RE: Ian Pearce - Johnnykayeengland - 03-08-2022
I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
RE: Ian Pearce - baggie93 - 03-08-2022
Ian Pearce..Head of Recruitment as far as I know. Given our recruitment in recent times I'd question his ability.
RE: Ian Pearce - Derek Hardballs - 03-08-2022
Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
RE: Ian Pearce - Borin' Baggie - 03-08-2022
(03-08-2022, 12:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
Ashworth's role was revolutionary in English football, but you could trace it from our use of Wyscout and data-focused scouting, building a comprehensive scouting network and building contacts to the club in general, the establishment and development of an actual academy and support staff etc.
Ian Pearce's role doesn't have that paper trail and given so many managers in recent times have relied on their own contacts external to the club that suggests there isn't a structure there. That's been highlighted by Gourlay as being non-existent at present in the local press this morning, which again begs the question what does Ian Pearce actually do?
(03-08-2022, 01:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
And as soon as Megson left that went with him, which is the point. Bilic's contacts worked well and it's the reason we signed Pereira, when he left that went. You can't run a football club like that anymore, it exemplifies the short-termism that has got us into our current predicament.
The club needs to build a sustainable model for recruitment, we are not going to have a manager for 10 years so we need to have a structure in place to identify players independent of the manager but we might have a framework of operation to distribute knowledge and crucially risk. Even a big club with loads of money to spaff up the wall like Man United have been screwed over on their reliance on one man across the whole club.
RE: Ian Pearce - MancBaggie - 03-08-2022
(03-08-2022, 01:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-08-2022, 12:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
Ashworth's role was revolutionary in English football, but you could trace it from our use of Wyscout and data-focused scouting, building a comprehensive scouting network and building contacts to the club in general, the establishment and development of an actual academy and support staff etc.
Ian Pearce's role doesn't have that paper trail and given so many managers in recent times have relied on their own contacts external to the club that suggests there isn't a structure there. That's been highlighted by Gourlay as being non-existent at present in the local press this morning, which again begs the question what does Ian Pearce actually do?
(03-08-2022, 01:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
And as soon as Megson left that went with him, which is the point. Bilic's contacts worked well and it's the reason we signed Pereira, when he left that went. You can't run a football club like that anymore, it exemplifies the short-termism that has got us into our current predicament.
The club needs to build a sustainable model for recruitment, we are not going to have a manager for 10 years so we need to have a structure in place to identify players independent of the manager but we might have a framework of operation to distribute knowledge and crucially risk. Even a big club with loads of money to spaff up the wall like Man United have been screwed over on their reliance on one man across the whole club.
Spot on
RE: Ian Pearce - Cuzer - 03-08-2022
So our recruitment hits an all time low and we promote the biff responsible?
Genius
Cuzer
RE: Ian Pearce - Derek Hardballs - 03-08-2022
(03-08-2022, 01:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-08-2022, 12:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
Ashworth's role was revolutionary in English football, but you could trace it from our use of Wyscout and data-focused scouting, building a comprehensive scouting network and building contacts to the club in general, the establishment and development of an actual academy and support staff etc.
Ian Pearce's role doesn't have that paper trail and given so many managers in recent times have relied on their own contacts external to the club that suggests there isn't a structure there. That's been highlighted by Gourlay as being non-existent at present in the local press this morning, which again begs the question what does Ian Pearce actually do?
(03-08-2022, 01:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
And as soon as Megson left that went with him, which is the point. Bilic's contacts worked well and it's the reason we signed Pereira, when he left that went. You can't run a football club like that anymore, it exemplifies the short-termism that has got us into our current predicament.
The club needs to build a sustainable model for recruitment, we are not going to have a manager for 10 years so we need to have a structure in place to identify players independent of the manager but we might have a framework of operation to distribute knowledge and crucially risk. Even a big club with loads of money to spaff up the wall like Man United have been screwed over on their reliance on one man across the whole club.
I never said we shouldn’t have a sustainable model, but models are only ever as good as those who work in them. Are we going to put the money into this model to make it work? Having a lovely diagram of how something is supposed to work is lovely but if you have Terry Burton it Richard Garlick leading the model, it will fail just as frequently / consistently as any old skool managerial model. All comes down ahem to money abs investment again.
RE: Ian Pearce - Borin' Baggie - 03-08-2022
(03-08-2022, 02:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-08-2022, 01:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-08-2022, 12:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
Ashworth's role was revolutionary in English football, but you could trace it from our use of Wyscout and data-focused scouting, building a comprehensive scouting network and building contacts to the club in general, the establishment and development of an actual academy and support staff etc.
Ian Pearce's role doesn't have that paper trail and given so many managers in recent times have relied on their own contacts external to the club that suggests there isn't a structure there. That's been highlighted by Gourlay as being non-existent at present in the local press this morning, which again begs the question what does Ian Pearce actually do?
(03-08-2022, 01:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
And as soon as Megson left that went with him, which is the point. Bilic's contacts worked well and it's the reason we signed Pereira, when he left that went. You can't run a football club like that anymore, it exemplifies the short-termism that has got us into our current predicament.
The club needs to build a sustainable model for recruitment, we are not going to have a manager for 10 years so we need to have a structure in place to identify players independent of the manager but we might have a framework of operation to distribute knowledge and crucially risk. Even a big club with loads of money to spaff up the wall like Man United have been screwed over on their reliance on one man across the whole club.
I never said we shouldn’t have a sustainable model, but models are only ever as good as those who work in them. Are we going to put the money into this model to make it work? Having a lovely diagram of how something is supposed to work is lovely but if you have Terry Burton it Richard Garlick leading the model, it will fail just as frequently / consistently as any old skool managerial model. All comes down ahem to money abs investment again.
Everything comes down to money, you pay the money you can get the best. Money isn't everything though, case in point Man United.
Doesn't mean you can't have a scalable framework, and let's not forget that we managed to pull well above our financial weight through having such a plan and structure beforehand. Luton are a prime example of a club pulling well above their financial weight in the Championship through a structured plan put into place in non-league and they are above us and our parachute payment riches. We can't keep with this cycle of relying on managers to do everything because it's just not sustainable, will cost more in the long term and will lead to us spiralling and once we sack the manager we lose all of that structure and are back at square one. We already have assets a lot of clubs in the Championship do not, our academy and commercial income, that we can use as a buffer.
RE: Ian Pearce - baggie_ray - 03-08-2022
I thought Ian Pearce was a middle manager with no real power. The scouts give him their reports which he passes on to the DOF/manager.
The DOF/manager tells Ian Pearce what they need in a footballer (soft feet etc.) which Ian Pearce relays to the scouts.
I didn't think the scouts had the authority or autonomy to look at a player and think "ooh, he's a bit good" and relay that back if said player doesn't have the attributes that the club are looking for.
I'm probably wide of the mark with all that though.
RE: Ian Pearce - Derek Hardballs - 03-08-2022
(03-08-2022, 03:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-08-2022, 02:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-08-2022, 01:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-08-2022, 12:49 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've no idea what Pearce does either. But then none of us had heard of Dan ashworth at first.
Nor what a director of football was.
Now we're desperate for one! Maybe he's an answer, maybe not. But I'm pleased to see that someone is trying to improve our structure.
Ashworth's role was revolutionary in English football, but you could trace it from our use of Wyscout and data-focused scouting, building a comprehensive scouting network and building contacts to the club in general, the establishment and development of an actual academy and support staff etc.
Ian Pearce's role doesn't have that paper trail and given so many managers in recent times have relied on their own contacts external to the club that suggests there isn't a structure there. That's been highlighted by Gourlay as being non-existent at present in the local press this morning, which again begs the question what does Ian Pearce actually do?
(03-08-2022, 01:05 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing Devil’s advocate the much derided on here at least Megson’s Dad and Courtina scouting was just as successful as any other model we have implemented.
And as soon as Megson left that went with him, which is the point. Bilic's contacts worked well and it's the reason we signed Pereira, when he left that went. You can't run a football club like that anymore, it exemplifies the short-termism that has got us into our current predicament.
The club needs to build a sustainable model for recruitment, we are not going to have a manager for 10 years so we need to have a structure in place to identify players independent of the manager but we might have a framework of operation to distribute knowledge and crucially risk. Even a big club with loads of money to spaff up the wall like Man United have been screwed over on their reliance on one man across the whole club.
I never said we shouldn’t have a sustainable model, but models are only ever as good as those who work in them. Are we going to put the money into this model to make it work? Having a lovely diagram of how something is supposed to work is lovely but if you have Terry Burton it Richard Garlick leading the model, it will fail just as frequently / consistently as any old skool managerial model. All comes down ahem to money abs investment again.
Everything comes down to money, you pay the money you can get the best. Money isn't everything though, case in point Man United.
Doesn't mean you can't have a scalable framework, and let's not forget that we managed to pull well above our financial weight through having such a plan and structure beforehand. Luton are a prime example of a club pulling well above their financial weight in the Championship through a structured plan put into place in non-league and they are above us and our parachute payment riches. We can't keep with this cycle of relying on managers to do everything because it's just not sustainable, will cost more in the long term and will lead to us spiralling and once we sack the manager we lose all of that structure and are back at square one. We already have assets a lot of clubs in the Championship do not, our academy and commercial income, that we can use as a buffer.
I think you are forgetting how we got to where we are now. Our lauded system fell to pieces as soon as Ashworth left. We tried to do it on the cheap with Garlick, then Burton, then expensively with the bloke from Blackburn whose name escapes me (Williams?) Have all the scaleable plans and structures you want but ultimately it will come down to whether we have the right people in place. Over the last decade getting rid of those failing in those roles has cost us a lot of money and seen a lot of upheaval. Every bit as much as losing managers.
Shall we list some of the dross bought by committee, Gamboa, Samaras, Davidson, Blanco, Poco etc Ot who can forget the ‘we want a coach not a manager’ situation where it led to Terry Burton bringing in Irvine who ticked every box under the system at the time.
|