WBAUnofficial
Defence - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Defence (/showthread.php?tid=43202)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Defence - Birdman1811 - 11-01-2026

It's a Championship defence. The players will make one or two mistakes a game, nothing any coach can do will stop that, it's why these players aren't in the Premier League. We have good shape generally, we stop most attacks quite well and can even with old pressure a fair bit. But there's a reason in most champ games, both teams score at least one, and with a high tempo meaning more passes go astray, we'll be more prime to those mistakes hurting us.

I'm not worried, I don't see a team, like under Mowbray, where the defence just isn't coached, we're just a championship team.


RE: Defence - Josh1873 - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 09:54 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-01-2026, 09:16 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: has come in for some criticism, but only 3 teams have a better goals conceded record, and they are all tied on 1 goal conceded less than us.

Do we make mistakes in defence, yes we do, everyone does, but generally I think we defend well as a team. Wolves and second half at Boro are perhaps the only occasions where I would say our defending fell significantly below the standard required.

If there was a weakness in the team it was in scoring goals, the last 4 games have seen an uptick in that department, but we remain the lowest scorers in the top 8, which probably shows how previous to the Wrexham game how much scoring was an issue.

My only issue with the defence is with one man down already, we are an injury and suspension from a real problem. But I think that's an issue the majority of clubs in the championship have.

Some criticism…. from Josh. Who is renowned for not having a fucking scooby doo about anything and pretending to be at the game, whilst posting minute by minute meltdowns on the match Fred. The big Bilbo Baggins.

You really are a petty, vile, and angry individual. Get a life.

(11-01-2026, 11:34 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-01-2026, 11:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not saying my opinion is right, but it's that - my opinion. Also, I'm not claiming to be some defensive expert, but just using my eyes and seeing the game how I do it feels like we're actually really well organised, but simultaneously just fuck up with silly goals conceded.

It's the team equivalent of Matt Carbon. Excellent for 85 mins, then have 5 mins where you just go AWOL!

Youre not wrong, Josh. We are not keeping enough clean sheets, which makes a decent defence pointless. But I think the problems are not where you might think. For example you pointed out styles not being close enough and MoL doing better etc. Styles did well and was close enough in fact to block Bowens shot and MOL had no chance after the deflection. 

IMO the problem came from sloppy play in CM and not getting the counter press right. Price, if anyone was a little to blame off the ball as he should have been more aggressive when the ball dropped in CM as he was facing the play. But after that if was rotten luck that Bowen got a deflection that whizzed passed MOL off his near post.

You're probably right, I'm just frustrated at seeing us concede silly goals when generally we're playing well. Clean sheets should always be a priority for any football club.

Yesterday's goal ultimately didn't cost us, but it came shortly after we scored, and was against the run of play. It's so frustrating.

It was literally the only negative part of the performance. But the wider issue of us conceeding soft goals has to be addressed.

(11-01-2026, 11:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's a Championship defence. The players will make one or two mistakes a game, nothing any coach can do will stop that, it's why these players aren't in the Premier League. We have good shape generally, we stop most attacks quite well and can even with old pressure a fair bit. But there's a reason in most champ games, both teams score at least one, and with a high tempo meaning more passes go astray, we'll be more prime to those mistakes hurting us.

I'm not worried, I don't see a team, like under Mowbray, where the defence just isn't coached, we're just a championship team.

I think there's a lot of truth to this, but it's mostly the same defence & GK that kept so many clean sheets at the back end of last season, so they're clearly capable of not conceeding, and being solid all game. I can't quite put my finger on why those same players suddenly can't keep a clean sheet at all? 

We're picking up points, and are overachieving results wise, the only frustration and complaint I have is how many preventable goals we're conceding. I am aware that all goals are preventable to some extent, but we seem to be conceeding a lot of goals where it's mainly down to switching off mentally, and not getting the basics right. It can definitely be tightened up a lot more. If we can increase the amount of clean sheets we keep, we shift from being a decent team, to a very good team. We're not far away at all, but it's the one area I want to see us improve on.


RE: Defence - Wednesburybaggie - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 11:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's a Championship defence. The players will make one or two mistakes a game, nothing any coach can do will stop that, it's why these players aren't in the Premier League. We have good shape generally, we stop most attacks quite well and can even with old pressure a fair bit. But there's a reason in most champ games, both teams score at least one, and with a high tempo meaning more passes go astray, we'll be more prime to those mistakes hurting us.

I'm not worried, I don't see a team, like under Mowbray, where the defence just isn't coached, we're just a championship team.

This in spades. If our players were error free they would be in the Premier league. It's the same with all the clubs here though. Not many defences will keep a multitude of clean sheets. Im happy enough that we are at the better end of the spectrum. I do think out defensive organisation could be better at defending corners though.


RE: Defence - WWHO - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 11:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not saying my opinion is right, but it's that - my opinion. Also, I'm not claiming to be some defensive expert, but just using my eyes and seeing the game how I do it feels like we're actually really well organised, but simultaneously just fuck up with silly goals conceded.

It's the team equivalent of Matt Carbon. Excellent for 85 mins, then have 5 mins where you just go AWOL!

I'd take your Matt Carbon and raise you a Darren Purse, who was the epitome of an 89 minute defender.


RE: Defence - Tom Joad 25 - 11-01-2026

It's not that the defence isn't decent. I believe the criticism came from the self inflicted wounds - at the custard bowl, and the 1st v Blackburn spring to mind.