WBAUnofficial
Just back, ratings. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just back, ratings. (/showthread.php?tid=36813)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Just back, ratings. - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-01-2025

(03-01-2025, 07:56 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Now is the time for Mowbray to show some balls and drop Wildsmith.

We are playing a very average six out of ten Champ keeper when we have an 8 out of 10 one with the potential to be as good as Palmer sat on the bench.

Football is about playing your best players not being kind to people.

Absolutely


RE: Just back, ratings. - Jerry - 03-01-2025

It seems to me that the goalkeeper is not picked by the manager but by the goalkeeping coach aka Bruce with Button. I would change to Griffiths but what do they see in training or is the risk of a new keeper to large at this stage.


RE: Just back, ratings. - SW4Baggie - 03-01-2025

(03-01-2025, 07:56 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(03-01-2025, 07:56 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Now is the time for Mowbray to show some balls and drop Wildsmith.

We are playing a very average six out of ten Champ keeper when we have an 8 out of 10 one with the potential to be as good as Palmer sat on the bench.

Football is about playing your best players not being kind to people.

Absolutely

Sorry but Griffith has shown nothing to suggest he’s an 8/10 Championship goalie - he has potential certainly, but he didn’t exactly inspire confidence in his appearances for us. Palmer’s return was a relief.

Yes Griffith was outstanding in League One but last season’s Golden Glove was Wildsmith.

I agree after today we should be considering Griffith, and I’d rather we gave a young player with a lot of potential priority over a player who has never really been trusted consistently as a number 1 at this level, but to say we have an 8/10 on Griffith just isn’t true.


RE: Just back, ratings. - tHEgLASSdOORS - 03-01-2025

I tend to think of it like this. Wildsmith has cost us 3 goals already that Palmer stops. Would Griffiths have at least equalled that or probably bettered it? Yes. Given he’s our future for the next 2-3 seasons at least, why aren’t we playing him and giving him the experience here and now when he’s at least as good as the bloke being picked in front of him (and better, if we are honest)

That’s my rationale and I can’t see the logic of persisting with a bloke who just doesn’t know when to come off his line and when to stay


RE: Just back, ratings. - Josh1873 - 03-01-2025

Wildsmith and Bartley, both culpable for the goal a 6? 

Give them both a 4, other than that, pretty much agree.


RE: Just back, ratings. - Beachboysbaggie - 03-01-2025

(03-01-2025, 05:00 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Wildo- 6 culpable for the opener, not troubled otherwise
Furgs-7 terrible defensively, great header earns us a point (the goal gets him a 7)
Heggo-6 bottled the challenge for the Leeds goal, several mistakes could of cost us
Barts-6 looked rusty, disappointing distribution 
Style-6 did a job both going forward and defensively, nothing spectacular 
Mows-6 quiet game, poor set pieces. 
Swift-7 great assist, unlucky not to score, tired towards the end 
MJ-7 caused Leeds trouble every time he got the ball
Price-7 looks better out wide than in the middle
AA- 6 huffed and puffed, should of scored 
Subs
Diang-6 didn’t improve us
Grant-7 looked dangerous, why doesn’t he start? 
Dike-6 tried hard, needs to get up to speed
Fellows-6 see Diang, not sure what’s up with him, seriously out of form.

TM-Got it right.

Marks (for clarification)
Everyone starts with a 6, assists, goals, clean sheets move you up a mark, anything detrimental moves you down a mark.

About as dangerous as John Inman


RE: Just back, ratings. - Vinebaggie - 03-01-2025

(03-01-2025, 11:13 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(03-01-2025, 05:00 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Wildo- 6 culpable for the opener, not troubled otherwise
Furgs-7 terrible defensively, great header earns us a point (the goal gets him a 7)
Heggo-6 bottled the challenge for the Leeds goal, several mistakes could of cost us
Barts-6 looked rusty, disappointing distribution 
Style-6 did a job both going forward and defensively, nothing spectacular 
Mows-6 quiet game, poor set pieces. 
Swift-7 great assist, unlucky not to score, tired towards the end 
MJ-7 caused Leeds trouble every time he got the ball
Price-7 looks better out wide than in the middle
AA- 6 huffed and puffed, should of scored 
Subs
Diang-6 didn’t improve us
Grant-7 looked dangerous, why doesn’t he start? 
Dike-6 tried hard, needs to get up to speed
Fellows-6 see Diang, not sure what’s up with him, seriously out of form.

TM-Got it right.

Marks (for clarification)
Everyone starts with a 6, assists, goals, clean sheets move you up a mark, anything detrimental moves you down a mark.

About as dangerous as John Inman

He’s dangerous because he bottles tackles, falls over and loses the ball in bad areas, not sure why we take off players who are doing well to bring Diangana on?


RE: Just back, ratings. - Dumbo - 03-01-2025

(03-01-2025, 11:21 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(03-01-2025, 11:13 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(03-01-2025, 05:00 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Wildo- 6 culpable for the opener, not troubled otherwise
Furgs-7 terrible defensively, great header earns us a point (the goal gets him a 7)
Heggo-6 bottled the challenge for the Leeds goal, several mistakes could of cost us
Barts-6 looked rusty, disappointing distribution 
Style-6 did a job both going forward and defensively, nothing spectacular 
Mows-6 quiet game, poor set pieces. 
Swift-7 great assist, unlucky not to score, tired towards the end 
MJ-7 caused Leeds trouble every time he got the ball
Price-7 looks better out wide than in the middle
AA- 6 huffed and puffed, should of scored 
Subs
Diang-6 didn’t improve us
Grant-7 looked dangerous, why doesn’t he start? 
Dike-6 tried hard, needs to get up to speed
Fellows-6 see Diang, not sure what’s up with him, seriously out of form.

TM-Got it right.

Marks (for clarification)
Everyone starts with a 6, assists, goals, clean sheets move you up a mark, anything detrimental moves you down a mark.

About as dangerous as John Inman

He’s dangerous because he bottles tackles, falls over and loses the ball in bad areas, not sure why we take off players who are doing well to bring Diangana on?

Who played the through ball to set Fellows free towards the end of the game?


RE: Just back, ratings. - Sliced - 03-02-2025

(03-01-2025, 05:00 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Wildo- 6 culpable for the opener, not troubled otherwise
Furgs-7 terrible defensively, great header earns us a point (the goal gets him a 7)
Heggo-6 bottled the challenge for the Leeds goal, several mistakes could of cost us
Barts-6 looked rusty, disappointing distribution 
Style-6 did a job both going forward and defensively, nothing spectacular 
Mows-6 quiet game, poor set pieces. 
Swift-7 great assist, unlucky not to score, tired towards the end 
MJ-7 caused Leeds trouble every time he got the ball
Price-7 looks better out wide than in the middle
AA- 6 huffed and puffed, should of scored 
Subs
Diang-6 didn’t improve us
Grant-7 looked dangerous, why doesn’t he start? 
Dike-6 tried hard, needs to get up to speed
Fellows-6 see Diang, not sure what’s up with him, seriously out of form.

TM-Got it right.

Marks (for clarification)
Everyone starts with a 6, assists, goals, clean sheets move you up a mark, anything detrimental moves you down a mark.

Agree for the most part. Could arguably give Heggem and Price an extra point. 

Good performance overall. We were a Bartley/Wildsmith fuck up away from a massive 3 points, but overall much more promising from Mowbray.


RE: Just back, ratings. - 1952 - 03-02-2025

Heggam deserves credit for his part in our goal, he took out the defender marking Furlong. Mowbray or his set piece coach deserves credit for targeting the back post.
Swift should take some blame for not winning by missing his chance.
Gutsy performance against a team most of us thought we would lose, especially going 1 down so early.