![]() |
|
What the UK could learn from Ireland - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: What the UK could learn from Ireland (/showthread.php?tid=33478) |
RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Borin' Baggie - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 10:41 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It's entirely consistent with corporate tax simplification, reducing reliefs and lowering the rate to say, 15% which is the floor in the OECD agreement. Unless GDP growth hits 2% corporation tax cannot go below 21% and we'd need to hit 2.2% to go below 20% (assuming no other tax revenue cuts) even accounting for simplification of rates and allowances. Sure, that's less than the current 25% but it's not going to entice any businesses to set up here vs our own tax havens or Ireland/Luxembourg/Netherlands. Also, that doesn't resolve regulatory barriers caused by not being in the customs union and single market. The only part of the UK this would work is Northern Ireland but it would involve significant fiscal freedoms to be devolved that Treasury will never grant, and it will have a net impact on the Exchequer for the UK as a whole affecting budgets in GB. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - baggy1 - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 11:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-26-2024, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years. Ffs, I tried not to go into the consumer credit B2B definitions, AML regulation clampdown and the information commissioner increase in monitoring. FS firms are shying away from domicile because of the CC interpretations. If there was any industry that disproves your point, it’s FS. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Protheroe - 04-26-2024 I'm sure you'd like to think that's a smoking gun rather than a corporate tax rate half of the UK's, but I'm afraid I don't agree with you regardless of your workplace and experience. I'm also delighted to hear you're coming round to my view on the over regulation of financial services, and professional services in general. The UK is in danger of killing the golden goose here too. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - baggy1 - 04-26-2024 The UK already has. The international organisation I work for has stopped using the UK for its x-border deals. Your inexperience in global trends shows up every time you post I’m afraid. Regulation is a global matter now and if the UK bucks the trend and gets rid of AML regs, data protection laws and consumer credit protection the we would rapidly see trade disappear quicker than someone could say Brexit bonus. Your binary view of the world keeps on showing how uninformed you are. Have a look at the total revenue from corp tax in Ireland and then work out how much that would increase the tax revenue for the UK if every single company upped and left Ireland. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Protheroe - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 02:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The UK already has. The international organisation I work for has stopped using the UK for its x-border deals. Your inexperience in global trends shows up every time you post I’m afraid. Regulation is a global matter now and if the UK bucks the trend and gets rid of AML regs, data protection laws and consumer credit protection the we would rapidly see trade disappear quicker than someone could say Brexit bonus. I think you're missing the point. At least your consistent. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - baggy1 - 04-26-2024 You have a simple view of business based on a very limited experience unfortunately. Your binary world view shows up each time you post. Brexit has fucked any chance of companies coming to the UK that aren’t already here. Your constant need to argue with people in their field of work is embarrassing- maybe you could post a podcast to prove you were right all along. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Ossian - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 09:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah 5M population against 65M is a great comparison. We should look at the Seychelles for their tax schemes, that’s bound to work as well Indeed: nor is the ROI a post-industrial economy to anything like the extent of the UK; not even Scotland and Wales in isolation would be valid comparators. This idea that the UK can become some kind of offshore Luxembourg is just fatuous. Not that you should take this as an acknowledgement of your qualifications or expertise.. RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Hudds1 - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 11:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-26-2024, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years. HMRC uses the term "footprint" to deal with the complexities of determining established and non-established businesses. I now use the term rather than try to explain what it would mean in legal parlance and to get into the statutory law and determinative complex case law. I can show you my qualifications per Bored protocol mandate - where are yours? RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - Protheroe - 04-26-2024 Sorry? IS there a difference between "footprint" and "domicile"? RE: What the UK could learn from Ireland - baggy1 - 04-26-2024 (04-26-2024, 03:56 PM)Ossian Wrote:(04-26-2024, 09:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah 5M population against 65M is a great comparison. We should look at the Seychelles for their tax schemes, that’s bound to work as well Med me loffWe actually parent our Lux treasury through our Irish entity. |