WBAUnofficial
What formation would you play. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: What formation would you play. (/showthread.php?tid=23881)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: What formation would you play. - Shabby Russian - 01-30-2022

Chelsea are an example of a team that can ay 343 well, but then they have players of the quality of Chillwell, James and Alonso to play at wing back.

And even then, not sure this system doesn't hold them back a little, when compared to Man City and Liverpo who deploy a back 4.


RE: What formation would you play. - Ant74 - 01-30-2022

Any one but what we do now!


RE: What formation would you play. - ElbowGrease1973 - 01-30-2022

It really doesn't matter what formation we deploy with Val in charge, we don't keep the ball, and just lob it aimlessly forward.

Can't believe there's been no news as yet about his position. It really is untenable now. If he's in charge for the next game, it's a dereliction of duty by the owners.


RE: What formation would you play. - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 04:53 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: SJ
O’Shea Ajayi Barley Townsend

          TGH Livermore

Phillips  Robinson.  Diangana

              DK

I know I’ve dropped Grant our leading scorer but he offers very little in open play and has one trick.  Maybe he can come on in the 60th minute…

And Birdman will put his fist through the screen at O’Shea at RB as he is our best centre half.  He can also actually play RB and I’d rather these than Fulromg playing.

Maybe Diang right side and Grant left side but there’s not much else I’d change without new players.

You've obviously forgotten how shite Ajayi can be. Led Zep's manager used to say "Silence makes legends". Ajayi gets better each time he doesn't play.


RE: What formation would you play. - Bob Fossil - 01-30-2022

People can defend 343 all they like by saying it works here or there, but, the fact is, it hasn't worked here for months and that combined with the fact that Val has NEVER tried anything else, is the reason he should go.
The truth is, the best formation, is the one that best suits the players you have and that is where Val has failed miserably.

Personally, I think 433 would best suit these players, but it's hard to be sure as we've seen nothing but 343 all season.


RE: What formation would you play. - Lurker#3 - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 05:42 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People can defend 343 all they like by saying it works here or there, but, the fact is, it hasn't worked here for months and that combined with the fact that Val has NEVER tried anything else, is the reason he should go.
The truth is, the best formation, is the one that best suits the players you have and that is where Val has failed miserably.

Personally, I think 433 would best suit these players, but it's hard to be sure as we've seen nothing but 343 all season.

If youre primary and/or only focus is to get success this week  month or season. 

Not if you want to implement a new philosophy and culture and require strong and consistent leadership.


RE: What formation would you play. - MassDebater - 01-30-2022

I was going to say 4-4-2 and then expected to be called a dinosaur or a cunt out his mind, but looks like I'm not alone in that thought after all.

I'd say 4-4-2 as a base, switching to 3-5-2 or even 3-4-3 as and when applicable. I'm all for being fluid.


RE: What formation would you play. - Bob Fossil - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 05:45 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 05:42 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People can defend 343 all they like by saying it works here or there, but, the fact is, it hasn't worked here for months and that combined with the fact that Val has NEVER tried anything else, is the reason he should go.
The truth is, the best formation, is the one that best suits the players you have and that is where Val has failed miserably.

Personally, I think 433 would best suit these players, but it's hard to be sure as we've seen nothing but 343 all season.

If youre primary and/or only focus is to get success this week  month or season. 

Not if you want to implement a new philosophy and culture and require strong and consistent leadership.

Of course that's our primary focus.
Long term plans are a nice idea mate but are purely fanciful. The only way a manager stays 4 years is by achieving rank mediocrity.
With our status and finance, a successful manager will be poached and a crap one will be sacked. Same with players.

The only way you can implement a longer term plan is to have money to burn to offset poor decisions (Villa), which we don't. We live hand to mouth so cut our cloth accordingly.

Val won't take us up so we need to find someone who can. Good news is, he's not a tough act to follow.

(01-30-2022, 05:57 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I was going to say 4-4-2 and then expected to be called a dinosaur or a cunt out his mind, but looks like I'm not alone in that thought after all.

I'd say 4-4-2 as a base, switching to 3-5-2 or even 3-4-3 as and when applicable. I'm all for being fluid.
Fucking heretic!
Get the pitchforks!


RE: What formation would you play. - Seat109 - 01-30-2022

Think 4-3-2-1 would be worth trying, nobody at the club capable of playing wing back effectively and the midfield 2 totally ineffective in Val’s ‘style’, can’t play 2 up front as we don’t have 2 central strikers so perm 2 from Diangana/Phillips/Robinson/Grant with Carroll ( for now) centrally, can’t be any worse.


RE: What formation would you play. - Lurker#3 - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 06:30 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 05:45 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 05:42 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: People can defend 343 all they like by saying it works here or there, but, the fact is, it hasn't worked here for months and that combined with the fact that Val has NEVER tried anything else, is the reason he should go.
The truth is, the best formation, is the one that best suits the players you have and that is where Val has failed miserably.

Personally, I think 433 would best suit these players, but it's hard to be sure as we've seen nothing but 343 all season.

If youre primary and/or only focus is to get success this week  month or season. 

Not if you want to implement a new philosophy and culture and require strong and consistent leadership.

Of course that's our primary focus.
Long term plans are a nice idea mate but are purely fanciful. The only way a manager stays 4 years is by achieving rank mediocrity.
With our status and finance, a successful manager will be poached and a crap one will be sacked. Same with players.

The only way you can implement a longer term plan is to have money to burn to offset poor decisions (Villa), which we don't. We live hand to mouth so cut our cloth accordingly.

Val won't take us up so we need to find someone who can. Good news is, he's not a tough act to follow.


Thats where I just fundamentally disagree mate. 

I have no desire to watch us in the prem. In fact I wouldn't care if we got relegated again aside from the fact that I enjoy to see us win. The only reason I have liked us in the orem in recent years was to ensure I jad a stream. With I follow I could watch us in league 2. 

I do however, enjoy seeing us have an identity that I can relate do and support. I enjoy other people giving my club praise for its integrity and ambition. 

In summary I would rather watch us in league 2 with a great match, consistent identity, producing our own players who may go on to bigger and better things. Challenging for relative success at what ever level were at, but doing it the right way. Than watching us clinging onto a miserable existence in the greed league whilst bouncing from short term fire fighter to the next.