley - solid top half Champ performer
Furlong/Townsend/Ajayi - part of the defence that took us up. Better than most seem to suggest.
Livermore - Vastly experienced, should be bossing this league.
Mowatt- Driving force of a Barnsley side that made the play offs
Grant - 20 goals for Huddersfield two years ago
Robinson - shows flashes of brilliance (eg Chelsea) should be consistent at this level
Grady - Pissed the league two years ago

The loss of Pereira was damaging for sure, but I cannot be convinced that if that lot had showed even an ounce of heart and fight then there would still be an eight point gap to the playoffs. They showed the correct mentality for the first few months and we were top three… what happened?


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - GunsOfNavarone - 04-12-2022

(04-11-2022, 04:49 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-11-2022, 04:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad is good enough the attitude isn’t. There is no way that most bar Fulham and perhaps Bournemouth have better players what they have is a better attitude and in some cases more confidence.

The squad is unbalanced in central midfield but that is down to the previous managers tactics and wishes. It doesn’t excuse where we are in the league however. We are like the lazy, clever kid in class who is far more intelligent than many but wastes that talent doing just enough.

This is my point, going purely on ability alone are there many better keepers at this level than Johnstone? Are there many better centre halves Bartley/Clarke/Ajayi? As much as we complain about the likes of Grant, Grady, Robinson, etc they have all proven that they can perform and score goals at this level, both here and elsewhere...........

Good players are good on a consistent basis. That's because they're good enough to perform on a consistent basis. None of the players that you have named are consistently good. That's because they're inconsistent.

Inconsistent players can't be relied on to deliver the goods as regularly as consistently good players. We've managed to accrue a squad of moments players. As in they have good moments in games or they are good for a couple of games before reverting to type. 

When was the last time you saw Johnstone, Bartley, Clarke, Ajayi, Grant, Diangana or Robinson play consistently well over a period of games? When was the last time you felt you could hang your hat on them to deliver the goods?

Never for me, not one of them. They're all wildly inconsistent. They have moments in games when they deliver. They even have good games but it's rare they have genuinely good runs of games.

They have their strengths but they all lack the desire, application and levels of concentration required to apply those strengths within a team framework over a prolonged period. The teams above us have players capable of applying themselves consistently. 

You can buy talent and you can coach it. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink. They're all far too comfortable in their own little bubbles to give enough of a shit to bother. They don't have the hunger.

I agree there should still be enough for the playoffs but we don't have a Pereira to paper over the cracks in their mentality. And that's just the players listed. Recruitment has been dire for several seasons and this is where we find ourselves.

Looking at where we were when Lai came in it could be argued Johnstone, Bartley, Ajayi, Grant, Diangana and Robinson should never have been signed as none of them would have played on a regular basis when Lai came in and there are reasons why we find ourselves lower. 

As for Phillips he was a confidence player back then. Now he's older, more injured and still out. He'll give us a few games and good moments before disappearing again. He should never have been offered a new contract.

Given he's post peak Townsend was given too many years and I'd be happily stunned if Furlong turned out to be a football player. I cannot fathom how either landed such long contracts. And that's before we get to midfield and going into a season minus the forward focal point we so obviously needed.

As for the players' attitudes in many instances (not all) they appear to stink. Too many go missing. A squad with players of ability and poor attitudes isn't a good squad. It's a squad lacking in desire, resilience and the attitude required to attain success.


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - coxy134 - 04-12-2022

When was any other club been linked with any of our players?

Besides our youth players who else is shown any interest with our first team squad? 

Only Johnstone.

That should tell us enough.


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - Kit Kat Chunky - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 07:15 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:06 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Don't agree Duffers.id say their career record and the fact they have not lasted at any higher level shows they are not good enough. Take Kanu and Pereira out and we're left with a mid table championship side.

We’ll have to agree to disagree. I look at the below and I see a group of players who are vastly underperforming, not through lack of ability, but through lack of heart and application.

Johnstone - proven PL quality, part of the England setup.
Bartley - solid top half Champ performer
Furlong/Townsend/Ajayi - part of the defence that took us up. Better than most seem to suggest.
Livermore - Vastly experienced, should be bossing this league.
Mowatt- Driving force of a Barnsley side that made the play offs
Grant - 20 goals for Huddersfield two years ago
Robinson - shows flashes of brilliance (eg Chelsea) should be consistent at this level
Grady - Pissed the league two years ago

The loss of Pereira was damaging for sure, but I cannot be convinced that if that lot had showed even an ounce of heart and fight then there would still be an eight point gap to the playoffs. They showed the correct mentality for the first few months and we were top three… what happened?

Agree with this post, and most of the thread, Duffers. 

Tom - There are many "mid table" Chump footballers who would give their right arm to be on the contracts that our lot are on. We are in the middle of a cluster fuck. The last one lasted many years, and it took Megson to sort it out. Val tried, but player power won.


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - Tom Joad - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 09:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:15 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:06 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Don't agree Duffers.id say their career record and the fact they have not lasted at any higher level shows they are not good enough. Take Kanu and Pereira out and we're left with a mid table championship side.

We’ll have to agree to disagree. I look at the below and I see a group of players who are vastly underperforming, not through lack of ability, but through lack of heart and application.

Johnstone - proven PL quality, part of the England setup.
Bartley - solid top half Champ performer
Furlong/Townsend/Ajayi - part of the defence that took us up. Better than most seem to suggest.
Livermore - Vastly experienced, should be bossing this league.
Mowatt- Driving force of a Barnsley side that made the play offs
Grant - 20 goals for Huddersfield two years ago
Robinson - shows flashes of brilliance (eg Chelsea) should be consistent at this level
Grady - Pissed the league two years ago

The loss of Pereira was damaging for sure, but I cannot be convinced that if that lot had showed even an ounce of heart and fight then there would still be an eight point gap to the playoffs. They showed the correct mentality for the first few months and we were top three… what happened?

Agree with this post, and most of the thread, Duffers. 

Tom - There are many "mid table" Chump footballers who would give their right arm to be on the contracts that our lot are on. We are in the middle of a cluster fuck. The last one lasted many years, and it took Megson to sort it out. Val tried, but player power won.
Kit Kat. I'm sure there are many bricklayers and plasterers that would give their right arms for such contracts but it doesn't mean they would be any good or challenging for the play offs.
Duffers. Attitude is a huge part of the job. Look at the desire of Beckham and Scholes, the workmate of Kane. If you haven't got the hunger to improve, you won't be a good player regardless of the odd good game every 6 weeks. I'm also not sold on Bartley and Ajayi as top half championship performers and Furlong was replaced by Ferguson,  only returning when we were on the slide.
The fact that a number of managers can't get a tune out of them is damning.


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - Hopalong - 04-12-2022

(04-11-2022, 02:06 PM)Duffers Wrote: TGH is hardly going to say “None of us give a fuck. While you’re booing we are all rolling around on a massive pile of your money pissing ourselves!” is he?

No, but conversely neither did he have to be as adamant as he was in what he said.  I think what he was really saying was the management are clueless.


RE: “The Squad isn’t good enough” - Duffers - 04-12-2022

(04-12-2022, 12:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 09:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:15 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-12-2022, 07:06 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Don't agree Duffers.id say their career record and the fact they have not lasted at any higher level shows they are not good enough. Take Kanu and Pereira out and we're left with a mid table championship side.

We’ll have to agree to disagree. I look at the below and I see a group of players who are vastly underperforming, not through lack of ability, but through lack of heart and application.

Johnstone - proven PL quality, part of the England setup.
Bartley - solid top half Champ performer
Furlong/Townsend/Ajayi - part of the defence that took us up. Better than most seem to suggest.
Livermore - Vastly experienced, should be bossing this league.
Mowatt- Driving force of a Barnsley side that made the play offs
Grant - 20 goals for Huddersfield two years ago
Robinson - shows flashes of brilliance (eg Chelsea) should be consistent at this level
Grady - Pissed the league two years ago

The loss of Pereira was damaging for sure, but I cannot be convinced that if that lot had showed even an ounce of heart and fight then there would still be an eight point gap to the playoffs. They showed the correct mentality for the first few months and we were top three… what happened?

Agree with this post, and most of the thread, Duffers. 

Tom - There are many "mid table" Chump footballers who would give their right arm to be on the contracts that our lot are on. We are in the middle of a cluster fuck. The last one lasted many years, and it took Megson to sort it out. Val tried, but player power won.
Kit Kat. I'm sure there are many bricklayers and plasterers that would give their right arms for such contracts but it doesn't mean they would be any good or challenging for the play offs.
Duffers. Attitude is a huge part of the job. Look at the desire of Beckham and Scholes, the workmate of Kane. If you haven't got the hunger to improve, you won't be a good player regardless of the odd good game every 6 weeks. I'm also not sold on Bartley and Ajayi as top half championship performers and Furlong was replaced by Ferguson,  only returning when we were on the slide.
The fact that a number of managers can't get a tune out of them is damning.

That’s been my point all along. With the right attitude this shower of bastards would be much higher in the league. People have been saying that they are technically poor footballers, which is what I can’t accept. They are technically good enough, it’s just that their attitudes stink.