WBAUnofficial
Ratings...... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings...... (/showthread.php?tid=463)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Ratings...... - igorbalis - 02-12-2019

(02-12-2019, 10:54 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Johnstone 7

Holgate 5
Dawson 4
Tosin 4
Gibbs 5

Harper 7
Livermore 4
Johansen 5

Gayle 6
Rodriguez 6
Murphy 5

Barry 7.5
Hoolahan 6

Moore 5

Fans 3
Johnstone 6 kept us in the game with the save at 1-2
Holgate -3 being generous
Dawson 5 did ok
Tosin - 3 all over the shop.
Gibbs -4 woefull crossing
Harper 6 not at his best

Livermoore - useless 2

Johansen - has to do better 4

Gayle - 6 was never a pen, but ultimately got us a point

Rodriguez - more bothered with his poxy hair - 4

Murphy - send him back 3
Barry - 7 best player for us tonight 

Hoolahan -what does he contribute? 3

Lets hope mint aero is better than the other two loanees or we're f*cked

Worst performance (first half anyway) for a while - but why gift the opposition a goal start?? seriously think we need to change something, or we will be struggling to make the playoffs.


RE: Ratings...... - MancBaggie - 02-13-2019

(02-12-2019, 10:54 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Not far off Dumbo and Sw4

Johnstone 7.  Prob 7.5. Big save from Grabban

Holgate 5.  4.5. Brain dead and petulant - utterly negates his PL class
Dawson 4.   3. Miles below par.  Pathetic challenge at end for yellow
Tosin 4.       3. Far too many mistakes. Can’t carry him
Gibbs 5.       5.5. Fortunate at the end. Key outlet so needs to improve his final ball

Harper 7.    7.5. Best of a bad bunch tonight.  The only one who got a proper shot off
Livermore 4.  3. 3 Reds in 12 months and he has the gall to return in that shape. Embarrassing 
Johansen 5.   5.5. Good player who needs to get up to speed fast 

Gayle 6.         6.5 Not his fault he is shunted out wide.  His linkplay could improve 
Rodriguez 6.   6. Good pressure pen  - another game where his general play was untidy/ineffective 
Murphy 5.       4. Got goal but must improve in every aspect. Atrocious at times


Barry 7.5.      7. Has to start Saturday. Know how and control
Hoolahan 6.    5.5. Body just can’t do it.  Reduced to ineffective dinks that were easily defended 

Moore 5

Fans 3



RE: Ratings...... - Toby Jugg - 02-13-2019

Spot on SW4, spot on review.

Unfortunately.


RE: Ratings...... - albion_pigeon - 02-13-2019

Back to the drawing board for BD and GJ at home. Play players to their strengths.

This squad is good enough to get out of this league. Imagine what Hodgson would be doing with it. Harsh on BD I know, but some of the tactical naivety is mad, game after game.


RE: Ratings...... - SW4Baggie - 02-13-2019

(02-13-2019, 12:15 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Back to the drawing board for BD and GJ at home. Play players to their strengths.

This squad is good enough to get out of this league. Imagine what Hodgson would be doing with it. Harsh on BD I know, but some of the tactical naivety is mad, game after game.

In fairness I imagine results wouldn’t be too dissimilar if Roy was here.

We’d be organised and fast on the break away, but struggle to break teams down at home. We’d give less silly goals away but probably not have scored as many.


RE: Ratings...... - igorbalis - 02-13-2019

(02-13-2019, 12:21 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-13-2019, 12:15 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Back to the drawing board for BD and GJ at home. Play players to their strengths.

This squad is good enough to get out of this league. Imagine what Hodgson would be doing with it. Harsh on BD I know, but some of the tactical naivety is mad, game after game.

In fairness I imagine results wouldn’t be too dissimilar if Roy was here.

We’d be organised and fast on the break away, but struggle to break teams down at home. We’d give less silly goals away but probably not have scored as many.

I don't think this squad is good enough. Too many has been journeymen imvho.