![]() |
|
St Pauli - an interesting read. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: St Pauli - an interesting read. (/showthread.php?tid=10888) |
RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Llandudno Baggie - 06-23-2020 (06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns. That's interesting. Talk about bad timing. What a pity, and I wonder what would have happened if a similar situation occurred now. Having said that I can't fathom out the enduring appeal of Celtic - other than "passion" - or am I missing something? RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Black Lake Victoria - 06-24-2020 (06-23-2020, 09:12 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote:(06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns. Having sat in the Celtic end at the Wembley Cup 4 team tournament a few years ago neither can I RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - UCEbaggie - 06-24-2020 (06-23-2020, 09:53 AM)Old Stroller Wrote: Back in 1991 the organisers of St Pauli's fan clubs, high up in the clubs hierarchy, came over to the UK for a cultural exchange visit, in an attempt to marry up their ethos with like minded clubs over here. I was involved as I had connections with both Albion and St Pauli, and invited them to a game at The Hawthorns. I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli. Celtic are, to an extent, traditionally more anti-establishment. Whether you agree with them or not. Rangers and the protestant faith were, historically, firmly part of the establushment in Scotland. I also wouldn't understate the impact of some of Celtic's fanbase being supportive of the IRA. To a lot of people outside Britain there is a rather romantic view of the IRA as freedom fighters against imperial opression and a core of the IRA in the post war period were also marxists - so a left wing link again RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Gzbaggy - 06-24-2020 Which clubs do you regard as having a "left leaning" fanbase? RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Old Stroller - 06-24-2020 (06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli. I'd agree with all of that. Most of our support back then, and probably now, are conservative with a small c, and as you say it was always unlikely that they would find common ground with their more radical approach. I managed to at least get them to check us out in preference to the other local teams, which was a small victory, as I'd have been gutted if they had ended up affiliating themselves with Villa or Wolves. RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - HeavyWoollenBaggie - 06-24-2020 (06-23-2020, 09:08 AM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Great article and the stand photo!!! Needs a second tier FFSs, they sell out every week !! RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Tom Joad - 06-24-2020 (06-24-2020, 12:29 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:This is true but surprisingly (to me anyway), a few years ago the results of a "who's your second team" survey at Albion had Celtic comfortably as the winners. Actually they genuinely were my second team as a kid, Catholic school and all that, but I find the overt politics of Celtic fans a proper turn off and can't be bothered with them now. Obviously my second team these days is wolves.(06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli. (One part of this post is a lie). RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Baggie_Nick - 06-24-2020 Loads of St Pauli stickers along the canal in Tipton. Bizarre! RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - 4-hero - 06-24-2020 (06-24-2020, 06:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:(06-24-2020, 12:29 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:This is true but surprisingly (to me anyway), a few years ago the results of a "who's your second team" survey at Albion had Celtic comfortably as the winners.(06-24-2020, 10:30 AM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I'm not surprised Stroller. This isn't intended as criticism: I'd describe our 'core' fanbase as being rather more to the right than the left on social issues and more nationalist than internationalist in outlook. And as I say, really not intended as a criticism, just a general observation which I think would make us incompatabile with Sankt Pauli. I think you must have dreamed that Tom, we all know our second team is Villa judging by the amount of posts on here about them. RE: St Pauli - an interesting read. - Ted Maul - 06-25-2020 (06-24-2020, 12:16 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Which clubs do you regard as having a "left leaning" fanbase? Liverpool and Everton, Celtic. Can't think of any others off the top of my head sadly. |