![]() |
|
Women's Boxing - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Women's Boxing (/showthread.php?tid=38593) |
RE: Women's Boxing - GunsOfNavarone - 09-03-2025 Lady boxers love it in the ring. Official. RE: Women's Boxing - Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 07:43 AM)Squid Wrote:(09-03-2025, 07:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The difficulty in these situations is finding the hill to die on I am not trying the "Phelps Gambit", squid. I am trying to find the point where the governing bodies of sports around the world can restrict certain individuals access to competition. As somebody who has completed at world level in Martial arts, I understand more than most the devastating impact contact sports can have on individuals and the need to regulate competition accordingly. There are two main issues I see here in relation to 'genetic testing' being used instead of sex assigned at birth they are; Consistency - For this to be rolled out it would have to be done for any organised, elite level sport from early teens onwards as it is then that most intersex individuals begin to notice that their bodies are developing differently. This would not only be invasive it would be a huge logistical operation costing far more than most amateur sports can afford. If it wasn't conducted as a blanket approach you would then fall into the muddy waters of judging a persons level of 'femininity' based on societal standards of height, beauty and body type, messy indeed. Thresholds - What are the thresholds? I know you'll say it's the "Phelps Gambit" again. But a women with Swyer Syndrome and an XY chromosome, and one with congenital adrenal hyperplasia and an XX chromosome may have similar levels of sex hormones throughout puberty, and have similar advantages physically there after. You would never really know who had what chromosomes, unless we go down the route of what I explained above. As a Sports Scientist by trade I find this really interesting but as a former junior elite athlete I really appreciate competitive integrity and the safety of competitors. Tricky indeed. RE: Women's Boxing - Jacko - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 07:15 AM)Squid Wrote: I can't find the original thread, which is a shame as some of the comments have aged like milk, especially the one calling Angela Carini a "drama queen", but the Court of Arbitration for Sport have issued a press release stating that that Imane Khelif has filed an appeal stating that they should be allowed to participate in the World Boxing Championships without undergoing a genetic test. OG thread is gone which is a pity, I've checked back to August 2024, when the travesty of the gold medal match happened and it's not in my posts list any more. As expected it's all coming out in the wash. RE: Women's Boxing - Squid - 09-03-2025 As set out in the links provided, the testing is either a blood test or cheek swab. So not hugely invasive and not excessively expensive either. The alternative is women being punched in the face by people with male strength, either due to a disorder of sexual development or under previous IOC rules, which went on the information in someone's passport, because they actually were born and registered as male before changing gender. Generally, rules are not made around edge cases. They are made to protest the majority. In the vast, vast majority of cases there is clear, blue water between male and female sporting ability. Saying "Oh, but what about..?" to muddy the waters does not benefit women's sport. RE: Women's Boxing - Ted Maul - 09-03-2025 If she's previously registered and competed as a male then I'm not sure there is any further argument to say she should be allowed to compete in women's sport. Wasn't aware of some of this in my earlier postings, hence the questions. Every day is a school day. RE: Women's Boxing - Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 10:07 AM)Squid Wrote: As set out in the links provided, the testing is either a blood test or cheek swab. So not hugely invasive and not excessively expensive either. A blood test is invasive, Squid, a swab not much. But in terms of expense. It's not just the test, it's the admin, record keeping, GDPR, enforcement etc. For many amature sports it is completely unmanageable Whilst I completely agree that there are clear disparities between Men and Women across the board in terms of their athletic abilities and I wouldn't want the average Jenny being lamped in the face by an average John. The difficulty, and muddiness comes in the classification of sex. Sex isn't as binary as many believe and is in 3 classifications; genetic, gonadal and anatomic. Testosterone tends to be the thing that most focus on as during puberty, higher levels of testosterone is what leads to natural increased physical performance. But this doesnt completely lie in line with my point above about different conditions regardless of genetic differences. Bluntly speaking, when does a women become a man? Any line drawn is going to be arbitrary and up for debate and frankly our understanding of DSDs and intersex peoples sporting advantage is lacking. In terms of women sports, sorting out the non physiological stuff would be a better use of resource and effort. Driving more engagement, removing barriers to competition, increasing funding and media exposure. These will not only benefit all women in sport by decreasing the performance gap, but allow us to critically analyse and understand the effects of things like DSDs and other hormonal issues in isolation. That would allow better, more productive discussions and a more complete and rounded approach to policy making. (09-03-2025, 10:27 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If she's previously registered and competed as a male then I'm not sure there is any further argument to say she should be allowed to compete in women's sport. She hasn't Ted. Born, a women, lived as a women, competed as a women. But a genetic test in 2023 allegedly questioned her ability to compete based on 'Gender Eligibility Criteria'. There is no where near enough clarity and transparency about what type of test is being mandated and what the criterias are. That's the big issue. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/crlr8gp813ko Another decent article outlining the scientific difficulties policy makers are facing. RE: Women's Boxing - Squid - 09-03-2025 Lurker - you've been told what the test involves. It's not difficult. The fact that Khalef doesn't want the test is clear indication of what the test is for: chromosomes. If you have XY chromosomes, you will not be allowed to compete in female sports unless there is compelling evidence otherwise. And yes, we all know that there is massive variance in human physiology. Not everyone is born with one thumb and four fingers on each hand, yet I don't see anyone crying to glove manufacturers. Your original post spoke volumes. Concern for Imane Khelif, concern for the sports authorities. None whatsoever for the women who have lost out on medals and have been endangered. You can subsequently wave about whatever other credentials you choose. That omission speaks volumes. Either you want to protect women's sport for women, or you don't. In the latter case, you end up with women facing a male boxer and an Olympic women's 800m final where gold, silver and bronze all go to athletes with XY chromosomes (Rio 2016). Hence why the IAAF is also bringing in genetic testing Btw, the other competitors in that race were all called cry baby drama queens too. Nobody was concerned about them until it was far too late to make a difference. RE: Women's Boxing - Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 12:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Lurker - you've been told what the test involves. It's not difficult. Not sure my concerns for a women being excluded from competition and an organisation having to take such upsetting decisions is in anyway an indication of my lack of allyship towards women. In fact it couldn't be any further from the truth for me personally. I am a white ribbon ambassador in the campaign against violence towards women and girls now. Before that I was coach for the GB girls shotokan karate team amongst other things within martial arts. But, regarding the test, I am not talking about what the physical test is. I am dubious about the testing parameters, and whether it will actually protect women's competition in the way I, and I know you want. As I say, the body of scientific literature in this area isn't particularly robust at the moment so I wouldn't like to nail my colours to the mast with an opinion. Fwiw, if a governing body was to say. We are not allowing any person to compete in women's categories unless they are female, genetically, gonadal and anatomically and have current testosterone levels of below 5 nmol/L. I wouldn't particularly kick up a stink for the time being as it is a reasonable thing to do for competitive integrity. It does not however mean that it is the best course of action in the long run as it will likely stop XX chromosome people from competing too. RE: Women's Boxing - Squid - 09-03-2025 (09-03-2025, 12:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(09-03-2025, 12:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Lurker - you've been told what the test involves. It's not difficult. It clearly is when you prioritise those concerns over the wellbeing of other women. And no, I am not in the slightest bit surprised that you consider yourself a self-appointed ally to women. Unfortunately, actually being an ally to women requires more than wearing a particular colour ribbon. RE: Women's Boxing - Lurker#3 - 09-03-2025 I can't remember saying I did prioritise it. I was purely shining a light on the ongoing complexity behind the implementation of genetic based testing in sport and how it does effect outliers and the sporting organisations who work their cob off to provide as much access to sport to all people as possible. I think your inability to approach the issue in a rational, reasonable and balanced way means you could never be part of a solution. Nothing self appointed about my work on the white ribbon campaign, in fact, politically I disagree with much of the founders beliefs. I was selected by my colleagues most of whom are women because they view me as an ally. Your desire to paint me as the enemy is peculiar to be honest. But you continue to do you. |