WBAUnofficial
Nice to see the EU - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Nice to see the EU (/showthread.php?tid=6964)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Nice to see the EU - baggy1 - 10-15-2019

You seem to shift your argument around a bit. It isn't the dictionary definition of despotism really is it - Despotism refers to individuals taking full control, individuals such as Hitler or Mussolini. Erdogen is probably the nearest we have to that on this continent at this moment.

Now, don't misinterpret me, I'm saying that this is a shit way of governing and the individuals or parties should be bought to task and made to answer for these crimes. But you have tried to shoehorn a statement from a key EU MP into this to win a point - Verhofstadt was clearly talking about Hitler and Mussolini, and that was one of the reasons for setting up the EU. The EU hasn't failed by not dealing with this - You have stretched the link to breaking point to get across a weak point.

I'll go back to my original point - The EU tend not to get involved in domestic politics.

Curiously you've avoided my question about Maggie, by your definition and what she authorised with the miners, does that make her a Despot?


RE: Nice to see the EU - Malcolm Tucker - 10-16-2019

(10-15-2019, 02:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You seem to shift your argument around a bit. It isn't the dictionary definition of despotism really is it - Despotism refers to individuals taking full control, individuals such as Hitler or Mussolini. Erdogen is probably the nearest we have to that on this continent at this moment.

Now, don't misinterpret me, I'm saying that this is a shit way of governing and the individuals or parties should be bought to task and made to answer for these crimes. But you have tried to shoehorn a statement from a key EU MP into this to win a point - Verhofstadt was clearly talking about Hitler and Mussolini, and that was one of the reasons for setting up the EU. The EU hasn't failed by not dealing with this - You have stretched the link to breaking point to get across a weak point.

I'll go back to my original point - The EU tend not to get involved in domestic politics.

Curiously you've avoided my question about Maggie, by your definition and what she authorised with the miners, does that make her a Despot?

Sorry, I must've missed the Maggie bit. In answer to your question, she was and always will be a complete and utter cunt.

Despotism - "the exercise of absolute power, especially in a cruel and oppressive way"


RE: Nice to see the EU - Sotv - 10-18-2019

(10-15-2019, 07:07 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: So you're saying you think the EU should've overruled the Spanish government in a domestic issue? I thought you took the opposite view.

As Baggy1 says, they don't really do that anyway...

I’m saying they are hardly the defenders of democracy that many claim they are

(10-15-2019, 08:33 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.

“Your ilk” are you able to describe “my ilk”’without resorting to stereotypes? I’d be interested in just what “my ilk”’is.
As it is, I have already written to my MP Andrew Mitchell asking him why the UK government hasn’t made a statement regarding Catalonia rather than just sitting their wondering.


RE: Nice to see the EU - baggy1 - 10-18-2019

I'm not certain that anyone has said they are the defenders of democracy - I certainly haven't, but one thing is clear we are better in the EU than out. This is shown by the lack of benefits to leaving being highlighted despite multiple times asked for. The only poster on here than has come close to any ability to show any benefits is JOK.

Simple question - what are the benefits to leaving the EU?


RE: Nice to see the EU - Sotv - 10-18-2019

(10-15-2019, 11:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-15-2019, 10:17 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Verhofstadt stood up in Parliament and credited the EU with ending despotism in Europe, yet here we are. Don't get me wrong, this is ultimately on the Spanish for being a shower of bastards but it just makes his claims totally ludicrous.

https://www.facebook.com/GuyVerhofstadt/videos/european-democracy/262849631029415/

You can't have it both ways, you can't have Brexiteers (way too cool a name for them) bemoaning the lack of autonomy of a national state that is in the EU and then at the same time slating the EU for not enforcing rather subjective rules of what is and isn't permissible democratically on said national state.  

This isn't so much a stick to beat the EU with rather a soggy twig.
You miss the point entirely dickheadballs. We voted to leave the EU precisely so they couldn’t interfere in our autonomy. The fact is Spain is an EU member and we are constantly told by remongols how the EU is supposed to be a force for democracy. It’s certainly failing on that count in this case.

(10-18-2019, 12:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not certain that anyone has said they are the defenders of democracy - I certainly haven't, but one thing is clear we are better in the EU than out. This is shown by the lack of benefits to leaving being highlighted despite multiple times asked for. The only poster on here than has come close to any ability to show any benefits is JOK.

Simple question - what are the benefits to leaving the EU?

There has been plenty of talk from remain about how the EU is a force for democracy and how it has kept Europe at peace. 
You are attempting to play the misdirection game with your question, a poor attempt at impersonating dickheadballs. I’m about to go back to work so only have time for one point.
A benefit of leaving the EU is honouring the results of the largest democratic exercise this country has ever undertaken and preventing a political vacuum that will be filled by extremist politicians who trade in the idea of working peoples voices being ignored.


RE: Nice to see the EU - ChamonixBaggie - 10-18-2019

Language like that isn't helpful and only serves to antagonise people.

I don't recall anyone saying that the EU is some ideal paragon of democracy (although the institution is more democratic than, for instance, the UK goverment) nevermind 'constantly being told'?

What is it you think the EU should've done with regards to Catalonia? If, as you seem to suggest, they should've overruled the Spanish government with regards to their justice policy then this does to run counter to your previous attitudes towards the EU and their 'interference' in national governments. If you could clarify your position it would help as I don't think your point is clear at the moment?


RE: Nice to see the EU - Borin' Baggie - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 12:45 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-15-2019, 08:33 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.

“Your ilk” are you able to describe “my ilk”’without resorting to stereotypes? I’d be interested in just what “my ilk”’is.
As it is, I have already written to my MP Andrew Mitchell asking him why the UK government hasn’t made a statement regarding Catalonia rather than just sitting their wondering.

Your ilk are people who seemingly want to blame everything on the EU even if they are independent to the issue or the complaint is contradictory to another complaint. Case in point being this exact issue.

And I've asked my MP, Jeremy Wright the exact same question as well as one asking for him to explain the Foreign Secretary's extremely unsatisfactory response to the issues with Hong Kong. But given that you seem to know that the complaints lie with the individual members of the EU (like the EU) not wanting to call out Spain and not the EU themselves based on you raising the issue to your MP, why are you blaming the EU for it?


RE: Nice to see the EU - Sotv - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 01:27 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 12:45 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-15-2019, 08:33 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.

“Your ilk” are you able to describe “my ilk”’without resorting to stereotypes? I’d be interested in just what “my ilk”’is.
As it is, I have already written to my MP Andrew Mitchell asking him why the UK government hasn’t made a statement regarding Catalonia rather than just sitting their wondering.

Your ilk are people who seemingly want to blame everything on the EU even if they are independent to the issue or the complaint is contradictory to another complaint. Case in point being this exact issue.

And I've asked my MP, Jeremy Wright the exact same question as well as one asking for him to explain the Foreign Secretary's extremely unsatisfactory response to the issues with Hong Kong. But given that you seem to know that the complaints lie with the individual members of the EU (like the EU) not wanting to call out Spain and not the EU themselves based on you raising the issue to your MP, why are you blaming the EU for it?
You really are scraping the barrel if you need to lie about what I have said. I haven’t blamed the EU for anything, would you like to point out where I have ? I’ve merely pointed to the fact that this case  illustrates that the EU are not the defenders of democracy many claim them to be. 
You’re very very wrong if you think I blame the EU for all our troubles. I do however think they are one of a multitude of negatives we could do without. I challenge you to find a post where I blame all this countries troubles on the EU. If you can I’ll state I was wrong, if you can’t, then you should apologise and admit you’re not the smart arse you think you are. Of course that will never happen because you and your ilk are as arrogant as you can get


RE: Nice to see the EU - Derek Hardballs - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 02:41 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 01:27 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 12:45 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-15-2019, 08:33 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.

“Your ilk” are you able to describe “my ilk”’without resorting to stereotypes? I’d be interested in just what “my ilk”’is.
As it is, I have already written to my MP Andrew Mitchell asking him why the UK government hasn’t made a statement regarding Catalonia rather than just sitting their wondering.

Your ilk are people who seemingly want to blame everything on the EU even if they are independent to the issue or the complaint is contradictory to another complaint. Case in point being this exact issue.

And I've asked my MP, Jeremy Wright the exact same question as well as one asking for him to explain the Foreign Secretary's extremely unsatisfactory response to the issues with Hong Kong. But given that you seem to know that the complaints lie with the individual members of the EU (like the EU) not wanting to call out Spain and not the EU themselves based on you raising the issue to your MP, why are you blaming the EU for it?
You really are scraping the barrel if you need to lie about what I have said. I haven’t blamed the EU for anything, would you like to point out where I have ? I’ve merely pointed to the fact that this case  illustrates that the EU are not the defenders of democracy many claim them to be. 
You’re very very wrong if you think I blame the EU for all our troubles. I do however think they are one of a multitude of negatives we could do without. I challenge you to find a post where I blame all this countries troubles on the EU. If you can I’ll state I was wrong, if you can’t, then you should apologise and admit you’re not the smart arse you think you are. Of course that will never happen because you and your ilk are as arrogant as you can get

Can you list your list of negatives?

I imagine your letter to your MP will be filed under pleb.


RE: Nice to see the EU - Borin' Baggie - 10-18-2019

(10-18-2019, 02:41 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 01:27 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(10-18-2019, 12:45 PM)Sotv Wrote:
(10-15-2019, 08:33 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Your ilk would have criticised the EU no matter what it did, either they turn a blind eye or they interfere in domestic matters.

If you actually gave a shit, you'd be wondering why the governments of the individual EU members (like the UK) have been silent on the matter.

“Your ilk” are you able to describe “my ilk”’without resorting to stereotypes? I’d be interested in just what “my ilk”’is.
As it is, I have already written to my MP Andrew Mitchell asking him why the UK government hasn’t made a statement regarding Catalonia rather than just sitting their wondering.

Your ilk are people who seemingly want to blame everything on the EU even if they are independent to the issue or the complaint is contradictory to another complaint. Case in point being this exact issue.

And I've asked my MP, Jeremy Wright the exact same question as well as one asking for him to explain the Foreign Secretary's extremely unsatisfactory response to the issues with Hong Kong. But given that you seem to know that the complaints lie with the individual members of the EU (like the EU) not wanting to call out Spain and not the EU themselves based on you raising the issue to your MP, why are you blaming the EU for it?
You really are scraping the barrel if you need to lie about what I have said. I haven’t blamed the EU for anything, would you like to point out where I have ? I’ve merely pointed to the fact that this case  illustrates that the EU are not the defenders of democracy many claim them to be. 
You’re very very wrong if you think I blame the EU for all our troubles. I do however think they are one of a multitude of negatives we could do without. I challenge you to find a post where I blame all this countries troubles on the EU. If you can I’ll state I was wrong, if you can’t, then you should apologise and admit you’re not the smart arse you think you are. Of course that will never happen because you and your ilk are as arrogant as you can get

This post is there for everyone to read right here. You're blaming the EU for not doing anything in Spain, despite knowing that they don't want to interfere in the domestic business of member states with the power over the issue lying with the other member states as evidenced by you emailing your MP. If you weren't blaming the EU then you wouldn't have brought them up. If you weren't blaming the EU for not interfering in a member states actions, may I ask what the purpose of you posting this thread is?

I seem also to remember very distinctly on a previous incarnation of this board before the servers went tits up that you blamed the EU for ECtHR rulings against the UK and the issues with the ECHR restricting UK domestic policy, despite the ECtHR having absolutely fuck all to do with the EU. That is clearly blaming the EU for something that they are independent of.

And the absolute gall of you accusing me of being arrogant while writing up that tripe. I'm going to file it under the same book where you randomly decided my criticism of an abhorrent statement by an MP in Parliament had something to do with Brexit and somehow that I was comparing leave voters to Nazis.